Home / Current Issue / Paper 1725230
Assessment of Value Engineering as A Strategic Tool for Cost Optimisation in Construction Project Delivery: A Case Study of a Two-Storey Commercial Complex
Subject area: Science,Engineering and Technology · Area of research: Construction Project Management
DOI: 10.64388/ire1725230
Abstract
Architects and other professionals in the architecture, engineering, and construction industries encounter numerous problems related to on-time and on-budget project delivery. Project failure and delays in developing countries such as Nigeria result from inefficient use and disposal of construction resources and materials, design deficiencies, and inadequate communication and coordination among project team members. This paper presents and evaluates a framework integrating 5D BIM and the Value Engineering Job Plan process to enhance value and reduce costs and time and improve communication and coordination during all phases of a project's life cycle. A mixed-method research design was used to conduct a quantitative survey of built environment professionals in Oyo State, Nigeria (N = 43 out of 50 completed survey questionnaires distributed, an 86.00% response rate), and a quantitative 5D BIM-VE case study of the completed Two-Storey Multipurpose Commercial Complex project (1,770 m²) on Secretariat-University College Hospital (UCH) Road in Ibadan, Nigeria. Survey methods included mean item rating and relative importance indexes. Orion BIM software data were analyzed at various stages of the VE Job Plan process (including Information, Function Analysis, Creativity, Evaluation, Development, and Proposal) related to the case project. Empirical studies show that individual professionals are generally knowledgeable about VE (mean knowledge index = 3.930, RII = 0.786) but that VE is underutilized by organizations due to a lack of VE skills in the organization (mean institutionalization index = 2.930, RII = 0.586) and other cultural factors inhibiting VE adoption (RII = 0.809). The key factors promoting VE adoption are management support (RII = 0.865) and VE skills (RII = 0.851). Case studies indicate that the major cost components for a project included Sub- and Superstructures (30.00%; ₦56,556,960), Doors, Windows, Wall Cladding, and Cutting Walls (28.00%; ₦52,786,496), and MEP (20.00%; ₦37,704,640). Floor slabs accounted for 49.37% (255.259 m³) of the total structural concrete volume of 516.998 m³. Replacing solid slabs and 225 mm sandcrete blocks with waffle or ribbed slabs and 150 mm lightweight blocks and replacing standard glazing with composite glass-aluminium curtain walling raised the weighted criteria score from 85 to 87 points and reduced the project cost from ₦188,523,200 to ₦161,140,300, a savings of ₦26,828,646, or 14.30% of the initial construction cost and up to 15.00% of total lifecycle costs, and saved 15% of the project time without compromising structural integrity or safety.
Keywords
Value engineering (VE), building information modelling (BIM), construction schedule, cost control, VE and BIM integration
References
[1] Abanda FH, Vidalakis C, Oti AH (2015). BIM and sustainability in construction projects: A review of BIM capabilities. International Journal of Building Pathology and Adaptation, 33(2), 126–148.
[2] Aduze OC (2014). A study of the prospects and challenges of value engineering in construction projects in Delta and Edo States of Nigeria. MSc Thesis, Nnamdi Azikiwe University, Awka.
[3] Akinola AO, Potts KF, Ndekugri IE (2022). Integrating Building Information Modelling and Value Engineering for construction cost optimization. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 148(4), 1–15.
[4] Al-Gahtani KS (2022). Comprehensive value engineering framework for building construction projects using BIM. Journal of Asian Architecture and Building Engineering, 21(5), 1924–1940.
[5] Amade B, Amaeshi UF, Ubani EC, Okorocha KA (2015). Project cost control practices in the Nigerian construction industry. International Journal of Engineering and Technical Research, 3(4), 120–127.
[6] Amoah K, Wao J (2023). Building information modeling and value engineering for project schedule and cost control. EasyChair Preprint. doi:10.29007/xw53
[7] Anyanwu CI (2013). Project cost control in the Nigerian construction industry. International Journal of Engineering Science Invention, 2(12), 65–71.
[8] Attard PM, Rane NL (2016). Application of Value Engineering in commercial building projects. International Journal of Latest Trends in Engineering and Technology (IJLTET), 6(3), 234–241.
[9] Aya Hasan A (2017). A framework for value engineering methodology application using building information modelling (BIM). Master's Thesis, The Islamic University of Gaza.
[10] Azhar S (2011). Building Information Modeling (BIM): Trends, benefits, risks, and challenges for the AEC industry. Leadership and Management in Engineering, 11(3), 241–252.
[11] Baarimah AO, Alaloul WS, Liew MS, Al-Aidrous AHMH, Alawag AM, Musarat MA (2021). Integration of building information modeling (BIM) and value engineering in construction projects: A bibliometric analysis. In: 2021 Third International Sustainability and Resilience Conference: Climate Change. IEEE, pp. 362–367. doi:10.1109/IEEECONF53624.2021.9668045
[12] Demirdöğen G, Diren NS, Aladağ H, Işık Z (2021). Lean based maturity framework integrating value, BIM and big data analytics: Evidence from AEC industry. Sustainability, 13(18), 10029. doi:10.3390/su131810029
[13] US Department of Defense (2006). Contractor's Guide to Value Engineering (Version 2.1). Washington, DC: US Department of Defense.
[14] Ewa UE (2013). Root causes of project abandonment in tertiary institutions in Nigeria. International Business Research, 6(11), 149–159.
[15] Galipogullari SA (2013). Application of Value Engineering in construction. Journal of Traffic and Transportation Engineering, 1(1), 39–48.
[16] Jaewook L, et al. (2020). BIM-based life-cycle cost analysis in early building design stages. Automation in Construction, 112, 103089.
[17] Kelly J, Male S, Graham D (2014). Value Management of Construction Projects (2nd ed.). Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell.
[18] Khaled AAA, Pandey RK (2016). Concept of Value Engineering in construction industry. International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR), 5(4), 1234–1239.
[19] Kolo BA, Ibrahim AD (2010). Value management: How adoptable is it in the Nigerian construction industry? In: Proceedings of the West Africa Built Environment Research (WABER) Conference, pp. 653–663.
[20] Lai NK (2006). Value management in construction industry. MSc Dissertation, Universiti Teknologi Malaysia.
[21] Lee J, Na S (2018). Investigation of practitioners' perceptions for developing Building Information Modelling (BIM)-based value analysis model. International Journal of Civil Engineering and Technology (IJCIET), 9(1), 301–313.
[22] Liang Y (2012). Value engineering application in construction project management. In: International Conference on Industrial and Electronics Engineering.
[23] Odeyinka HA (2006). The role of the quantity surveyor in value management. In: 22nd Biennial Conference of the Nigerian Institute of Quantity Surveyors (NIQS).
[24] Oke AE, Ogunsemi DR (2011). Value management in the Nigerian construction industry: Militating factors and the perceived benefits. In: Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Advances in Engineering and Technology, pp. 353–359.
[25] Philip D, Mansfield S, Udo-Inyang P (2006). Application of value engineering within the construction industry. In: ASC Proceedings of the 42nd Annual Conference. Colorado State University.
[26] SAVE International (2020). Value Methodology Standard and Body of Knowledge. SAVE International.
[27] Sharma A, Belokar RM (2012). Achieving success through value engineering: A case study. In: Proceedings of the World Congress on Engineering and Computer Science 2012 (WCECS 2012), Vol. II. San Francisco, USA.
[28] Zhang Y, et al. (2022). Automated multi-criteria decision support system for BIM-integrated value engineering. Journal of Computing in Civil Engineering, 36(3), 04022008.
How to cite this paper
@article{1725230,
author = {Adeyele, Tayo Mathew, Coker, Akinwale O},
title = {Assessment of Value Engineering as A Strategic Tool for Cost Optimisation in Construction Project Delivery: A Case Study of a Two-Storey Commercial Complex},
journal = {Iconic Research And Engineering Journals},
year = {2026},
volume = {10},
number = {5},
pages = {3142-3155},
issn = {2456-8880},
url = {https://www.irejournals.com/formatedpaper/1725230.pdf},
abstract = {Architects and other professionals in the architecture, engineering, and construction industries encounter numerous problems related to on-time and on-budget project delivery. Project failure and delays in developing countries such as Nigeria result from inefficient use and disposal of construction resources and materials, design deficiencies, and inadequate communication and coordination among project team members. This paper presents and evaluates a framework integrating 5D BIM and the Value Engineering Job Plan process to enhance value and reduce costs and time and improve communication and coordination during all phases of a project's life cycle. A mixed-method research design was used to conduct a quantitative survey of built environment professionals in Oyo State, Nigeria (N = 43 out of 50 completed survey questionnaires distributed, an 86.00% response rate), and a quantitative 5D BIM-VE case study of the completed Two-Storey Multipurpose Commercial Complex project (1,770 m²) on Secretariat-University College Hospital (UCH) Road in Ibadan, Nigeria. Survey methods included mean item rating and relative importance indexes. Orion BIM software data were analyzed at various stages of the VE Job Plan process (including Information, Function Analysis, Creativity, Evaluation, Development, and Proposal) related to the case project. Empirical studies show that individual professionals are generally knowledgeable about VE (mean knowledge index = 3.930, RII = 0.786) but that VE is underutilized by organizations due to a lack of VE skills in the organization (mean institutionalization index = 2.930, RII = 0.586) and other cultural factors inhibiting VE adoption (RII = 0.809). The key factors promoting VE adoption are management support (RII = 0.865) and VE skills (RII = 0.851). Case studies indicate that the major cost components for a project included Sub- and Superstructures (30.00%; ₦56,556,960), Doors, Windows, Wall Cladding, and Cutting Walls (28.00%; ₦52,786,496), and MEP (20.00%; ₦37,704,640). Floor slabs accounted for 49.37% (255.259 m³) of the total structural concrete volume of 516.998 m³. Replacing solid slabs and 225 mm sandcrete blocks with waffle or ribbed slabs and 150 mm lightweight blocks and replacing standard glazing with composite glass-aluminium curtain walling raised the weighted criteria score from 85 to 87 points and reduced the project cost from ₦188,523,200 to ₦161,140,300, a savings of ₦26,828,646, or 14.30% of the initial construction cost and up to 15.00% of total lifecycle costs, and saved 15% of the project time without compromising structural integrity or safety.},
keywords = {Value engineering (VE), building information modelling (BIM), construction schedule, cost control, VE and BIM integration},
month = {November},
doi = {https://doi.org/10.64388/ire1725230}
}