Cost Management
Implementing Target Costing in Small and Medium Business Units in India: A Market-Back Design and Cost-Gap Closure Case
Department of Management Studies, Ballari Institute of Technology & Management, Ballari, Karnataka, India
Published November 2026
Abstract
Indian small and medium business units increasingly face price-sensitive buyers, input-cost volatility and pressure to maintain acceptable quality. Yet many firms continue to set prices by adding a mark-up to accumulated production costs. This paper examines how target costing can reverse that logic: a credible market price and required profit determine an allowable cost before the product or service is finalised. Drawing on established scholarship and newly checked 2025–2026 Indian MSME policy evidence, it develops a transparent, constructed case of a small metal-products manufacturer launching a modular storage rack. The case traces market-price selection, a 15% operating-profit objective, component-level cost gaps, value engineering, supplier negotiation, pilot quality checks and sensitivity testing. With an assumed net realisation of ₹2,400 per rack, target cost is ₹2,040 against an initial estimated cost of ₹2,280, creating a ₹240 gap. A costed improvement package reduces expected cost to ₹2,030 without assuming a quality downgrade. The resulting ₹370 contribution before tax and finance charges is a modelled outcome, not observed company performance. The paper proposes a staged 90-day implementation framework and interprets the managerial implications for resource-constrained Indian firms. The contribution lies in offering a replicable management-accounting decision protocol while clearly separating observed public evidence from scenario assumptions.
Keywords: Target costing; Indian MSMEs; strategic cost management; value engineering; supplier collaboration; cost-gap analysis; affordable product design
1Introduction
The economics of a small factory often begins with a difficult conversation: the customer has a price in mind, while the owner knows what raw material, labour, electricity and transport actually cost. In a highly competitive market the buyer may simply turn to another producer when the quoted price rises. Target costing treats this situation as a design question rather than a last-minute discounting exercise. Managers ask what the customer will pay, how much profit is required and what production system could deliver the promised function within that limit.
India offers a compelling setting. Official public releases in 2026 report that micro, small and medium enterprises contribute around 31.1% of GDP and 35.4% of manufacturing output, while current registration counts run into several crore enterprises (PIB, 2026a, 2026b). These are sector-wide context figures, not evidence that target costing is widely adopted. For smaller units, the practical challenge is to translate a concept often associated with large automotive companies into a simple spreadsheet, team discussion and documented product launch decision.
2Conceptual foundations and literature review
Target costing starts with an externally anchored sales price and subtracts a required profit. In contrast, conventional cost-plus pricing begins with estimated or incurred cost and adds a mark-up. The formula is simple, but its managerial significance is profound: purchasing, engineering, sales, production and accounting must reconcile the customer’s expectations before costs become locked in.
Kato (1993) described target costing as an early-stage, life-cycle oriented management process rather than merely an accounting formula. Tani et al. (1994) showed that Japanese target-cost management combined cost objectives with quality, delivery, product development and supplier cooperation. Cooper and Slagmulder (1997) foregrounded value engineering and design choices, highlighting the need to manage costs before production routines become fixed.
Dekker and Smidt (2003), in a survey of Dutch listed manufacturing firms, found that 19 of 32 respondents reported practices resembling target costing. Their sample is not representative of Indian MSMEs, yet it demonstrates that target costing can occur outside its Japanese origins. Ellram (2006) observed the importance of purchasing, early supplier involvement and cross-functional activity in 11 US organisational cases. Ibusuki and Kaminski (2007) integrated value engineering into concept, project and validation stages in an automotive development case.
Ansari, Bell and Okano (2006) conceptualised target costing as an important strategic-cost-management approach but emphasised continuing questions about its organisational processes and outcomes. Roffia, Benavides and Carrilero (2024) found persistent barriers to formal cost accounting in SMEs, reinforcing the need for simpler tools and management commitment. These studies support transferability of the principles; they do not establish measured Indian SME adoption rates or causal profit gains. Table 1 summarises how each source informs the present case.
| Source | Contribution to this case | Caution for transfer |
|---|---|---|
| Kato (1993) | Early design and life-cycle cost discipline | Different industrial setting |
| Tani et al. (1994) | Joint cost/quality/delivery goals | Predominantly Japanese firms |
| Dekker & Smidt (2003) | Adoption beyond Japan | Listed Dutch manufacturers |
| Ellram (2006) | Purchasing and supplier participation | 11 US cases |
| Ibusuki & Kaminski (2007) | Value engineering as closing mechanism | Automotive product case |
| Roffia et al. (2024) | SME cost-accounting constraints | Not India-specific |
2.1Strategic cost management linkage
Target costing works best alongside activity-based cost identification for overhead drivers, lean process improvement to remove waste, kaizen for continued savings after launch and life-cycle costing for warranty and disposal obligations. No technique should be presented as a substitute for engineering validation, labour safety or regulatory compliance.
3Research problem, objectives and design
3.1Problem statement
Small businesses often know their purchase prices but lack reliable product-level profit visibility. Indirect expenses may be allocated roughly; desired profit margins may not be stated; suppliers may be consulted only after a design is fixed. The central problem is whether an accessible, market-back target-costing routine can improve the quality of product launch decisions in this setting.
3.2Research objectives
- 1. To synthesise established research on target costing and the constraints of smaller firms.
- 2. To document the recent macro context of India’s MSME sector with traceable official figures.
- 3. To build an auditable component-level target-cost model for a representative small manufacturing business.
- 4. To evaluate the sensitivity of the proposed design to selling-price, input-price and volume changes.
- 5. To formulate an implementation roadmap and measurable pilot indicators.
3.3Design and evidentiary boundaries
This is a structured analytical or teaching case, not a field survey, action-research study or account of a named factory. The fictitious organisation, product specifications, quotations, cost sheets, volumes, timings and improvement outcomes below are explicit modelling assumptions created to demonstrate the method. They are not primary observations, interviews, audited accounts or verified current market quotations. External 2025–2026 MSME figures and published academic findings are secondary evidence. Table 2 sets out how each category of evidence should be interpreted. No hypothesis test, interview count, correlation coefficient or causal effect is claimed.
| Evidence category | What is included | How it should be interpreted |
|---|---|---|
| Verified secondary evidence | Official MSME releases and scholarly studies | Context / theory, not unit outcomes |
| Illustrative assumptions | Rack price, bill of materials, cost gap and redesign | Decision simulation only |
| Analytical results | Arithmetic, scenario margins, breakeven-like checks | Conditional on assumptions |
| Not available | Actual SME field data, customer interviews, pilots | No real-world effectiveness claim |
3.4Contribution and publication positioning
The manuscript offers an implementation framework and worked case anchored in recent official context. A journal that requires novel empirical data should classify this as a conceptual/analytical case, or the author should subsequently collect real purchase orders, process times, customer feedback and pre/post cost records before submitting it as an empirical case study.
4Recent Indian MSME evidence and relevance
As of June 2026, Udyam Registration and Udyam Assist registrations together had crossed 8.7 crore, according to a Press Information Bureau release on the MSME sector (PIB, 2026c). A separate 2026 parliamentary briefing cites the Economic Survey’s approximate MSME share of 31.1% of GDP, 35.4% of manufacturing output, 48.58% of exports and employment around 32.82 crore (PIB, 2026a). These figures refer to different administrative and statistical constructs; counts should not be treated as equivalent estimates of active, independent production factories. The main indicators are summarised in Table 3.
| Indicator | Reported value / date | Source and interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| GDP contribution | 31.1% (latest cited survey estimate) | PIB 2026a, sectoral share |
| Manufacturing output | 35.4% | PIB 2026a, sectoral share |
| Exports | 48.58% | PIB 2026a, sectoral share |
| Employment | ~32.82 crore | PIB 2026a, estimate |
| Registrations | >8.7 crore by June 2026 | PIB 2026c, combined registration platforms |
| Revised small category | Investment ≤₹25 crore; turnover ≤₹100 crore | PIB 2025; effective April 2025 |
| Revised medium category | Investment ≤₹125 crore; turnover ≤₹500 crore | PIB 2025; effective April 2025 |
The post-April 2025 classification changes matter for management research: a “small” unit may now represent a wider range of investment and revenue than in earlier studies. Any future sampling protocol should clearly identify manufacturing/services, employee count, product type, ownership and regional cluster rather than relying on an undifferentiated MSME label.
4.1Why target costing may be useful—but not automatic
A small fabricator, garment maker, food processor or packaging supplier may have relatively little power to change market prices. Waste, rejected units, over-specification, purchasing terms, changeovers and product variety are therefore natural places to scrutinise. The National Productivity Council also implements the MSME Competitive (Lean) Scheme, suggesting an institutional route through which process improvement can be explored. However, registration totals and scheme availability do not measure actual target-costing adoption, and business feasibility depends on product quality requirements and local supply conditions.
4.2Boundary between target cost and ethical cost reduction
A lower-cost design is acceptable only if safety margins, product function, durability, labour standards, and mandated compliance remain intact. Redesign proposals in the case are screened for load capacity and corrosion resistance; lower material weight is not counted as an achievement unless an engineer approves it. A firm should record all test expenses, warranty risk and any new equipment cost alongside apparent unit savings.
5The constructed Indian small-unit case
5.1Business situation
Shakti Fabrications operates in a tier-two Indian manufacturing cluster and supplies powder-coated storage fixtures to distributors. Management sees demand for a modular rack with an easy-assembly design. Two competing regional offers suggest a feasible trade selling-price band of ₹2,300–₹2,500; for the case, ₹2,400 is chosen as assumed net realisation. No live retailer quotation or customer field survey was obtained for this paper.
The owner intends to earn 15% operating surplus on sales to fund tools, future upgrades and working-capital shocks. The sales team worries that a cost-plus quote will exceed buyers’ budgets. The production supervisor favours thicker steel and higher finishing allowance for reliability; the accountant points to high scrap and setup expense; the buyer believes the design could be simplified and the steel supplier involved earlier. These competing views make the case appropriate for target costing rather than a unilateral cost-cutting instruction.
5.2Calculation of allowable cost
Target selling price = ₹2,400; required operating surplus = 15% × ₹2,400 = ₹360; target product cost = ₹2,400 − ₹360 = ₹2,040. The initial engineering estimate is ₹2,280, so the cost gap is ₹240 per rack, or 10.53% of estimated cost. The firm should not approve the launch on the assumed margin until it can show a technically acceptable path to close the gap.
Table 4 presents the initial estimated cost structure of the modular rack.
| Initial cost element | ₹ / rack | Cost share |
|---|---|---|
| Steel tube, sheet and brackets | 1,140 | 50.0% |
| Fasteners and fittings | 190 | 8.3% |
| Powder coating and consumables | 245 | 10.7% |
| Direct assembly labour | 265 | 11.6% |
| Power, setup, scrap and rework | 205 | 9.0% |
| Assigned production overhead | 235 | 10.3% |
| Total estimated cost | 2,280 | 100.0% |
5.3Management challenge
If management simply adds a 15% mark-up on cost, a selling price of ₹2,622 is implied (₹2,280 × 1.15), even though a 15% mark-up is not identical to a 15% margin on sales. At ₹2,400 the initial surplus is only ₹120, equal to 5.0% of sales. The decision is not merely to ask suppliers for a ₹240 discount; it is to identify functions worth paying for, prevent unnecessary production effort and validate any proposed changes before orders are accepted.
6Closing the cost gap through value engineering
A three-person working group—owner/finance, production, and purchasing/sales—ranks the largest cost drivers, maps each to the customer function served, and tests potential reductions. The trial below assumes that identical load capacity and corrosion criteria are met after prototype testing. For real deployment, each proposed reduction requires supplier evidence, a time study, a first-article inspection and sign-off.
Table 5 presents the modelled value-engineering interventions and assumed savings.
| Proposed intervention | Cost driver changed | Assumed saving ₹/rack |
|---|---|---|
| Optimise tube cuts and nesting | Steel waste reduction | 85 |
| Standardise brackets / fitting sizes | Fasteners and assembly simplification | 42 |
| Revise coating batch and hanging density | Powder and energy utilisation | 31 |
| Assembly jig and sequence redesign | Labour minutes | 38 |
| Prevent setup scrap and rework | Setup / reject allowance | 39 |
| Reallocate validated production overhead | Absorption after stable batch scheduling | 15 |
| Total modelled saving | 250 |
New modelled unit cost = ₹2,280 − ₹250 = ₹2,030. Modelled operating surplus = ₹2,400 − ₹2,030 = ₹370, or 15.42% of sales. This clears the ₹2,040 allowable-cost target by ₹10. The slender buffer suggests that management should not view the result as robust without sensitivity analysis.
Table 6 presents the target-cost control card: initial versus redesigned model.
| Target-cost control card | Initial | Redesigned model |
|---|---|---|
| Net sales realization | ₹2,400 | ₹2,400 |
| Unit production cost | ₹2,280 | ₹2,030 |
| Operating surplus | ₹120 | ₹370 |
| Operating margin on sales | 5.00% | 15.42% |
| Gap versus allowable cost | ₹240 above target | ₹10 below target |
6.1Functional rather than indiscriminate reduction
A shorter tube-cut list is attractive only if it respects the required load and deflection tests. A jig may reduce labour time but must be tested for accuracy and ergonomic safety. Improved batch coating could lower usage but may alter colour consistency. An overhead “saving” is not cash savings unless capacity is redeployed, spend is avoided or throughput truly rises; in a cautious financial forecast, the ₹15 overhead component should therefore be tracked separately as a potentially non-cash improvement. Without it, expected cost is ₹2,045, narrowly missing the ₹2,040 target. This distinction is important for lender and investor credibility.
6.2Supplier involvement
The purchasing team shares functional requirements rather than imposing an arbitrary percentage price cut. A supplier might offer longer standard tube lengths, consolidated fitting packs or more consistent surface preparation. The arrangement should protect payment discipline and give the supplier a share of verified efficiency gains where appropriate.
7Scenario and sensitivity analysis
Financial conclusions should survive reasonable stress testing. Table 7 holds redesigned unit cost at ₹2,030 except where a specific input-cost shock is stated; all cases are assumed rather than observed. Margin is calculated as (selling price − product cost) / selling price.
| Scenario | Net price ₹ | Unit cost ₹ | Surplus ₹ | Margin |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base redesign | 2,400 | 2,030 | 370 | 15.42% |
| Distributor price pressure −5% | 2,280 | 2,030 | 250 | 10.96% |
| Input-cost rise +8% on material/fittings/coating* | 2,400 | 2,156 | 244 | 10.17% |
| Joint price and material shock | 2,280 | 2,156 | 124 | 5.44% |
| Extra ₹50 quality assurance / warranty reserve | 2,400 | 2,080 | 320 | 13.33% |
| Only verified cash-like savings (₹235) | 2,400 | 2,045 | 355 | 14.79% |
Note: † For the stress test, the ₹126 cost increment is an explicitly rounded assumption representing an approximately 8% increase on a modelled ₹1,575 cost exposure, not a quoted commodity index. Product mix, GST, credit losses and tax impacts are not modelled.
7.1Volume and implementation economics
At 1,000 racks a month, the baseline difference between initial and redesigned modelled cost is ₹250,000 per month, but only if all savings genuinely occur and capacity, product mix and sales conditions hold. Assume an upfront jig/prototype/testing spend of ₹90,000, with ₹235 per unit of improvements judged potentially cash-relevant after excluding the ₹15 overhead absorption effect. Under these assumptions a simplistic payback is ₹90,000 / (₹235 × 1,000) = 0.38 months, ignoring ramp-up, downtime and working capital. Such a rapid apparent payback is precisely why the assumptions need field validation; it must not be reported as an achieved return.
Table 8 presents the monthly volume and potential cash-like savings.
| Monthly output | Cash-like saving / rack | Gross monthly benefit | 90-day lesson |
|---|---|---|---|
| 250 racks | ₹235 | ₹58,750 | Higher exposure to setup and low utilisation |
| 500 racks | ₹235 | ₹117,500 | Pilot economics may be plausible |
| 1,000 racks | ₹235 | ₹235,000 | Needs validated recurring production orders |
If sales fall below forecast, overhead absorption and procurement discounts may reverse. Management should therefore maintain a weekly earned-savings register: standard cost, actual purchase price, scrap quantity, minutes per rack, coating usage, rejects, warranty complaints and actual invoiced selling price.
8A 90-day implementation pathway for Indian SMEs
Table 9 presents the proposed 90-day target-costing implementation pathway.
| Period | Managerial action | Evidence required / control |
|---|---|---|
| Days 1–15 | Select one product; gather competitor offers and customer needs | Written price assumptions, feature priorities |
| Days 16–30 | Build bill of materials and activity-level cost sheet | Supplier rates, labour-time and scrap baseline |
| Days 31–45 | Set target profit and allocate cost gaps by function | Approved target-cost card and owners |
| Days 46–60 | Co-design changes with shop floor and suppliers | Samples, drawings, supplier confirmations |
| Days 61–75 | Run pilot batches and quality tests | Test logs, actual yield, rework and rejection |
| Days 76–90 | Reconcile true cost, realised price and launch decision | Signed cost-gap dashboard; go/no-go decision |
8.1Minimum viable information system
A unit need not begin with expensive enterprise software. A well-controlled spreadsheet can capture (i) product code and revision, (ii) normalised bill of materials, (iii) purchase rates and validity dates, (iv) standard and actual labour minutes, (v) scrap and return rates, (vi) overhead method, (vii) target margin, and (viii) customer feedback.
One nominated employee should control assumptions; version histories and approval signatures are essential when design choices change.
8.2Responsibilities and safeguards
The owner defines an acceptable margin and funds trial activity; sales tests price realism; purchasing validates supplier capability; production quantifies operations; and the accountant reconciles cost categories. Where professional engineering review is necessary, external expertise must be obtained. A monthly review should prevent “paper savings” from being counted twice, such as reducing scrap allowance while also crediting the same scrap to lower material consumption.
8.3Key performance indicators
Five core indicators offer a manageable starting point: target-cost achievement ratio (approved design cost / allowable cost), realised contribution per sale, kilograms of scrap per acceptable rack, direct assembly minutes per rack and first-pass yield. Two complementary indicators—on-time supplier delivery and warranty/returns per 100 units—guard against a false impression of success when apparent costs decline at the expense of reliability.
8.4Decision rule
A launch proceeds only when an approved product meets all non-negotiable functional requirements, the market-price assumption is supportable, cost calculations are reproducible, and the downside case remains within management’s risk tolerance. If the target cannot be achieved, managers must reconsider the product specification, customer segment or required profit—not conceal costs or compromise safety.
9Findings, discussion and implications
9.1Analytical findings
First, the worked case shows the usefulness of expressing an apparently small commercial disagreement as a measurable cost gap. The initial ₹240 gap is a clear design objective instead of a vague request to “be more economical.” Second, most assumed savings arise from process and design coordination rather than a simple supplier price cut. Third, the case illustrates the difference between economically verified reductions and changes in accounting allocation: the ₹15 overhead absorption item matters because it is not necessarily a cash saving. Fourth, the price and input-cost stress tests show that meeting a target in the baseline case does not protect the business from adverse shocks.
The interpretation is consistent with Kato’s (1993) early-design emphasis, Tani et al.’s (1994) multiple product goals, Ellram’s (2006) supplier focus and Ibusuki and Kaminski’s (2007) value-engineering model. Roffia et al. (2024) also helps explain why a simple tool may be more realistic for smaller firms than a technically complex costing system. Consistency with international literature is not proof of Indian effectiveness; it establishes conceptual plausibility.
9.2Practical implications
For owner-managers, the most valuable change is to treat desired profit as an explicit design constraint. For accountants, the challenge is to improve cost traceability without creating excessive administrative burden. For policymakers and cluster support agencies, training could focus on product-cost cards, small-group engineering workshops and supplier benchmarking, potentially alongside existing lean initiatives. For researchers, the gap is empirical: how often do SMEs use target-costing elements informally, and does documented adoption correlate with verified margins after controlling for product mix and demand?
9.3Limitations and future research
This analysis uses a fictitious factory, illustrative prices, no interviewed firms and no observed post-implementation results. The model omits financing cost, capital depreciation for new tools, working-capital interest, tax, GST cash-flow timing, market entry costs, warranty probability and competitor response. Consequently, none of the apparent savings can be generalised as an Indian SME industry average. A future multi-cluster study could recruit 60–100 manufacturing SMEs, examine 6–12 months of actual product records, collect customer quality ratings, and estimate within-firm changes or compare matched adopting and non-adopting firms. Such a study would require consent, verified accounts, a pre-registered protocol and proper statistical controls.
10Conclusion
Target costing is best understood as a shared decision discipline: listen to the market, protect the required customer function, establish an affordable cost and redesign work before committing to production. The constructed Indian rack case demonstrates the calculations and governance steps in a form a small unit could reasonably adapt. Its central claim is procedural rather than causal: a market-back process makes cost and quality trade-offs explicit. Actual profit improvement remains a proposition for on-site validation.
References
- [1]Ansari S, Bell J, Okano H (2006). Target costing: Uncharted research territory. In: Chapman CS, Hopwood AG, Shields MD, editors. Handbook of Management Accounting Research, Vol. 2, pp. 507–530. Elsevier. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1751-3243(06)02002-5
- [2]Cooper R, Slagmulder R (1997). Target Costing and Value Engineering. Productivity Press
- [3]Dekker H, Smidt P (2003). A survey of the adoption and use of target costing in Dutch firms. International Journal of Production Economics, 84(3), 293–305. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0925-5273(02)00450-4
- [4]Ellram LM (2006). The implementation of target costing in the United States: Theory versus practice. Journal of Supply Chain Management, 42(1), 13–26. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-493X.2006.04201003.x
- [5]Ibusuki U, Kaminski PC (2007). Product development process with focus on value engineering and target-costing: A case study in an automotive company. International Journal of Production Economics, 105(2), 459–474. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpe.2005.08.009
- [6]Kato Y (1993). Target costing support systems: Lessons from leading Japanese companies. Management Accounting Research, 4(1), 33–47. https://doi.org/10.1006/mare.1993.1002
- [7]Ministry of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (2025). Annual Report 2024–25. Government of India. https://www.msme.gov.in/sites/default/files/MSME-ANNUAL-REPORT-2024-25-ENGLISH.pdf
- [8]National Productivity Council (n.d.). MSME Competitive (Lean) Scheme. Government of India. https://www.npcindia.gov.in/NPC/MCLS/
- [9]Press Information Bureau (2025, December 30). Year end review 2025: Ministry of Micro, Small & Medium Enterprises. Government of India. https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=2209712
- [10]Press Information Bureau (2026a, March 11). Press release on the 333rd report of the Department-related Parliamentary Standing Committee on Industry. Government of India. https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=2238242
- [11]Press Information Bureau (2026b, May 14). Empowering the grassroots economy: A comprehensive push for rural and semi-urban MSMEs. Government of India. https://www.pib.gov.in/PressNoteDetails.aspx?ModuleId=3&NoteId=158608
- [12]Press Information Bureau (2026c, June 26). From enterprise to empowerment: The MSME story. Government of India. https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=2278107
- [13]Roffia P, Benavides MM, Carrilero A (2024). Cost accounting practices in SMEs: Liability of age and other factors that hinder or burst its implementation in turbulent years. International Entrepreneurship and Management Journal, 20(1), 115–139. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11365-023-00938-2
- [14]Tani T, Okano H, Shimizu N, Iwabuchi Y, Fukuda J, Cooray S (1994). Target cost management in Japanese companies: Current state of the art. Management Accounting Research, 5(1), 67–81. https://doi.org/10.1006/mare.1994.1005