Economic Environmental Equilibrium

Creating an Innovative Digital Twin Model of the Global Ecosystem to Achieve Sustainable Growth at Equilibrium Point Using Predictive Analysis through Socio-tech Entrepreneurship and Exponential Synergistic Architecture

Ravikumar Gajbiye

Thakur Institute of Management Studies & Research, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India

Published November 2026

Abstract

This paper explores the feasibility impact of Digital Twins Technology of Industry 5.0 on the global economic-environmental ecosystem for achieving sustainable growth. The researcher proposes an innovative econometric model based on natural resource infrastructure using Predictive Analysis embedded in the human-focused, sustainability, and resiliency aspects of the fifth Industrial revolution. The research combines seamlessly the Socio-tech Entrepreneurship of Industry 4.0 and the Exponential Synergistic Architecture of Industry 5.0. The researcher additionally aims to propose a new indicator of economic growth for the world economy, introduce a wealth redistribution model for sustainable development, and emphasize the role of our nation, India, as a global leader for promoting inclusive growth for all the nations of the world in the New Industrial 5.0 era and beyond.

Keywords: Digital twins technology; econometric model; predictive analysis; socio-tech entrepreneurship; wealth redistribution model; Industry 5.0

1Introduction

1.1Terminology used

1.2Aim of the research

1.3Research questions

  1. 1. How to replace defunct GDP as an Economic Growth Indicator?
  2. 2. Why are Resource-rich nations economically poor?
  3. 3. Is the Statistical data of the World Economy reliable or accurate?
  4. 4. Have global organisations like the UNO and WB outlived their purpose?

1.4Hypotheses and assumptions

This research work explores the impact of Digital Twins Technology of Industry 5.0 on the global economic-environmental ecosystem for sustainable growth.

Three key pillars define Industry 5.0:

These are (1) human focus, (2) sustainability and (3) resiliency.

An econometric model based on resource infrastructure and the embedded intelligent upgrade for equipment is a Digital Twin's primary condition. Digital Twins can provide automated real-time process analysis between connected machines and data sources, speeding up error detection and correction.

In addition, Digital Twins can bring obvious efficiency improvements and cost. Digital Twins reflects its potential application value and subsequent potential value in Industry 5.0 in the Industrial X.0 era.

2Research design

2.1Type of research

It is an exploratory type of research using secondary data from panel data framework which makes it possible to allow for differences in the form of unobservable individual country effects and ability to control for individual heterogeneity. Panel studies are able to control for state and time‐invariant variables. Method of sampling used is non-probability, judgment, convenience sampling.

2.2Research flow plan

This study follows the guidelines proposed by Durach et al. (2017), Okoli and Schabram (2010), and Webster and Watson (2002) for a systematic literature review. According to Durach et al. (2017), the usual steps include “(1) defining the research question, (2) determining the required characteristics of primary studies, (3) retrieving a sample of potentially relevant literature, (4) selecting the pertinent literature, (5) synthesizing the literature, and (6) reporting the results” (Durach et al., 2017). Okoli and Schabram (2010) also suggest that the researchers train in literature search before starting the analysis, particularly when the work is done in parallel by multiple researchers, while Webster and Watson (2002) provide essential suggestions for structuring the study and conducting a concept-centric analysis.

The first stage (planning) defined our goal of understanding the role of DTs in the emerging needs of Industry 5.0, the literature survey, and the synthesis protocol by two reviewers.

Bibliometric network analysis preceded the second stage (selection) to identify relevant keywords and clusters in the main pillars of Industry 5.0.

In the selected context, human and technology dimensions are deeply intertwined. Among the several possible theoretical lenses for understanding the phenomena, strong structuration theory (Stones, 2005) stands out.

According to this theory, systems that include the behaviour of the actors at the micro (e.g., individual), meso (e.g., organization), and macro (e.g., country or region) levels, and structure (resources and rules that are used and created by humans) are inseparable (Giddens, 1984). Structures support society’s actions and are shaped by the results of these actions.

More recently, strong structuration theory has appeared to clarify the duality of structure, providing a theoretically helpful lens for understanding technology developments, which have already been adopted in critical settings such as healthcare and management (Greenhalgh and Stones, 2010; Jack and Kholeif, 2007).

Stones (2005) posits that structure and patterns of action should be studied through hermeneutics, suggesting the identification of position-practice networks (ontology-in-situ) involving humans and non-human agents (e.g., technology).

Four main components must be addressed in studies adopting the theory, called the quadripartite nature of structuration:

  1. 1. external structures (forces that affect agents’ behaviours independently of their will);
  2. 2. internal structures of agents (knowledge or agent roles);
  3. 3. active agency, referring to the types of actions performed; and
  4. 4. outcomes of actions, where structures can remain the same or change (Greenhalgh and Stones, 2010; Stones, 2005).

Figure 1 shows the use cases of digital twins in Industry 5.0.

Use cases of digital twins in Industry 5.0.
Figure 1. Use cases of digital twins in Industry 5.0.

2.3Variables used in the research design

2.3.1Factors of economic production used in the study

The four basic parameters that define a nation’s economy are:

  1. 1. Land: As it remains constant, and produces resources to run the economy
  2. 2. Population: As a multiplicative factor being consumer base in economy.
  3. 3. Agriculture (supra-soil asset base): Satisfies basic need of hunger
  4. 4. Minerals (sub-soil asset base): Valuation necessary for trade of resources

2.3.2Operationalisation of factors of production

(i)GDP: GDP at purchaser's prices is the sum of gross value added by all resident producers in the economy plus any product taxes and minus any subsidies not included in the value of the products. It is calculated without making deductions for depreciation of fabricated assets or for depletion and degradation of natural resources. Data are in current U.S. dollars. Dollar figures for GDP are converted from domestic currencies using single-year official exchange rates.

Population: Total population is based on the de facto definition of population, which counts all residents regardless of legal status or citizenship. The values shown are midyear estimates.

Note: Population of a nation is taken as a multiplicative factor as it adds up to the economic wealth of a nation by actively participating in the economic process as consumers/end-users.

Land area: Surface area is a country's total area, including areas under inland bodies of water and some coastal waterways.

Land Revenue: It is the sum of the sub-soil and supra-soil assets revenue base.

Agriculture Revenue: Agriculture corresponds to ISIC divisions 1-5 and includes forestry, hunting, and fishing, as well as cultivation of crops and livestock production. Value added is the net output of a sector after adding up all outputs and subtracting intermediate inputs. It is calculated without making deductions for depreciation of fabricated assets or depletion and degradation of natural resources.

Mineral Revenue: It is the revenue derived from the minerals in the soil, as a product of the quantity of that mineral extracted in a given year and its price.

Table 1 presents the list of primary variables and secondary (derived) factors.

Table 1. List of primary variables and secondary (derived) factors.
Primary factors Secondary factors
1. GDP 1. Conversion Factor
2. Population 2. Common Pricing Mechanism
3. Agriculture Revenue 3. Wealth Redistribution Model
4. Mineral Output 4. Economic-Environmental Equilibrium Point

2.3.3Relationships between variables/constructs used in the model

2.3.4Explanation of the variables

Independent variables: the variables that decide the value of the dependent variable-

Dependent variable: the variable whose value is to be calculated

UGNRP: economic potential based on valuation of natural resources

Intervening variable: Influences the independent variables affecting value of dependent variable.

SNA transparency is the level of accuracy and reliability of the economic accounting data at national level of aggregation

2.3.5New economic concepts introduced in the research study

An economic indicator is a statistic about the economy (Moffatt, 2009). By studying the correlation between a developing country's GDP and its environmental quality, central concepts of environmental economics like market failures and externalities can be analysed.

GNRP (Gross Natural Resource Product): GNRP of a nation is the cumulative worth of all its resources. Mathematically it is the product of land revenue and a population factor.

UGDP (Universal Gross Domestic Product): It is the cumulative economic performance of all nations.

Normally, GDP (Gross Domestic Product) is the monetary value of all goods and services, including all private and public consumption, government outlays, investments and foreign trade in a country.

Mathematically, for any nation, GDP is given by Equation (1):

G D P = C + G + I + N X (1)

Similarly, the cumulative actual economic worth (achieved performance) of all nations is proposed as Universal GDP.

Land Revenue: It is the sum total of the mineral revenue and agricultural revenue for a nation in a given time period (business cycle).

Mineral revenue: It is the valuation of the raw resources of economy based on a common price mechanism. It is an aggregation of the quantity of natural resource multiplied by its price.

UGNRP (Universal Gross Natural Resource Product): The Cumulative GNRP of the World is calculated at the beginning of the economic cycle of world trade. It is the sum of the GNRP of all the nations of the world.

Mathematically, UGNRP is represented by Equation (2):

G N R P c u m = G N R P 1 + G N R P 2 + G N R P 3 + … + G N R P n (2)

where 1, 2, 3, …, n denote nation 1, nation 2, nation 3, …, nation n.

Note: The cumulative GNRP of the world (GNRPcumulative) is calculated at the beginning of the economic cycle.

3Conceptual framework

The basic conceptual premise on which the research rests is:

Resource Utilization (Environmental Decline) must equal Economic Growth.

This section gives a brief idea of the working of the statistical methods utilized for arriving at the solutions proposed.

3.1Solutions proposed in the research study

The innovative solutions proposed in the research are:

  1. 1. Concept of GNRP
  2. 2. Concepts of UGDP and UGNRP
  3. 3. Wealth Redistribution Model
  4. 4. Economic Environmental Equilibrium Point

3.2Data compilation

3.3Stages in the research working process

The research process is carried out in three stages:

3.4Stage 1: define and calculate GNRP

3.4.1Highlights of GNRP calculation

This economic worth based on mineral valuation is the critical element in calculating the proposed Gross Natural Resource Product (GNRP)

3.4.2Working for GNRP derivation

This is a simple two-step mechanism

Step 1: Land Revenue = Mineral Value + Agriculture Revenue

Step 2: GNRP = Land Revenue * Population factor (pop. in bn)

3.5Stage 2: deriving the wealth redistribution model

3.5.1Defining UGNRP, UGDP and excess wealth

3.5.2Working principle behind the wealth redistribution model

The excess wealth for a nation is ploughed back into the economic potential valuation (UGNRP) of the successive business cycle until UGNRP equals UGDP, and there is no excess wealth created.

3.5.3Operationalising the wealth redistribution model

The method to operationalize WRM is given below step-wise.

  1. 1. Check the difference between the GDP and the mean UGDP for a nation for a particular year for the nation/economy (GDP – mean UGDP).
  2. 2. If the difference is a positive value, the difference (excess GDP) is to be added to the GNRP of that nation in the subsequent year (INJECT).
  3. 3. If the difference is a negative value, no action is to be taken for subsequent year.
  4. 4. The addition of excess GDP to the GNRP of that nation to ensure excess wealth created is ploughed back into the nation’s economy for the next year.

3.5.4Logic behind the methodology

3.6Stage 3: forecasting the equilibrium point

This section involves Trend Analysis and Forecasting of the Equilibrium Point based on the forecasts for the year 2017 and 2022.

The process of forecasting is achieved in five steps:

  1. 1. Trend Analysis
  2. 2. Forecast Analysis
  3. 3. Projections based on forecast
  4. 4. Achieving zero difference
  5. 5. Interpretation of the Results

Step 1: Trend Analysis

Trend Analysis based on the forecast is graphically depicted using

After adjusting for UGNRP (original) with the excess growth factor, the difference between UGNRP (Revised) and UGDP is seen to be reduced drastically over successive years. It may reach zero level of macro-constancy at equilibrium point if proper measures are taken.

Step 2: Forecast Analysis

  1. 1. The forecast value of GDP (nominal) for the years 2017 and 2022 are considered
  2. 2. Value of UGDP forecast is calculated for the given nations for 2017and 2022
  3. 3. Growth Rate for prediction values based on forecast is calculated
  4. 4. Using the growth rate, UGNRP is calculated for the year 2017 and 2022
  5. 5. Difference between forecast UGDP and derived UGNRP for 2017 is obtained
  6. 6. Difference between forecast UGDP and derived UGNRP for 2022 is obtained.

Note: The final aim of the research is to achieve zero difference between UGDP and UGNRP values, projected for the year 2022.

Step 3: Projections based on forecast

Graphically, the linear trend value for UGDP can be devised for the years 2018 to 2021. Accordingly, the UGNRP can be adjusted to reach zero difference.

Step 4: Achieving Zero difference

The target of “Zero difference” between UGNRP and UGDP can be achieved in two ways:

Step 5: Interpretation of the Results/Conclusion

At this point, we can conclude that equilibrium point of sustainable growth has been achieved.

4Statistical framework of research

This section gives a brief idea about the statistical methodology used in the derivation of the proposed new economic growth indicator, the wealth redistribution model methodology, and the process of arriving at the economic-environmental equilibrium point for sustainable growth.

4.1Statistical methods used

  1. 1. Regression analysis is the method adopted to reflect correlation between GDP growth and various factors of production.
  2. 2. Correlation analysis is used for inferring correlation between GDP (dependent variable) and Land, Agriculture, Population, and Minerals (independent variables).

Note: The researcher has highlighted these methods in the research paper titled “Derivation of Constant UGDP using Econometric Models; Calculating Real GDP using Valuation of Key Natural Resources” and presented at the 4th IRC at IIM-Ahmedabad- 'ICADABAI- 2015 by the researcher.

  1. 1. Trend Analysis and Forecast Analysis are used for predicting the values of GDP for a 5-year period.
  2. 2. Simple mathematical calculations are used to deduce growth rate based on which proposed GNRP value is derived.

4.2Summary of the wealth redistribution mechanism

  1. 1. At the initial evaluation of natural resources, the cumulative economic potential (UGNRP) is calculated.
  2. 2. UGNRP is compared with cumulative wealth generated (UGDP). If the two values are unequal, we conclude that there is economic disequilibrium.
  3. 3. The GDP of each nation is compared with mean UGDP. If the GDP is more than mean GDP, the difference is added to the GNRP of that nation in next business cycle.
  4. 4. The UGNRP is compared with UGDP in next cycle. The steps are repeated till the stage when both the values are equal. i.e. UGDP = UGNRP

This distribution ensures equal growth opportunity and optimizing usage of natural resources in the subsequent economic cycle, based on sufficing requirement for growth.

4.3Statistical derivation of GNRP, UGNRP and UGDP

4.3.1Part A: steps in calculating GNRP based on valuation of natural resources

  1. 1. Collating Mineral Output Data for nations
  2. 2. Finding the Common Price Index of each commodity
  3. 3. Extracting other economic data like Agriculture revenue and population
  4. 4. Final derivation of GNRP based on Land revenue and population factor

GNRP as an indicator of economic growth potential is defined principally to include the valuation of natural resources, mainly agriculture and mineral revenue.

4.3.2Part B: derivation of UGNRP and UGDP

Nation is denoted by N, Land Revenue by L, agriculture revenue by A, mineral revenue by M.

Land revenue is the sum of Agriculture revenue and Mineral revenue.

Mineral Revenue (M1) for nation N1 is the sum of revenues derived from all minerals extracted.

For mineral ma, potential revenue derived is the product of quantity q of mineral ma and (common) price c of mineral ma. The total Mineral Revenue M1 of nation N1 is the sum of potential revenue of all its minerals m to mz.

Now:

The economic wealth potential of nation N1 is the sum of A1 and M1 (Equation 3).

W N 1 = A 1 + M 1 (3)

M1 is the summation of revenues from minerals m1 to mm (Equation 4).

M 1 = ∑ a = 1 m R m a (4)

The revenue derived from mineral ma is the product of qa and ca (Equation 5).

R m a = q a × c a (5)

Mineral revenue M1 is therefore the sum of mineral revenue from m1 to mm (Equation 6).

M 1 = ∑ a = 1 m q a c a (6)

Total agriculture and mineral revenue is calculated as shown in Equation (7):

A total = ∑ i = 1 n A i , M total = ∑ i = 1 n ∑ j = 1 m m i j (7)

where i denotes nations and j minerals.

Total revenue potential (TRP) is the sum of Atotal and Mtotal (Equation 8).

T R P = A total + M total (8)

This is the underlying statistical derivation of UGNRP

Similarly, the concept of cumulative economic wealth created is calculated as the sum of the GDP of all nations. i.e. UGDP (Equation 9).

U G D P total = ∑ i = 1 n G D P i (9)

4.3.3Part C: comparing achieved wealth with potential wealth

Let the GNRP of each nation be x1, x2, x3…. xn, respectively.

At the end of the business cycle, the value of the economic wealth achieved by each nation as a result of individual economic activity is the GDP of that nation.

Let the GDP of each nation be y1, y2, y3…. yn, respectively.

Mean UGDP is given by the division of UGDP by the number of participating nations.

Let this mean UGDP value be denoted by X.

On comparing the GDP value (yn) of each nation with the mean UGDP (X) we find three likely situations for that nation (y1):

  1. 1. y1 is more than X (y1 > X: surplus growth)
  2. 2. y1 is less than X (y1 < X: deficit growth)
  3. 3. y1 is equal to X (y1 = X: constant growth)

4.3.4Part D: actualising the economic-environmental equilibrium point

Phase 1: Injection of Excess Growth into successive year’s GNRP

If a nation achieves surplus growth, the excess amount of achieved wealth (y n - X) is ploughed back (injected) into the wealth potential (GNRP) of the nation in the next business cycle. If there is growth deficit, no action is taken.

Phase 2: Economic Excess Dis- incentivization

All the nations who have surplus growth (overachievers) will contribute more to the cumulative wealth potential UGNRP of next business cycle.

Phase 3: Break-even point of Economic-Environmental Equilibrium

Nations who achieve a higher economic wealth will ensure that fewer natural resources are used to reach level of equilibrium with their individual growth potential, thus ensuring sustainable growth through optimal resource utilization.

Underachieving nations (GDP less than mean UGDP) will by default ensure distribution of excess wealth created, creating an environment for sufficing growth instead of maximizing growth.

When there is constant growth for maximum nations for a consistent time period, it can be concluded that the Economic-Environmental Equilibrium point has been achieved.

4.4Summary of the research methodology

This section has introduced the research strategy and the design of the research methodology.

The conceptual and strategic framework of the study is outlined for better understanding of the detailed working to follow.

5Economic growth and environmental degradation

This section, presents a statistical analysis of the factors responsible for economic growth and environmental degradation and attempts to discover the most relevant economic and environmental factors for the purpose of the study.

The study sets to prove that environmental degradation is caused by economic growth using correlational analysis. Factor analysis and Principal Component Analysis (PCA) determine the factors that influence both economic and environmental aspects of the study.

5.1Hypothesis formation

Hypothesis: Economic Development is responsible for Environmental Degradation

5.2Methodology followed for hypothesis testing

To test the hypothesis that economic growth is the cause of environmental degradation, we use socio-economic database pertaining to the emerging economies in South Asia (SAARC nations), namely Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Maldives, Nepal, Pakistan and Sri Lanka.

Data type: Secondary data of the type one-time longitudinal time-series.

Table 2 presents the socio-economic variables used for SAARC nations.

Table 2. Socio-economic variables used for SAARC nations.
Variables Description
Variables measuring Environmental Impact Variables measuring Environmental Impact
Forest Cover Percentage of Forest in Total Geographic area
RSPM Level Average annual Respirable Suspended Particulate Matter
SO2 Level Average annual SO2 emission (gm/m3)
NO2 Level Average annual NO2 emission (gm/m3)
Explanatory Variables Explanatory Variables
Population Size Total Projected Population (in thousands)
Urbanization Percentage of Urban Population in the Total
Population in Working Age Percentage of Population in age Group 15-59
Population Density Number of Persons per Sq. Km.
State GDP Gross State Domestic Product at Current Prices (Rs in Crores)
Urban MPCE Average Monthly Consumption Expenditure (Rs) per person for Urban Areas
Electricity Consumption Gross Annual per Capita Consumption of Electricity
Mobile cellular subscription Percentage of Urban Population in the Total

The database is appended below:

Table 3 presents the database of the socio-economic variables: SAARC nations.

Table 3. Database of the socio-economic variables: SAARC nations.
Description/Country Unit Afghanistan Bangladesh Bhutan India Maldives Nepal Pakistan Sri-Lanka
Population ('000) 25985.6 153600 (2013) 745 (2014) 1210569 (2011) 331 (2012) 26494.5 (2011) 184350 (2012-13) 20483 (2013)
Population growth rate (%) 2.03 1.36 (2011) 1.8 (2005) 1.8 (2011) 1.69 (2006) 1.35 (2011) 2.0 (2012-13) 0.9 (2012)
Population density 37.5 1021 (2011) 19.4 (2014) 382 (2011) 1053 (2010) 180 (2011) 231 (2012-13) 327 (2013)
Sex ratio 104.7 100.3 (2011) 108.4 (2014) 106.07 (2011) 103 (2006) 94.2 (2011) 106.99 (2012-13) 94.3 (2013)
Crude Birth Rate) CBR NA 19.2 (2011) 18.5 (2012) 21.6 (2012) 22 (2010) 24.3 (2011) 26.8 (2012-13) 17.5 (2012)
Crude Death Rate CDR NA 5.5 (2011) 8.5 (2012) 7.0 (2012) 3 (2010) 8.3 (2006) 7 (2012-13) 6.0 (2012)
Total Fertility Rate TFR NA 2.1 (2011) 2.1 (2012) 2.4 (2012) 2.1 (2006) 2.6 (2006) 3.3 (2012-13) 2.3 (2006/07)
Life expectancy Males, (Years) NA 67.9 (2011) 67.3 (2013) 64.6 (2006-10) 73 (2012) 63.6 (2006) 64.6 (2012-13) 68.8 (2001)
GDP (mn USD) 9600 73780 1120 1147740 1400 9740 129380 31500
Private Cons Exp (% of GDP) 98.2 (2009) 75.15 (2012) 45.8 (2012) 57.1 (2012-13) NA 76.41 (2012) 81.05 (2012-13) 66.8 (2013)
Private Cons Exp (% of GDP) 98.2 75.15 45.8 57.1 NA 76.41 81.05 66.8
Private Cons Exp (mn USD) 9427.2 55445.67 512.96 655359.54 #VALUE! 7442.334 104862.49 21042
Afghanistan Bangladesh Bhutan India Maldives Nepal Pakistan Sri-Lanka
GHG AND OTHER GASES ('000 tons CO2 equi) 20221.4 144666.95 989.25 1197470.175 0.8 38183.15 252057.7 11279.025
Ozone-depleting subs cons gm/1000 GDP (2005 PPP $) 2.26 0.96 0.1 0.92 2.12 #DIV/0! 1 0.62

5.3Statistical tools used to prove the hypothesis

Factor analysis and Principal Component Analysis (PCA) are used to arrive at key factors responsible for Environmental degradation in SAARC nations.

Table 4 presents the components of regression analysis.

Table 4. Components of regression analysis.
Component Regressed with Variables
Environmental Impact Forest Cover RSPM, SO2, NO2
Population GDP Size, Density, Working % age
Affluence Population Size GDP, Cons Exp., Electricity cons
Technology GDP Urbanization, Mobile subscription

5.4SPSS output for FA and PCA: SAARC nations

SPSS output for the different variables, dependent as well as explanatory, gave an output which is tabulated below in the correlation matrix. Result of Factor Analysis, Regression, Correlation and Co-variance, along with Principal Component Analysis is presented.

5.4.1Correlation matrix

Table 5 presents the correlation matrix of dependent vs explanatory variables.

Table 5. Correlation matrix of dependent vs explanatory variables.
Independent Variables Pop Size Pop Density Wkng Popn GDP Cons Exp Elect Cons Urbansn Mobile subs
Population Size 1
Population Density -0.008 1
Working Population -0.195 0.062 1
GDP 0.997 -0.032 -0.190 1
Consumption Expenditure 0.999 -0.031 -0.210 0.999 1
Electricity Consumption 0.991 -0.062 -0.265 0.989 0.994 1
Urbanization 0.142 0.363 -0.288 0.132 0.143 0.204 1
Mobile subscription -0.164 0.605 -0.169 -0.136 -0.146 -0.148 0.515 1
Dependent Variables Dependent Variables Dependent Variables
Forest Cover -0.066 -0.442 0.515 -0.035 -0.056 -0.075 -0.061 -0.222
RSPM Level 0.074 -0.326 -0.344 0.034 0.062 0.104 -0.267 -0.621
SO2 Level -0.302 0.173 -0.443 -0.282 -0.297 -0.303 0.177 0.484
NO2 Level 1.000 -0.013 -0.188 0.999 0.999 0.990 0.144 -0.157

Note: Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed)

5.4.2Result of principal component analysis

Extraction Method used is Principal Component Analysis. Rotation Method used is Varimax with Kaiser Normalization. Rotation is converged in 4 iterations.

Table 6 presents the SPSS output of principal component analysis.

Table 6. SPSS output of principal component analysis.
Component Component Percentage Variation
X11 Population Size 0.998
X22 Private Consumption Expenditure 0.996
X21 GDP 0.995
X23 Electricity Consumption 0.986

5.4.3Result of regression model fit

5.5Inference

From principal component analysis

The First Component explains 51.26 % of the total variation in the data. Since the Eigen-Value of the first three components (4.10, 2.02, 1.01) is greater than 1, the first three components are used to calculate component score for each nation to determine its ranking in environmental degradation.

From correlation analysis

Population size has a strong impact on Environmental degradation.

There is strong correlation between GDP (economic growth indicator), and each of the factors: Consumer Expenditure (satisfaction), Electricity Consumed (urbanization) and NO2 levels (environmental degradation)

5.6Conclusion of the hypothesis test

The factors to be considered for the research study based on the above results are: GDP and Population size.

5.7Stage a: data collection

Source of data: Secondary data is used for statistical analysis of macroeconomic components of the various factors of economics from various sources. These are mentioned against each database.

Data Characteristics: The periodicity of data collection is annual. The unit of analysis (level of aggregation) is nation of the world. A one-shot longitudinal time series data is maintained for a time period from 2009 to 2013. The database related to GDP of the nations is utilized at a later stage to derive the Econometric Model and the Equilibrium Point of Economic growth and Environmental decline.

The characteristics of the data are presented below in tabular form

Table 7 presents the characteristics of data used for research study.

Table 7. Characteristics of data used for research study.
Type of data Pooled cross-sectional and Time series data (Panel data)
Periodicity Annual
Unit of Analysis Nations (the level of aggregation of data)
Time Horizon One shot/longitudinal time series
Variables (Objects) Economic Growth potential of Nations of the World
Attributes/Characteristics Land area, Population, Agriculture Revenue, Mineral Revenue (derived), GDP

5.7.1Aggregation of data

Data is aggregated as a time-series data over different time periods ranging from 2009 to 2013. For any given year, the data for a group of nation (64 nations in aggregate) is used as cross-section data, while data for the same group for 64 nations over the time period of 5 years (in average) is used as panel data type.

Nations are included from different geographic areas: the five major continents of the world. The database of nations includes nations from all the various economic strata: Developed, developing as well as transient economies. These are indicated by the GDP factor over differing time periods. Thus, the data type used is multi-variate data varying over different geographic areas and different time periods.

A summary table of the data is presented below.

Table 8 presents the summary of data aggregation.

Table 8. Summary of data aggregation.
Over different Time periods Time Series data
Group of Nations in one year Cross –section data
Group of Nations over many years Panel data
Multivariate data over several geographic areas aggregate cross section data
developed, developing, transient economies strata of nations
Multivariate data over time for all Universe aggregate time series data

5.8Stage b: sampling method

5.9Stage c: database of economic parameters

The nation-wise database of different economic parameters used in the research study is collected and tabulated for ease of reference. These databases are used in further in the statistical derivation of the new economic parameters and models proposed in the research.

The databases collated relevant to this section of the study are as follows:

Table 9 presents the list of all nations of the world.

Table 9. List of all nations of the world.
Sr No Country Sr No Country Sr No Country
1 Afghanistan 36 Canada 71 French Polynesia
2 Albania 37 Cayman Islands 72 Gabon
3 Algeria 38 Central African Rep 73 Gambia
4 Andorra 39 Chad 74 Georgia
5 Angola 40 Chile 75 Germany
6 Anguilla 41 China 76 Ghana
7 Antigua/ 42 Hong Kong 77 Greece
8 Argentina 43 Colombia 78 Greenland
9 Armenia 44 Comoros 79 Grenada
10 Aruba 45 Congo 80 Guatemala
11 Australia 46 Cook Islands 81 Guinea
12 Austria 47 Costa Rica 82 Guinea-Bissau
13 Azerbaijan 48 Côte d'Ivoire 83 Guyana
14 Bahamas 49 Croatia 84 Haiti
15 Bahrain 50 Cuba 85 Honduras
16 Bangladesh 51 Curaçao 86 Hungary
17 Barbados 52 Cyprus 87 Iceland
18 Belarus 53 Czech Republic 88 India
19 Belgium 54 D.P.R. of Korea 89 Indonesia
20 Belize 55 D.R. of the Congo 90 Iran
21 Benin 56 Denmark 91 Iraq
22 Bermuda 57 Djibouti 92 Ireland
23 Bhutan 58 Dominica 93 Israel
24 Bolivia 59 Dominican Republic 94 Italy
25 Bosnia /Herzegovina 60 Ecuador 95 Jamaica
26 Botswana 61 Egypt 96 Japan
27 Brazil 62 El Salvador 97 Jordan
28 British Virgin Islands 63 Equatorial Guinea 98 Kazakhstan
29 Brunei Darussalam 64 Eritrea 99 Kenya
30 Bulgaria 65 Estonia 100 Kiribati
31 Burkina Faso 66 Ethiopia 101 Kosovo
32 Burundi 67 Fiji 102 Kuwait
33 Cabo Verde 68 Finland 103 Kyrgyzstan
34 Cambodia 69 Netherlands Antilles 104 Lao
35 Cameroon 70 France 105 Latvia
106 Lebanon 141 Oman 176 Sri Lanka
107 Lesotho 142 Pakistan 177 St. Vincent/Grenada
108 Liberia 143 Palau 178 State of Palestine
109 Libya 144 Panama 179 Sudan
110 Liechtenstein 145 Papua New Guinea 180 Suriname
111 Lithuania 146 Paraguay 181 Swaziland
112 Luxembourg 147 Peru 182 Sweden
113 Madagascar 148 Philippines 183 Switzerland
114 Malawi 149 Poland 184 Syria
115 Malaysia 150 Portugal 185 Tajikistan
116 Maldives 151 Puerto Rico 186 Macedonia
117 Mali 152 Qatar 187 Thailand
118 Malta 153 Republic of Korea 188 Timor-Leste
119 Marshall Isles 154 Republic of Moldova 189 Togo
120 Mauritania 155 Romania 190 Tonga
121 Mauritius 156 Russian Federation 191 Trinidad/Tobago
122 Mexico 157 Rwanda 192 Tunisia
123 Micronesia 158 Saint Kitts/Nevis 193 Turkey
124 Monaco 159 Saint Lucia 194 Turkmenistan
125 Mongolia 160 Samoa 195 Turks/Caicos Isles
126 Montenegro 161 San Marino 196 Tuvalu
127 Montserrat 162 Sao Tome/Principe 197 U.R. of Tanzania
128 Morocco 163 Saudi Arabia 198 Uganda
129 Mozambique 164 Senegal 199 Ukraine
130 Myanmar 165 Serbia 200 United Arab Emirates
131 Namibia 166 Seychelles 201 United Kingdom
132 Nauru 167 Sierra Leone 202 United States
133 Nepal 168 Singapore 203 Uruguay
134 Netherlands 169 Sint Maarten 204 Uzbekistan
135 New Caledonia 170 Slovakia 205 Vanuatu
136 New Zealand 171 Slovenia 206 Venezuela
137 Nicaragua 172 Solomon Islands 207 Viet Nam
138 Niger 173 Somalia 208 Yemen
139 Nigeria 174 South Africa 209 Zambia
140 Norway 175 Spain 210 Zanzibar
211 Zimbabwe

Table 10 presents the list of 191 nations used in the research study.

Table 10. List of 191 nations used in the research study.
Rank Economy GDP Rank Economy GDP Rank Economy GDP
1 United States 19,417.14 33 Hong Kong 332.266 65 Ukraine 95.934
2 China 11,795.30 34 Philippines 329.716 66 Slovak Rep 89.134
3 Japan 4,841.22 35 South Africa 317.568 67 Sri Lanka 84.023
4 Germany 3,423.29 36 Malaysia 309.86 68 Ethiopia 78.384
5 United Kingdom 2,496.76 37 Colombia 306.439 69 Dominican Rep 76.85
6 India 2,454.46 38 Denmark 304.216 70 Kenya 75.099
7 France 2,420.44 39 Ireland 294.193 71 Myanmar 72.368
8 Brazil 2,140.94 40 Egypt 294.109 72 Oman 71.325
9 Italy 1,807.43 41 Singapore 291.86 73 Guatemala 70.943
10 Canada 1,600.27 42 Venezuela 251.589 74 Uzbekistan 68.324
11 Russia 1,560.71 43 Pakistan 251.487 75 Luxembourg 59.997
12 Korea 1,498.07 44 Chile 251.22 76 Costa Rica 59.796
13 Australia 1,359.72 45 Bangladesh 248.853 77 Panama 59.486
14 Spain 1,232.44 46 Finland 234.524 78 Uruguay 58.123
15 Indonesia 1,020.52 47 Vietnam 215.829 79 Belarus 54.689
16 Mexico 987.303 48 Peru 207.072 80 Libya 54.411
17 Turkey 793.698 49 Portugal 202.77 81 Lebanon 53.915
18 Netherlands 762.694 50 New Zealand 198.043 82 Bulgaria 52.291
19 Saudi Arabia 707.379 51 Czech Rep 196.068 83 Tanzania 51.194
20 Switzerland 659.368 52 Greece 193.1 84 Croatia 50.084
21 Argentina 628.935 53 Romania 189.79 85 Macao SAR 45.728
22 Taiwan 566.757 54 Iraq 189.432 86 Slovenia 43.503
23 Sweden 507.046 55 Algeria 173.947 87 Lithuania 42.826
24 Poland 482.92 56 Qatar 173.649 88 Ghana 42.753
25 Belgium 462.715 57 Kazakhstan 157.878 89 Turkmenistan 42.355
26 Thailand 432.898 58 Kuwait 126.971 90 Congo 41.098
27 UAE 407.21 59 Hungary 125.297 91 Jordan 40.506
28 Nigeria 400.621 60 Angola 122.365 92 Tunisia 40.289
29 Norway 391.959 61 Sudan 115.874 93 Bolivia 39.267
30 Austria 383.509 62 Morocco 105.623 94 Azerbaijan 38.583
31 Iran 368.488 63 Puerto Rico 99.727 95 Serbia 37.739
32 Israel 339.99 64 Ecuador 97.362 96 Côte d'Ivoire 36.873
97 Bahrain 34.31 129 Eq. Guinea 11.686 161 Burundi 3.384
98 Cameroon 29.547 130 Mozambique 11.17 162 Timor-Leste 2.727
99 Paraguay 28.743 131 Malta 11.164 163 Lesotho 2.439
100 Latvia 27.795 132 Macedonia 10.951 164 Bhutan 2.308
101 El Salvador 27.548 133 Armenia 10.741 165 Liberia 2.215
102 Yemen 27.189 134 Madagascar 10.372 166 Djibouti 2.088
103 Uganda 27.174 135 Mongolia 10.271 167 C. African Rep. 1.992
104 Estonia 23.422 136 Chad 9.636 168 Belize 1.829
105 Nepal 23.316 137 Bahamas 9.172 169 Cabo Verde 1.637
106 Zambia 23.137 138 Rwanda 8.918 170 San Marino 1.551
107 Iceland 22.97 139 Benin 8.792 171 Seychelles 1.475
108 Honduras 21.79 140 Rep. of Congo 8.341 172 Antigua/Barbuda 1.454
109 Trinidad/Tobago 21.748 141 Haiti 7.897 173 St. Lucia 1.428
110 Papua Guinea 21.189 142 Niger 7.674 174 Solomon Islands 1.245
111 Cambodia 20.953 143 Moldova 7.409 175 Guinea-Bissau 1.166
112 Afghanistan 20.57 144 Tajikistan 7.242 176 Grenada 1.089
113 Cyprus 19.648 145 Guinea 6.936 177 The Gambia 1.041
114 Bosnia 16.78 146 Kyrgyz Rep. 6.854 178 St. Kitts/Nevis 0.951
115 Botswana 15.564 147 Kosovo 6.809 179 Samoa 0.843
116 Senegal 15.431 148 Malawi 6.182 180 Vanuatu 0.829
117 Zimbabwe 15.285 149 Eritrea 6.051 181 St. Vincent 0.809
118 Lao P.D.R. 14.971 150 Mauritania 5.063 182 Comoros 0.654
119 Mali 14.344 151 Fiji 4.869 183 Dominica 0.539
120 Jamaica 14.272 152 South Sudan 4.812 184 Tonga 0.422
121 Gabon 14.208 153 Barbados 4.759 185 São Tomé 0.355
122 Nicaragua 13.748 154 Togo 4.554 186 Micronesia 0.334
123 Georgia 13.723 155 Montenegro 4.185 187 Palau 0.315
124 Brunei Darussalam 12.326 156 Sierra Leone 4.088 188 Marshall Isles 0.188
125 Albania 12.294 157 Swaziland 3.938 189 Kiribati 0.173
126 Burkina Faso 12.258 158 Suriname 3.641 190 Nauru 0.114
127 Mauritius 12.245 159 Guyana 3.591 191 Tuvalu 0.036
128 Namibia 11.765 160 Maldives 3.578 192 Syria -

Note: GDP is the Nominal GDP projected for 2017 (USD billion). Source: - StatisticsTimes.com

Sample Size of Nations used for the Research Study: The sample size of nations selected for the research study is based on the contribution of that nation to a projected value world GDP.

The top five economies account for 53.82 %, the top ten accounts for approx. 67.19 %, and the top 20 economies add up to over 80% of World GDP.

Out of the universal sample size of 191 nations (economies), the first 64 nations account for 95.63 % of the World GDP (US$77.99 trillion in 2017).

Table 11 presents the world GDP and share of top 64 nations (year 2017).

Table 11. World GDP and share of top 64 nations (year 2017).
Aggregate Economy Unit Cumulative GDP (USD bn) Percentage of World GDP
TOP 64 nations 74,577 95.63 %
World GDP 77,988

Source: IMF Statistics.com

Database of Sample size of nations: 64 nations sample size are tabulated below:

Table 12 presents the research sample size of 64 nations.

Table 12. Research sample size of 64 nations.
SN Country/Economy SN Country/Economy SN Country/Economy
1 United States 23 Sweden 45 Finland
2 China 24 Poland 46 Vietnam
3 Japan 25 Belgium 47 Peru
4 Germany 26 Thailand 48 Portugal
5 United Kingdom 27 United Arab Emirates 49 New Zealand
6 India 28 Nigeria 50 Czech Republic
7 France 29 Norway 51 Greece
8 Brazil 30 Austria 52 Romania
9 Italy 31 Iran 53 Iraq
10 Canada 32 Israel 54 Algeria
11 Russia 33 Philippines 55 Qatar
12 Korea 34 South Africa 56 Kazakhstan
13 Australia 35 Malaysia 57 Kuwait
14 Spain 36 Colombia 58 Hungary
15 Indonesia 37 Denmark 59 Kenya
16 Mexico 38 Ireland 60 Luxembourg
17 Turkey 39 Egypt 61 Tanzania
18 Netherlands 40 Venezuela 62 Bahrain
19 Saudi Arabia 41 Pakistan 63 Zimbabwe
20 Switzerland 42 Chile 64 Central African Republic
21 Argentina 43 Bangladesh
22 Taiwan Province of China 44 Central America

Important point to note

It is highly interesting to note that the IMF, an internationally recognized institute, utilizes the term Gross World Product, which is quite similar to the new concept of Universal Gross Domestic Product (UGDP) proposed in this research.

Table 13 presents the database of the minerals used in the research study.

Table 13. Database of the minerals used in the research study.
S. No. Commodity S. No. Commodity S. No. Commodity
1 Abrasives 41 Calcareous 81 Ferronickel magnesium
2 Acid Clay 42 Calcite 82 Ferroniobium
3 Agate 43 Calcium carbonate 83 Ferrophosphorus
4 Aggregates 44 Carbon 84 Ferrosilicon
5 Alabaster 45 Caustic Soda 85 Ferrovanadium
6 Alexandrite 46 Cement 86 Fire Clay
7 Alginate (sodium) 47 Chalk 87 Flagstone
8 Alumina 48 Chromite 88 Fluorspar
9 Aluminum 49 Clay 89 Fuel oil
10 Amethyst 50 Clinker 90 Fuller's Earth
11 Ammonia 51 Coal 91 Gabbro (Dim. stone)
12 Amphibolite (feldspar) 52 Cobalt 92 Gallium
13 Andalusite 53 Coke, metallurgical 93 Garnet
14 Anthracite Coal 54 Construction sand 94 Gas Oil
15 Antimony 55 Copper 95 Gasoline
16 Apatite (Phosphate rock) 56 Copper sulfate 96 Gemstones
17 Aquamarine 57 Coquina 97 Gemstones Crude
18 Aromatic Tar 58 Cordierite, Iolite 98 Geniss (feldspar)
19 Arsenic 59 Crude Oil 99 Germanium
20 Asbestos 60 Crushed/broken Stone 100 Glauberite
21 Asphalt 61 Cyclohexane 101 Gold
22 Attapulgite clay 62 Diamond 102 Granite
23 Avigas 63 Diaspore 103 Graphite
24 Ball (Clay) 64 Diatomite 104 Gravel
25 Barite 65 Diesel 105 Greywacke (sandstone)
26 Basalt 66 Dimension stone 106 Guano
27 Bauxite 67 Distillate fuel oil 107 Gypsum
28 Bentonite 68 Dolomite 108 Helium
29 Beryllium 69 Dunite 109 Igneous rock
30 Biotite 70 Electrolytic, cathode4 110 Ilmenite
31 Bismuth 71 Emerald 111 Indium
32 Bitumen fuel 72 Ethane 112 Iodine
33 Bituminous Coal 73 Fe content 113 Iolite
34 Blister Copper 74 Feldspar 114 Iridium
35 Boron 75 Felsite 115 Iron
36 Brine, salt 76 Ferro Titanium 116 Iron Oxide pigments
37 Briquets (Peat) 77 Ferrochromium 117 Jadeite
38 Bromine 78 Ferrochromium silicon 118 Jasper
39 Butane 79 Ferromanganese 119 Kaolin
40 Cadmium 80 Ferromolybdenum 120 Kerosene and jet fuel
121 Kyanite 161 Phosphate rock 201 Silica
122 Lead 162 Phosphatic Fertilizer 202 Siliceous earth
123 Leonardite 163 Phosphoric acid 203 Silicomanganese
124 Leucoxene 164 Phosphorite 204 Silicon
125 Lignite 165 Pig iron 205 Sillimanite
126 Lime 166 Pigments, Iron oxide 206 Silver
127 Limestone 167 Platinum 207 Slate
128 Liquefied petroleum gas 168 Porphyry 208 Soda ash
129 Lithium 169 Potash 209 Sodium Sulfate (mirabilite)
130 Lubricants 170 Potassium Nitrate 210 Solvent (Toluene)
131 Magnesite 171 Pottery Clay 211 Sponge iron
132 Magnesium 172 Pozzolan 212 Steatite
133 Manganese 173 Propane 213 Steel, crude
134 Marble 174 Pumice, pumicite 214 Stone
135 Marl (lime) 175 Pyrite 215 Strontium
136 Mercury 176 Pyrochlore (niobium) 216 Sulfur
137 Methanol 177 Pyrope 217 Sulfuric acid
138 Mica 178 Pyrophyllite (Talc) 218 Talc
139 Moldavite 179 Pyroxenite 219 Tantalum
140 Moler (Diatomite) 180 Quartz and quartzite 220 Tanzanite
141 Molybdenum 181 Rare-earths 221 Tellurium
142 Monazite 182 Refinery gas 222 Tin
143 Naphtha 183 Residual fuel oil 223 Titanium, slag
144 Natural Gas 184 Rhenium 224 Topaz
145 Natural gas liquid 185 Rhodium 225 Tourmaline
146 Nepheline syenite (feldspar) 186 Rhodochrosite 226 Travertine (limestone)
147 Nickel 187 Rock salt 227 Tuff
148 Niobium 188 Ruby 228 Tungsten
149 Nitrogen 189 Ruthenium 229 Ulexite
150 Obsidian 190 Rutile 230 Uranium
151 Olivine 191 Salable crude 231 Vanadium
152 Onyx 192 Salt 232 Vermiculite
153 Palladium 193 Sandstone 233 Volcanic sand
154 Paludal mud (clay) 194 Sapphire 234 White clay (kaolin)
155 Paraffin wax 195 Schist 235 Wollastonite
156 Peat 196 Selenite 236 Zeolite
157 Pentane 197 Selenium 237 Zinc
158 Perlite 198 Sepiolite clay 238 Zirconium
159 Petroleum Crude 199 Serpentine
160 Petroleum Refinery 200 Shale

Table 14 presents the classification of the minerals and metals.

Table 14. Classification of the minerals and metals.
Iron and Ferro-Alloy Metals Non-Ferrous Metals Precious Metals Industrial Minerals Mineral Fuels
Iron Aluminum Gold Asbestos Anthracite
Chromium Antimony Palladium Baryte Bituminous coal
Cobalt Arsenic Platinum Bentonite Coking coal
Manganese Bauxite Rhodium Boron Lignite
Molybdenum Bismuth Silver Diamond Natural Gas
Nickel Cadmium Diatomite Crude Petroleum
Niobium Copper Feldspar Oil Sands
Tantalum Gallium Fluorspar Oil Shales
Titanium Germanium Graphite Uranium
Tungsten Lead Gypsum
Vanadium Lithium Anhydrite
Mercury Kaolin
Rare Earth Minerals Magnesite
Rhenium Perlite
Selenium Phosphates
Tellurium Potash
Tin Salt
Zinc Sulfur
Talc
Vermiculite
Zircon

5.10Database of mineral prices based on the common price mechanism

The database of mineral prices based on a “Common Price mechanism” can be achieved in two different ways as described below:

5.10.1Method 1: average annual price of commodity

In this method, the average of prices from annual price database for a pre-determined time horizon is considered. The basis for establishing the common price of most of the minerals used in the research is the pricing structure sourced from USGS: Mineral Commodity Summaries, Jan 2017 database.

The price per unit by weight of the commodity for the time horizon 2012 to 2016 is considered. The average price for this 5-year time period is considered as base price for establishing the “Common Price” of each mineral.

The database of prices for the minerals as per Method 1: Average annual price of commodity is given below.

Table 15 presents the average common price of minerals (2012–2016).

Table 15. Average common price of minerals (2012–2016).
Commodity Annual Price of Commodity Annual Price of Commodity Annual Price of Commodity Annual Price of Commodity Annual Price of Commodity Avg Price per Unit
Commodity 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Avg Price per Unit
Abrasives 988 1030 1020 584 468 818 USD/T
Aluminum 101 94.2 104.5 88.2 80 93.58 USD/T
Antimony 565 463 425 327 300 416 USD/T
Arsenic 75 72 75 84 88 78.8 USD/T
Asbestos 931 1570 1510 1830 1610 1630 USD/T
Ball (Clay) 46 43 44 46 45 44.8 USD/T
Barite 187 180 191 197 198 190.6 USD/T
Bauxite 28 27 27 28 29 27.8 USD/T
Bentonite 62 65 69 74 74 68.8 USD/T
Bismuth 10.1 8.71 11.14 6.43 4.5 8.176 USD/lbs.
Boron 510 433 372 400 550 453 USD/T
Bromine 3650 4400 4025 USD/T
Cadmium 2030 1920 1940 1050 1735 USD/T
Calcareous 9.73 9.89 10.15 10.57 10.98 10.264 USD/mT
Chalk 115.4 117.8 119.1 120 120 118.46 USD/T
Chromite 381 309 243 217 200 270 USD/T
Clay 12 12 11 13 13 12.2 USD/T
Construction sand 7.65 7.89 8.09 8.58 8.8 8.202 USD/mT
Crushed & broken Stone 9.73 9.89 10.15 10.57 10.98 10.264 USD/mT
Diaspore 563 663 659 579 445 581.8 USD/T
Diatomite 286 293 298 291 294 292.4 USD/T
Dimension stone 154309 171371 169557 124786 87931 141591 USD/mT
Fe content 116.48 87.42 84.43 81.19 82.41 90.386 USD/mT
Feldspar 66 73 66 73 73 70.2 USD/T
Ferromolybdenum 11.955 12.83 12.3925 USD/kg
Fire Clay 27 18 17 14 11 17.4 USD/T
Fluorspar 425 350 310 270 270 325 USD/T
Fuller's Earth 92 88 86 106 99 94.2 USD/T
Gallium 529 502 363 317 400 422.2 USD/Kg
Germanium 1640 1900 1900 1250 950 1528 USD/Kg
Graphite 339 375 360 394 364 366.4 USD/T
Gypsum 8.16 7.6 8.9 8.9 9 8.512 USD/mT
Ilmenite 300 265 155 110 105 187 USD/mT
Indium 540 570 705 520 340 535 USD/kg
Iodine 42.28 42.77 37.04 27.74 23 34.566 USD/kg
Iridium 1066.23 826.45 556.19 544.19 575 713.612 USD/kg
Kaolin 149 146 144 130 132 140.2 USD/T
Kyanite 340 300 260 270 300 294 USD/mT

Table 16 presents the average common price of minerals (2012–2016) (continued).

Table 16. Average common price of minerals (2012–2016) (continued).
Commodity Annual Price of Commodity Annual Price of Commodity Annual Price of Commodity Annual Price of Commodity Annual Price of Commodity Annual Price of Commodity Avg Price per Unit
Commodity 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 per Unit
Lime 115.4 818 119.1 120 120 118.46 118.46 USD/T
Lithium 6060 6800 6690 6500 7400 6690 6690 USD/mT
Magnesium 3170 2615 2325 1825 2400 2467 2467 USD/mT
Mercury 2578 3412 3037 1954 1400 2476.2 2476.2 USD/flask
Mica 281 279 285 290 290 285 285 USD/mT
Molybdenum 28.09 22.85 25.84 15.01 14.5 21.258 21.258 USD/Kg
Natural gas liquid 10.98 9.93 9.65 4.99 5.03 8.114 8.114 USD/MMBtu
Nickel 17533 15018 16865 11831 9298 14109 14109 USD/mT
Niobium 27 27 25 24 20 24.6 24.6 USD/Kg
Nitrogen 579 541 531 481 270 480.4 480.4 USD/T
Palladium 649.27 729.58 809.89 694.99 615 699.746 699.746 USD/kg
Peat 52 55 55 60 61 56.6 56.6 USD/T
Perlite 24.44 25.37 24.97 28.37 27 26.03 26.03 USD/T
Petroleum Crude 103.41 105.43 96.2 50.8 42.8 79.728 79.728 USD/bbl
Phosphate rock 102.54 91.11 78.59 72.41 77 84.33 84.33 USD/T
Pigments, Iron oxide 1.61 1.6 1.58 1.46 1.46 1.542 1.542 USD/kg
Platinum 1555.39 1489.57 1387.89 1056.09 1000 1297.788 1297.788 USD/kg
Potash 650 590 560 570 360 546 546 USD/T
Pumice, pumicite 31.85 34.65 38.52 32.68 33 34.14 34.14 USD/T
Pyrophyllite (Talc) 152 163 171 169 180 167 167 USD/mT
Rhenium 4040 3160 3000 2700 2000 2980 2980 USD/Kg
Rhodium 1274.98 1069.1 1174.23 954.9 670 1028.642 1028.642 USD/kg
Rock salt 110.2 117.5 112.2 113.3 113.3 USD/mT
Ruthenium 112.26 75.63 65.13 47.63 42 68.53 68.53 USD/kg
Salt 169.93 172.09 180.61 185 190 179.526 179.526 USD/T
Selenium 54.47 36.17 26.78 22.09 26 33.102 33.102 USD/T
Silicon 1.27 1.22 1.4 1.27 0.91 1.214 1.214 USD/Kg
Soda ash 141.9 131.71 134.87 140.88 141 138.072 138.072 USD/T
Sodium Sulfate 134 134 134 134 140 135.2 135.2 USD/T
Steatite 152 163 171 169 180 167 167 USD/mT
Stone 9.73 9.89 10.15 10.57 10.98 10.264 10.264 USD/mT
Strontium 50 50 50 51 70 54.2 54.2 USD/T
Sulfur 123.54 68.71 80.07 87.62 78 87.588 87.588 USD/T
Tantalum 239 260 221 193 193 221.2 221.2 USD/Kg
Tellurium 150 112 119 77 34 98.4 98.4 USD/Kg
Titanium, slag 766.5 657.5 741 740 679 716.8 716.8 USD/T
Tungsten 358 358 348 302 142 301.6 301.6 USD/mT
Vanadium 6.49 6.04 5.61 4.16 3.1 5.08 5.08 USD/lbs.
Vermiculite 287.5 335 355 357.5 357.5 338.5 338.5 USD/T
Zeolite 425 425 275 530 530 437 437 USD/mT
Zirconium 64000 91000 75000 59000 86000 75000 75000 USD/T

Method 2: For the remaining minerals, Common Pricing Structure is determined by the price of the mineral as given by the source associated with the pricing of the mineral.

Table 17 presents the other source of common price of minerals.

Table 17. Other source of common price of minerals.
Commodity Avg Unit Source
Acid Clay 250.00 USD/mT https://www.alibaba.com › Minerals & Metallurgy › bleaching earth
Agate 0.50 USD/carat
Aggregates 8.71 USD/T USGS: Mineral Commodity Summaries, 2010-2014 summaries
Alabaster 3.50 USD/lbs. https://www.sculpturehouse.com/s-267-alabaster.aspx
Alexandrite 15000.00 USD/carat
Alginate (sodium) 3750.00 USD/mT https://www.alibaba.com › Chemicals › alginate › sodium alginate
Alumina 283.10 USD/T
Amethyst 25.50 USD/carat https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/value-of-amethyst.
Ammonia 425.00 USD/T farmdocdaily.illinois.edu
Andalusite 40.00 USD/carat www.ebay.com/gds/Andalusite-Gemstone-Value-Price-and-Jewelry/g.html
Anthracite Coal 42.58 USD/T https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/index.cfm?page=coal_prices
Aquamarine 175.00 USD/carat https://www.ajsgem.com/articles/aquamarine-prices.html
Aromatic Tar 425.00 USD/mT https://www.alibaba.com › Energy › oil
Asphalt 117.50 USD/T https://sciencing.com/how-6558396-calculate-asphalt-prices.html
Attapulgite clay 250.00 USD/mT https://www.alibaba.com/showroom/attapulgite-clay-price.html
Avigas 305.62 USD/bbl aviationweek.com/bca/jet-and-avgas-fuel-prices-august-2015 (USD 7.3/gn)
Basalt 92.50 USD/mT https://www.alibaba.com › Construction & Real Estate › basalt
Beryllium 230.00 USD/lbs. www.beresources.ca/AboutBeryllium/BeryllliumPrices.htm
Biotite 450.00 USD/mT https://www.alibaba.com › Minerals & Metallurgy › biotite
Bitumen fuel 404.56 USD/mT https://www.iocl.com/Product_PreviousPrice/BitumenPreviousPrice.aspx
Bituminous 46.70 USD/T https://www.eia.gov/coal/
Blister Copper 4756.00 USD/T https://www.zauba.com/import-blister-copper-hs-code.html (Rs 311/Kg)
Brine, salt 140.00 USD/T www.caryinstitute.org/newsroom/road-salt-winters-23-billion-game-changer
Calcite 165.00 USD/T https://www.alibaba.com/showroom/calcite-prices.html
Calcium carbonate 118.46 USD/T USGS: Mineral Commodity Summaries, Jan 2017
Carbon 26.00 USD/T www.synapse-energy.com/sites/.../2015CarbonDioxidePriceReport.pdf
Caustic Soda 425.00 USD/mT https://www.alibaba.com › Chemicals › soda › caustic soda
Cement 48.75 USD/T Alibaba.com
Clinker 30.80 USD/T www.cwgrp.com/.../434681-fob-prices-for-cement-increase-clinker-prices
Coal 71.39 USD/T
Cobalt 14.21 USD/T
Coke, 200.00 USD/T https://www.alibaba.com/showroom/metallurgical-coke-price.html
Copper 5593.67 USD/T
Copper sulfate 2000.00 USD/mT https://www.alibaba.com › Chemicals › sulphate › copper sulphate
Coquina 45.85 USD/T www.energyprofessional.in/14_8854/crushed-coquina-cost/

(Note: A blank cell in the Source column indicates global internet price)

5.11Final consolidated database of mineral prices

The final consolidated pricing structure for all the 238 minerals is as given below.

Table 18 presents the consolidated database of common price of all minerals.

Table 18. Consolidated database of common price of all minerals.
Commodity Avg Unit Commodity Avg Unit Commodity Avg Unit
Abrasives 818.0 USD/T Cadmium 1735.0 USD/T Ferromanganese 2281.8 USD/T
Acid Clay 250.0 USD/mT Calcareous 10.3 USD/mT Ferromolybdenum 5.6 USD/kg
Agate 0.5 USD/Ct Calcite 165.0 USD/T Ferronickel magnesium 8551.4 USD/T
Aggregates 8.7 USD/T Calcium carbonate (lime) 118.5 USD/T Ferroniobium 33.5 USD/Kg
Alabaster 3.5 USD/lb. Carbon 26.0 USD/T Ferro Phosphorous 612.0 USD/T
Alexandrite 15000.0 USD/carat Caustic Soda 425.0 USD/mT Ferrosilicon 1380.0 USD/T
Alginate (sodium) 3750.0 USD/mT Cement 48.8 USD/T Ferrovanadium 22.6 USD/Kg
Alumina 283.1 USD/T Chalk 118.5 USD/T Fire Clay 17.4 USD/T
Aluminum 424.5 USD/T Chromite 270.0 USD/T Flagstone 400.0 USD/T
Amethyst 25.5 USD/carat Clay 12.2 USD/T Fluorspar 325.0 USD/T
Ammonia 425.0 USD/T Clinker 30.8 USD/T Fuel oil 2.7 USD/gn
Amphibolite (feldspar) 70.2 USD/T Coal 71.4 USD/T Fuller's Earth 94.2 USD/T
Andalusite 40.0 USD/carat Cobalt 14.2 USD/T Gabbro (Dimension stone) 10.3 USD/mT
Anthracite Coal 42.6 USD/T Coke, metallurgical 200.0 USD/T Gallium 422.2 USD/Kg
Antimony 1886.9 USD/T Construction sand 8.2 USD/mT Garnet 365.0 USD/T
Apatite (Phosphate rock) 84.3 USD/T Copper 5593.7 USD/T Gas Oil 56.0 USD/bbl
Aquamarine 175.0 USD/carat Copper sulfate 2000.0 USD/mT Gasoline 170.1 USD/bbl
Aromatic Tar 425.0 USD/mT Coquina 45.9 USD/T Gemstones 2005.0 USD/carat
Arsenic 1737.2 USD/T Cordierite, Iolite 450.0 USD/Mt Gemstones Crude 500.0 USD/carat
Asbestos 1630.0 USD/T Crude Oil 54.4 USD/bbl Geniss (feldspar) 70.2 USD/T
Asphalt 117.5 USD/T Crushed & broken Stone 10.3 USD/mT Germanium 1528.0 USD/Kg
Attapulgite clay 250.0 USD/mT Cyclohexane 1065.0 USD/mT Glauberite 90.0 USD/T
Avigas 305.6 USD/bbl Diamond 1400.0 USD/carat Gold 1223.7 USD/oz
Ball (Clay) 44.8 USD/T Diaspore 581.8 USD/T Granite 242.0 USD/T
Barite 190.6 USD/T Diatomite 292.4 USD/T Graphite 366.4 USD/T
Basalt 92.5 USD/mT Diesel 121.8 USD/bbl Gravel 8.7 USD/mT
Bauxite 27.8 USD/T Dimension stone 10.3 USD/mT Greywacke (sandstone) 130.0 USD/T
Bentonite 68.8 USD/T Distillate fuel oil 151.7 USD/bbl Guano 242.5 USD/mT
Beryllium 230.0 USD/lb. Dolomite 115.0 USD/mT Gypsum 8.5 USD/mT
Biotite 450.0 USD/mT Dunite 46.5 USD/T Helium 3.4 USD/cu m
Bismuth 8.2 USD/lb. Electrolytic, cathode4 220.0 USD/T Igneous rock 6.0 USD/lb.
Bitumen fuel 404.6 USD/mT Emerald 800.0 USD/carat Ilmenite 187.0 USD/mT
Bituminous Coal 46.7 USD/T Ethane 11.8 USD/bbl Indium 535.0 USD/kg
Blister Copper 4756.0 USD/T Fe content 90.4 USD/mT Iodine 34.6 USD/kg
Boron 453.0 USD/T Feldspar 70.2 USD/T Iolite 97.5 USD/carat
Brine, salt 140.0 USD/T Felsite 69.7 USD/mT Iridium 22943.1 USD/kg
Briquets (Peat) 56.6 USD/T Ferro Titanium 3770.0 USD/T Iron 61.9 USD/T
Bromine 4025.0 USD/T Ferrochromium 2480.0 USD/T Iron Oxide pigments 950.0 USD/T
Butane 51.2 USD/bbl Ferrochromium silicon 31325.0 USD/T Jadeite 5000.0 USD/carat
Jasper 33069.4 USD/T Perlite 26.0 USD/T Sepiolite clay 1835.0 USD/T
Kaolin 140.2 USD/T Petroleum Crude 79.7 USD/bbl Serpentine 1250.0 USD/mT
Kerosene and jet fuel 84.3 USD/bbl Petroleum Refinery 47.6 USD/bbl Shale 50.0 USD/bbl
Kyanite 294.0 USD/mT Phosphate rock 84.3 USD/T Silica 107.0 USD/mT
Lead 2169.3 USD/T Phosphatic Fertilizer 425.0 USD/T Siliceous earth 9.3 USD/T
Leonardite 200.0 USD/mT Phosphoric acid 600.0 USD/T Silicomanganese 948.4 USD/T
Leucoxene 778.0 USD/T Phosphorite 125.0 USD/T Silicon 267.6 USD/Kg
Lignite 45.0 USD/mT Pig iron 344.0 USD/T Sillimanite 475.0 USD/T
Lime 118.5 USD/T Pigments, Iron oxide 1.5 USD/kg Silver 17.5 USD/oz.
Limestone 198.0 USD/T Platinum 41724.8 USD/kg Slate 605.0 USD/T
Liquefied petroleum gas 100.2 USD/bbl Porphyry 40.0 USD/kg Soda ash 138.1 USD/T
Lithium 6690.0 USD/mT Potash 546.0 USD/T Sodium Sulfate 135.2 USD/T
Lubricants 545.0 USD/bbl Potassium Nitrate 675.0 USD/mT Solvent (Toluene) 157.5 USD/bbl
Magnesite 130.0 USD/mT Pottery Clay 25.5 USD/T Sponge iron 311.1 USD/T
Magnesium 2467.0 USD/mT Pozzolan 60.0 USD/mT Steatite 167.0 USD/mT
Manganese 187.1 USD/T Propane 68.9 USD/bbl Steel, crude 300.0 USD/mT
Marble 304.0 USD/T Pumice, pumicite 34.1 USD/T Stone 10.3 USD/mT
Marl (lime) 118.5 USD/T Pyrite 475.0 USD/mT Strontium 54.2 USD/T
Mercury 2476.2 USD/flask Pyrochlore (niobium) 24.6 USD/Kg Sulfur 87.6 USD/T
Methanol 549.0 USD/T Pyrope 5000.0 USD/T Sulfuric acid 280.0 USD/mT
Mica 285.0 USD/mT Pyrophyllite (Talc) 167.0 USD/mT Talc 167.0 USD/mT
Moldavite 20000.0 USD/Kg Pyroxenite 54.0 USD/T Tantalum 221.2 USD/Kg
Moler (Diatomite) 292.4 USD/T Quartz and quartzite 220000.0 USD/T Tanzanite 675.0 USD/carat
Molybdenum 21.3 USD/Kg Rare-earths 102712.1 US$/T Tellurium 98.4 USD/Kg
Monazite 9.1 USD/T Refinery gas 84.0 USD/bbl Tin 20638.7 USD/T
Naphtha 549.5 USD/T Residual fuel oil 43.1 USD/bbl Titanium, slag 716.8 USD/T
Natural Gas 3.2 USD/MMBtu Rhenium 2980.0 USD/Kg Topaz 20.0 USD/carat
Natural gas liquid 8.1 USD/MMBtu Rhodium 33071.6 USD/kg Tourmaline 400.0 USD/carat
Nepheline syenite 70.2 USD/T Rhodochrosite 30000.0 USD/Kg Travertine (limestone) 198.0 USD/T
Nickel 14109.0 USD/mT Rock salt 113.3 USD/mT Tuff 923.5 USD/T
Niobium 24.6 USD/Kg Ruby 1650.0 USD/carat Tungsten 301.6 USD/mT
Nitrogen 480.4 USD/T Ruthenium 2203.3 USD/kg Ulexite 754.1 USD/mT
Obsidian 4409.2 USD/T Rutile 822.6 USD/T Uranium 25.7 USD/lb..
Olivine 145.0 USD/T Salable crude 61.5 USD/bbl Vanadium 5.1 USD/lb..
Onyx 599.0 USD/T Salt 179.5 USD/T Vermiculite 338.5 USD/T
Palladium 22497.3 USD/kg Sandstone 130.0 USD/T Volcanic sand 190.0 USD/mT
Paludal mud (clay) 12.2 USD/T Sapphire 4000.0 USD/carat White clay (kaolin) 140.2 USD/T
Paraffin wax 1085.0 USD/mT Schist 75.0 USD/T Wollastonite 360.0 USD/T
Peat 56.6 USD/T Selenite 55000.0 USD/T Zeolite 437.0 USD/mT
Pentane 95.8 USD/bbl Selenium 72977.5 USD/T Zinc 2739.7 USD/T
Zirconium 75000.0 USD/T

Table 19 presents the mineral production (2009–2013) India/cluster Asia.

Table 19. Mineral production (2009–2013) India/cluster Asia.
Commodity Units 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Agate metric tons 20 20 400 500 200
Alumina Metal, primary thousand metric tons 1,598 1,607 1,667 1,700 1,606
Asbestos metric tons 261 262 274 359 267
Ball Clay thousand metric tons 949 1,000 1,500 1,800 1,900
Barite thousand metric tons 2,000 2,300 1,900 1,700 1,200
Bauxite, gross weight thousand metric tons 15,460 14,124 12,723 13,600 15,360
Bentonite metric tons 671,000 561,000 739,000 996,000 1,100,000
Bituminous Coal thousand metric tons 450,000 480,000 500,000 550,000 563,000
Bromine, elemental metric tons 1,500 1,600 1,600 1,700 1,700
Cadmium metal metric tons 550 550 450 450 450
Calcareous (Sand) thousand metric tons 280 285 290 295 290
Calcite metric tons 54,000 41,000 50,000 68,000 87,000
Cement, hydraulic thousand metric tons 205,000 220,000 240,000 270,000 280,000
Chalk metric tons 189,000 179,000 178,000 170,000 136,000
Chromium, chromite thousand metric tons 2,588 4,101 3,274 2,943 2,950
Cobalt metal metric tons 1,001 1,187 1,299 800 295
Copper Mine output metric tons 29,500 35,500 37,700 34,000 36,100
Diamond Gem thousand carats 13 13 16 28 36
Diaspore metric tons 25,000 26,000 24,000 18,000 15,000
Distillate fuel oil thousand 42-gallon barrels 480,000 490,000 500,000 520,000 511,200
Dolomite thousand metric tons 5,800 5,900 5,900 6,600 7,000
Dunite metric tons 66,500 35,700 35,000 75,000 70,000
Electrolytic, cathode Copper metric tons 705,100 654,900 671,100 670,000 680,000
Feldspar metric tons 523,000 503,000 763,000 1,200,000 1,200,000
Felsite metric tons 3,000 2,000 1,300 1,200 700
Ferrochromium, metric tons 873,385 850,000 891,000 1,001,582 903,000
Ferrochromium silicon metric tons 10,000 10,000 11,000 11,000 11,000
Ferromanganese metric tons 399,100 440,000 440,000 402,000 447,000
Ferronickel magnesium metric tons 88 96 107 110 200
Ferrosilicon metric tons 101,337 115,000 127,000 130,000 132,000
Fire clay thousand metric tons 540 780 950 900 740
Fluorspar metric tons 8,786 8,400 8,500 8,600 8,800
Fuller's earth metric tons 29,000 5,600 5,600 5,600 5,600
Garnet thousand metric tons 1,500 2,000 1,800 1,400 700
Gas, Natural Gross million cubic meters 35,000 37,000 38,000 40,000 39,600
Gasoline thousand 42-gallon barrels 125,000 130,000 135,000 137,000 135,000
Gold metal kilograms 2,173 2,320 2,245 1,740 1,570
Graphite metric tons 123,000 118,000 144,000 140,000 143,000
Gypsum thousand metric tons 3,500 4,500 5,200 3,600 3,000
Ilmenite metric tons 675,000 729,000 550,000 340,000 340,000
Iron ore thousand metric tons 217,155 210,006 178,226 144,160 117,000
Jasper metric tons 8,700 8,800 8,900 8,800 8,800
Kaolin thousand metric tons 2,500 2,700 2,900 3,400 4,400
Kerosene and jet fuel thousand 42-gallon barrels 120,000 125,000 130,000 133,000 131,000
Kyanite metric tons 5,300 5,900 4,500 1,800 1,700
Lead Mine output metric tons 62,000 70,000 84,000 100,000 105,000
Lignite Coal thousand metric tons 25,000 27,000 28,000 30,000 27,000
Lime (shell) metric tons 71,000 38,000 33,000 26,000 19,900
Limestone thousand metric tons 230,000 243,000 259,000 275,000 279,000
Liquefied petroleum gas thousand 42-gallon barrels 55,000 58,000 60,000 62,000 61,000
Magnesite metric tons 253,000 301,000 236,000 224,000 213,000
Manganese Ore thousand metric tons 2,374 2,858 2,542 2,225 2,264
Nitrogen, thousand metric tons 10,100 10,600 10,500 10,700 10,800
Petroleum, crude thousand 42-gallon barrels 255,000 260,000 265,000 270,000 265,000
Phosphate rock, thousand metric tons 7,800 6,400 5,500 3,400 2,200
Pig iron thousand metric tons 34,000 38,685 43,600 48,000 51,359
Pyrite, gross weight metric tons 115,000 115,000 110,000 110,000 110,000
Pyrophyllite metric tons 244,000 240,000 252,000 248,000 218,000
Pyroxenite metric tons 280,000 260,000 128,000 62,000 16,000
Rare-earths metric tons 5,000 5,200 5,200 5,400 2,900
Residual fuel oil thousand 42-gallon barrels 140,000 145,000 150,000 152,000 149,000
Rock (Salt) thousand metric tons 2 1 2 2 2
Rutile metric tons 25,000 19,000 19,000 24,000 26,000
Selenite metric tons 14,800 8,700 11,500 8,900 2,300
Selenium kilograms 15,000 15,000 16,000 16,000 16,000
Silica thousand metric tons 2,600 3,200 4,500 4,000 3,400
Silicomanganese metric tons 875,500 1,000,000 1,433,600 1,522,600 1,418,844
Sillimanite metric tons 33,700 45,000 56,600 47,600 57,100
Silver, smelter output kilograms 130,406 145,922 192,434 332,321 355,842
Slate metric tons 14,000 14,500 15,000 15,500 17,000
Soda ash thousand metric tons 1,400 1,500 1,400 1,500 1,500
Steatite, soapstone metric tons 880,000 897,000 974,000 954,000 940,000
Steel Crude thousand metric tons 63,500 69,000 73,500 77,300 81,300
Tin kilograms 59,206 60,236 51,735 48,023 38,082
Uranium metric tons 290 400 400 385 400
Vermiculite metric tons 12,000 17,000 12,000 8,000 10,000
Wollastonite metric tons 127,000 171,000 184,000 152,000 18,000
Zinc ore metric tons 1,260,000 1,400,000 1,350,000 1,400,000 1,493,000
Zirconium concentrate metric tons 32,000 27,800 39,000 40,000 40,000

6Mineral value of a nation

6.1Purpose of this section

In order to postulate a new economic growth indicator, the mineral value is the most critical consideration for this research. This section describes the processes for quantifying this value in terms of economic worth.

The economic worth of a nation is its potential for economic activity. Mineral resources being the DNA of economic activity, its economic worth is the potential based on its mineral content. In this stage, it is proposed to reinforce the “Common Pricing mechanism”, in order to eliminate the economic distortions (inequality) caused by differential pricing.

The stages involved are:

  1. 1. To establish the Conversion factor
  2. 2. To calculate mineral value for the particular commodity
  3. 3. To arrive at the aggregate value of all minerals for a particular nation

6.2Stage 1: conversion factor

Important note: It is observed that the measuring unit for quantity and price for most minerals differ i.e. the unit of measurement of physical quantity differs from the physical unit used for per unit price of minerals.

See table below displaying different units for physical quantity and price.

Table 20 presents the difference in measuring units for quantity and price of minerals.

Table 20. Difference in measuring units for quantity and price of minerals.
Mineral Unit of Physical Quantity Price Unit of Pricing
Alumina thousand metric tons 283.1 USD/T
Diamond thousand carats. 1400.0 USD/carat
Anthracite Coal thousand metric tons 42.6 USD/T
Zirconium metric tons 75000.0 USD/T
Talc (Pyrophyllite) thousand metric tons 167.0 USD/mT
Natural gasoline (butane) million 42-gallon barrels 8.1 USD/MMBtu
Gold metric tons 1223.7 USD/oz
Steel, crude thousand metric tons 300.0 USD/mT
Liquefied petroleum gas thousand 42-gallon barrels 100.2 USD/bbl
Ferrochromium metric tons 2480.0 USD/T
Uranium metric tons 25.7 USD/lbs.

Due to this differentiation, it is necessary to arrive at a common rate of measurement between quantitative and pricing units. This is achieved mathematically through a conversion factor using simple logic and the mensuration tables used in physics.

This “Conversion factor” is presented in a database which is tabulated below.

Table 21 presents the conversion factor table.

Table 21. Conversion factor table.
Measurement Unit Pricing Unit Conversion factor Measurement Unit Pricing Unit Conversion factor
cubic meters T 0.35 flask lbs. 76.00
cubic meters mT 0.39 Ton flask 26.32
kilograms flask 0.02632 Ton carat 5000000
kilograms T 0.00100 Ton bbl 7.35
kilograms ounce 35.27 42-gallon barrels mT 0.14
kilograms bbl 0.007 42-gallon barrels T 0.12
kilograms carat 5000.00 Metric tons mT 1.00
Metric tons carat 5511550 Metric tons Oz. 35274.00
Metric tons flask 29.01 Metric tons bbl 8.10
Metric tons T 1.10 thousand carats Kg 0.20
Metric tons Kg 1102.31 thousand carats T 0.0002205
Metric tons Lbs. 2204.62 thousand carats mT 0.0002
thousand cubic meters MMBtu 42.38 thousand 42-gallon barrels mT 136.00
thousand cubic meters T 353.14 thousand 42-gallon barrels T 123.38
thousand cubic meters mT 388.45 thousand 42-gallon barrels MMBtu 5551.37
million cubic meters MMBtu 42380.00 thousand metric tons barrels 8101.98
million cubic meters bbl 7634.16 thousand metric tons MMBtu 133.47
million cubic meters T 350000.00 thousand metric tons T 1102.31
million cubic meters mT 317515.04

Note: The table may be read as: “Conversion from Unit of Measurement to Unit”. For e.g.,

The Database of “Common Price of all minerals” used in the research is The same is also tabulated below.

Table 22 presents the common price table: All minerals.

Table 22. Common price table: All minerals.
Commodity Avg Unit Commodity Avg Unit Commodity Avg Unit
Acid Clay 250.0 USD/mT Calcite 165.0 USD/T Ferroniobium 33.5 USD/Kg
Agate 0.5 USD/Ct Calcium carbonate 118.5 USD/T FerroPhosphorous 612.0 USD/T
Aggregates 8.7 USD/T Carbon 26.0 USD/T Ferrosilicon 1380.0 USD/T
Alabaster 3.5 USD/lbs. Caustic Soda 425.0 USD/mT Ferrovanadium 22.6 USD/Kg
Alexandrite 15000.0 USD/carat Cement 48.8 USD/T Fire Clay 17.4 USD/T
Alginate 3750.0 USD/mT Chalk 118.5 USD/T Flagstone 400.0 USD/T
Alumina 283.1 USD/T Chromite 270.0 USD/T Fluorspar 325.0 USD/T
Aluminum 424.5 USD/T Clay 12.2 USD/T Fuel oil 2.7 USD/gn
Amethyst 25.5 USD/carat Clinker 30.8 USD/T Fuller's Earth 94.2 USD/T
Ammonia 425.0 USD/T Coal 71.4 USD/T Gabbro 10.3 USD/mT
Amphibolite 70.2 USD/T Cobalt 14.2 USD/T Gallium 422.2 USD/Kg
Andalusite 40.0 USD/carat Coke, met. 200.0 USD/T Garnet 365.0 USD/T
Anthracite Coal 42.6 USD/T Construction sand 8.2 USD/mT Gas Oil 56.0 USD/bbl
Antimony 1886.9 USD/T Copper 5593.7 USD/T Gasoline 170.1 USD/bbl
Apatite 84.3 USD/T Copper sulfate 2000.0 USD/mT Gemstones 2005.0 USD/carat
Aquamarine 175.0 USD/carat Coquina 45.9 USD/T Crude Gemstones 500.0 USD/carat
Aromatic Tar 425.0 USD/mT Cordierite, Iolite 450.0 USD/Mt Geniss 70.2 USD/T
Arsenic 1737.2 USD/T Crude Oil 54.4 USD/bbl Germanium 1528.0 USD/Kg
Asbestos 1630.0 USD/T Crushed Stone 10.3 USD/mT Glauberite 90.0 USD/T
Asphalt 117.5 USD/T Cyclohexane 1065.0 USD/mT Gold 1223.7 USD/oz
Attapulgite clay 250.0 USD/mT Diamond 1400.0 USD/carat Granite 242.0 USD/T
Avigas 305.6 USD/bbl Diaspore 581.8 USD/T Graphite 366.4 USD/T
Ball (Clay) 44.8 USD/T Diatomite 292.4 USD/T Gravel 8.7 USD/mT
Barite 190.6 USD/T Diesel 121.8 USD/bbl Greywacke 130.0 USD/T
Basalt 92.5 USD/mT Dimension stone 10.3 USD/mT Guano 242.5 USD/mT
Bauxite 27.8 USD/T Distillate fuel oil 151.7 USD/bbl Gypsum 8.5 USD/mT
Bentonite 68.8 USD/T Dolomite 115.0 USD/mT Helium 3.4 USD/cu m
Beryllium 230.0 USD/lbs. Dunite 46.5 USD/T Igneous rock 6.0 USD/lbs.
Biotite 450.0 USD/mT Electrolytic 220.0 USD/T Ilmenite 187.0 USD/mT
Bismuth 8.2 USD/lbs. Emerald 800.0 USD/carat Indium 535.0 USD/kg
Bitumen fuel 404.6 USD/mT Ethane 11.8 USD/bbl Iodine 34.6 USD/kg
Bituminous Coal 46.7 USD/T Fe content 90.4 USD/mT Iolite 97.5 USD/carat
Blister Copper 4756.0 USD/T Feldspar 70.2 USD/T Iridium 22943.1 USD/kg
Boron 453.0 USD/T Felsite 69.7 USD/mT Iron 61.9 USD/T
Brine, salt 140.0 USD/T Ferro Titanium 3770.0 USD/T Iron Oxide pig. 950.0 USD/T
Briquets (Peat) 56.6 USD/T Ferrochromium 2480.0 USD/T Jadeite 5000.0 USD/carat
Bromine 4025.0 USD/T Ferro Ch. silicon 31325.0 USD/T Jasper 33069.4 USD/T
Butane 51.2 USD/bbl Ferromanganese 2281.8 USD/T Kaolin 140.2 USD/T
Cadmium 1735.0 USD/T Ferromolybdenum 5.6 USD/kg Kerosene/jet fuel 84.3 USD/bbl
Lead 2169.3 USD/T Phosphate rock 84.3 USD/T Shale 50.0 USD/bbl
Leonardite 200.0 USD/mT Phosphatic Fert 425.0 USD/T Silica 107.0 USD/mT
Leucoxene 778.0 USD/T Phosphoric acid 600.0 USD/T Siliceous earth 9.3 USD/T
Lignite 45.0 USD/mT Phosphorite 125.0 USD/T Silicomanganese 948.4 USD/T
Lime 118.5 USD/T Pig iron 344.0 USD/T Silicon 267.6 USD/Kg
Limestone 198.0 USD/T Pigments, FeO 1.5 USD/kg Sillimanite 475.0 USD/T
Liq. Petroleum gas 100.2 USD/bbl Platinum 41724.8 USD/kg Silver 17.5 USD/oz
Lithium 6690.0 USD/mT Porphyry 40.0 USD/kg Slate 605.0 USD/T
Lubricants 545.0 USD/bbl Potash 546.0 USD/T Soda ash 138.1 USD/T
Magnesite 130.0 USD/mT Potassium Nitro 675.0 USD/mT Sodium Sulfate 135.2 USD/T
Magnesium 2467.0 USD/mT Pottery Clay 25.5 USD/T Toluene 157.5 USD/bbl
Manganese 187.1 USD/T Pozzolan 60.0 USD/mT Sponge iron 311.1 USD/T
Marble 304.0 USD/T Propane 68.9 USD/bbl Steatite 167.0 USD/mT
Marl (lime) 118.5 USD/T Pumice, 34.1 USD/T Steel, crude 300.0 USD/mT
Mercury 2476.2 USD/flask Pyrite 475.0 USD/mT Stone 10.3 USD/mT
Methanol 549.0 USD/T Pyrochlore 24.6 USD/Kg Strontium 54.2 USD/T
Mica 285.0 USD/mT Pyrope 5000.0 USD/T Sulfur 87.6 USD/T
Moldavite 20000.0 USD/Kg Pyrophyllite 167.0 USD/mT Sulfuric acid 280.0 USD/mT
Moler 292.4 USD/T Pyroxenite 54.0 USD/T Talc 167.0 USD/mT
Molybdenum 21.3 USD/Kg Quartz 220000.0 USD/T Tantalum 221.2 USD/Kg
Monazite 9.1 USD/T Rare-earths 102712.1 US$/T Tanzanite 675.0 USD/carat
Naphtha 549.5 USD/T Refinery gas 84.0 USD/bbl Tellurium 98.4 USD/Kg
Natural Gas 3.2 USD/MMBtu Res. fuel oil 43.1 USD/bbl Tin 20638.7 USD/T
Natural gas liquid 8.1 USD/MMBtu Rhenium 2980.0 USD/Kg Titanium, slag 716.8 USD/T
Nepheline syenite 70.2 USD/T Rhodium 33071.6 USD/kg Topaz 20.0 USD/carat
Nickel 14109.0 USD/mT Rhodochrosite 30000.0 USD/Kg Tourmaline 400.0 USD/carat
Niobium 24.6 USD/Kg Rock salt 113.3 USD/mT Travertine 198.0 USD/T
Nitrogen 480.4 USD/T Ruby 1650.0 USD/carat Tuff 923.5 USD/T
Obsidian 4409.2 USD/T Ruthenium 2203.3 USD/kg Tungsten 301.6 USD/mT
Olivine 145.0 USD/T Rutile 822.6 USD/T Ulexite 754.1 USD/mT
Onyx 599.0 USD/T Salable crude 61.5 USD/bbl Uranium 25.7 USD/lbs.
Palladium 22497.3 USD/kg Salt 179.5 USD/T Vanadium 5.1 USD/lbs.
Paludal mud 12.2 USD/T Sandstone 130.0 USD/T Vermiculite 338.5 USD/T
Paraffin wax 1085.0 USD/mT Sapphire 4000.0 USD/carat Volcanic sand 190.0 USD/mT
Peat 56.6 USD/T Schist 75.0 USD/T White clay 140.2 USD/T
Pentane 95.8 USD/bbl Selenite 55000.0 USD/T Wollastonite 360.0 USD/T
Perlite 26.0 USD/T Selenium 72977.5 USD/T Zeolite 437.0 USD/mT
Petroleum Crude 79.7 USD/bbl Sepiolite clay 1835.0 USD/T Zinc 2739.7 USD/T
Petroleum Ref. 47.6 USD/bbl Serpentine 1250.0 USD/mT Zirconium 75000.0 USD/T

6.3Stage 2: economic value of mineral commodities

The economic value for a particular commodity (mineral) is calculated as a simple arithmetic product of quantity produced and its average price, with the conversion factor factored in in order to neutralize the difference in units of measurement.

The product of (i) the quantity of commodity produced, (ii) the average price, and (iii) the Conversion factor, gives the economic value of that commodity.

Consider the example of the mineral (commodity): Aluminum

Table 23 presents the economic value: Mineral aluminum.

Table 23. Economic value: Mineral aluminum.
Commodity Aluminum Aluminum Aluminum Aluminum Aluminum
Year Economy Production Unit Avg price Conversion Factor Mineral Value
Year Economy thousand mT USD/lbs. Conversion Factor (US$ mn)
2012 USA 2070 0.94 2204620.00 4270.58
2013 USA 1946 0.94 2204620.00 4014.76
2014 USA 1710 0.94 2204620.00 3527.87
2015 USA 1587 0.94 2204620.00 3274.11
2016 USA 840 0.94 2204620.00 1732.99
Year Economy mT USD/Ton CF (US$ mn)
2012 UK 208,800 283.10 1.10231 65.16
2013 UK 192,800 283.10 1.10231 60.17
2014 UK 191,000 283.10 1.10231 59.60
Year Economy thousand mT USD/Ton CF (US$ mn)
2012 China 47,000 27.80 1102.31 1440.28
2013 China 50,400 27.80 1102.31 1544.47
2014 China 65,000 27.80 1102.31 1991.87
Year Economy thousand mT USD/Ton CF (US$ mn)
2012 Saudi Arabia 426 283.10 1102.31 132.94
2013 Saudi Arabia 187 283.10 1102.31 58.36
2014 Saudi Arabia 665 283.10 1102.31 207.52
Year Economy mT USD/Ton CF (US$ mn)
2012 Argentina 413,395 424.47 1.10 193.43
2013 Argentina 440,176 424.47 1.10 205.96
2014 Argentina 442,900 424.47 1.10 207.23

Note

  1. 1. The production unit of UK and Argentina (mT) is different from that of other nations (thousand mT).
  2. 2. The pricing unit of USA is USD/lbs., whereas for other nations it is USD/T.
  3. 3. Consequently, the conversion factor differs for different nations.
  4. 4. Hence the need for Common Pricing is justified.

6.4Stage 3: aggregate economic value of all minerals for a particular nation

In this part, the economic value of all minerals for a given nation is calculated.

Step 1: Database of all minerals for USA (2012-2016) is tabulated below:

Table 24 presents the mineral production – USA (2012–2016).

Table 24. Mineral production – USA (2012–2016).
Commodity Unit 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Magnesium thousand mT 341 324 342 380 390
Steel million mT 88.7 86.9 88.2 78.8 80
Tripoli thousand mT 120000 110000 93100 70500 93857
Calcium carbonate million mT 1180 1180 1250 1330 1480
Crushed stone million mT 1180 1180 1250 1330 1480
Granite million mT 1180 1180 1250 1330 1480
Sandstone million mT 1180 1180 1250 1330 1480
Traprock million mT 1180 1180 1250 1330 1480
Crushed stone million mT 1180 1180 1180 1180 1180
Gold mT 235 230 210 214 209
Copper thousand mT 1170 1250 1360 1380 1410
Salt thousand mT 37200 39900 45300 45000 42000
Cement thousand mT 67173 69420 74372 76000 77000
Sand, Gravel million mT 812 847 897 937 1010
Sand and Gravel million mT 812 847 897 937 1010
Tin mT 13640 12750 12000 12500 12100
Nitrogen thousand mT 8730 9170 9330 9590 9800
Aluminum thousand mT 2070 1946 1710 1587 840
Phosphate rock thousand mT 30100 31200 25300 27400 27800
Lime thousand mT 18800 19200 19500 18300 17000
Zinc thousand mT 999 1017 1012 997 920
Iron and Steel million mT 30.1 30.3 29.4 25.4 23
Soda ash thousand mT 11100 11500 11700 11600 11700
Alumina thousand mT 4370 4320 4460 4540 2500
Titanium dioxide mT 1140000 1280000 1260000 1220000 1200000
Diamond industrial million carats 80.5 84.1 96.7 103.5 108.3
Molybdenum mT 60400 61000 68200 47400 31600
Silicon thousand mT 390 392 401 411 396
Sulfur thousand mT 9000 9210 9630 9540 9780
Silver mT 1060 1040 1180 1090 1100

Note: Cells in yellow highlights are average values based on previous data.

Step 2: The database of average price (of 2012-2016 prices) of all minerals for USA and the conversion factor (in italics) to neutralize differentiation in measuring and pricing units is given below:

Table 25 presents the average price of minerals/conversion factor – USA (2012–2016).

Table 25. Average price of minerals/conversion factor – USA (2012–2016).
USA: PRICE OF MINERALS USA: PRICE OF MINERALS USA: PRICE OF MINERALS USA: PRICE OF MINERALS USA: PRICE OF MINERALS USA: PRICE OF MINERALS USA: PRICE OF MINERALS USA: PRICE OF MINERALS Conversion Factor
Commodity 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Avg price Unit Conversion Factor
Magnesium 199.50 USD/Kg 1102310
Steel 545.00 USD/mT 1000000
Tripoli 280.00 USD/Kg 1000
Calcium carbonate 9.73 9.9 10.15 10.57 10.98 10.26 USD/mT 1000000
Crushed stone 9.73 9.9 10.15 10.57 10.98 10.26 USD/mT 1000000
Granite 9.73 9.9 10.15 10.57 10.98 10.26 USD/mT 1000000
Sandstone 10.26 USD/mT 1000000
Traprock 10.26 USD/mT 1000000
Crushed stone 9.73 9.9 10.15 10.57 10.98 10.26 USD/mT 1000000
Gold 1673 1415.0 1269 1163 1270 1358.00 USD/tr oz 35274
Copper 3.673 3.4 3.181 2.562 2.2 3.00 USD/lbs. 2204620
Salt 169.93 172.09 180.61 185 190 179.53 USD/T 1102.31
Cement 89.5 95.0 100.5 105.5 111 100.30 USD/T 1102.31
Sand, Gravel 7.65 7.9 8.09 8.58 8.8 8.20 USD/mT 1000000
Sand and Gravel 7.65 7.89 8.09 8.58 8.8 8.20 USD/mT 1000000
Tin 973.5 10.265 10.085 7.425 7.575 201.77 USD/lbs. 2204.62
Nitrogen 579 541 531 481 270 480.40 USD/T 1102.31
Aluminum 1.01 0.9 1.045 0.882 0.8 0.94 USD/lbs. 2204620
Phosphate rock 102.54 91.11 78.59 72.41 77 84.33 USD/T 1102.31
Lime 115.4 117.8 119.1 120 120 118.46 USD/T 1102.31
Zinc 0.9205 0.911 1.026 0.9155 0.955 0.95 USD/lbs. 2204620
Iron and Steel 71.53 USD/mT 1000000
Soda ash 141.9 131.71 134.87 140.88 141 138.07 USD/T 1102.31
Alumina 374 368.0 394 400 360 379.20 USD/T 1102.31
Titanium dioxide 1250.00 USD/mT 1
Diamond industrial 15.3 15.5 14.4 17.5 16.8 15.90 USD/ct. 1000000
Molybdenum 28.09 22.85 25.84 15.01 14.5 21.26 USD/Kg 1102.31
Silicon 1.27 1.22 1.4 1.27 0.91 1.21 USD/lbs. 2204620
Sulfur 123.54 68.71 80.07 87.62 78 87.59 USD/T 1102.31
Silver 31.22 23.87 19.37 15.72 19.62 21.96 USD/tr oz 35274

Step 3: The database of the economic value all minerals for the time period 2012 to 2016 for USA is calculated as a product of

(i) quantity extracted, (ii) Average price, and (iii) Conversion factor

The same is tabulated below:

Table 26 presents the economic value of all minerals – USA (2012–2016).

Table 26. Economic value of all minerals – USA (2012–2016).
Commodity 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Magnesium 74989.60 71251.11 75209.51 83566.12 85765.23
Steel 48341.50 47360.50 48069.00 42946.00 43600.00
Tripoli 33600.00 30800.00 26068.00 19740.00 26280.00
Calcium carbonate 12111.52 12111.52 12830.00 13651.12 15190.72
Crushed stone 12111.52 12111.52 12830.00 13651.12 15190.72
Granite 12111.52 12111.52 12830.00 13651.12 15190.72
Sandstone 12111.52 12111.52 12830.00 13651.12 15190.72
Traprock 12111.52 12111.52 12830.00 13651.12 15190.72
Crushed stone 12111.52 12111.52 12111.52 12111.52 12111.52
Gold 11256.99 11017.48 10059.44 10251.05 10011.54
Copper 7745.95 8275.59 9003.84 9136.25 9334.87
Salt 7361.63 7895.94 8964.57 8905.20 8311.52
Cement 7426.76 7675.19 8222.69 8402.69 8513.25
Sand, Gravel 6660.02 6947.09 7357.19 7685.27 8284.02
Sand and Gravel 6660.02 6947.09 7357.19 7685.27 8284.02
Tin 6067.43 5671.53 5337.91 5560.33 5382.40
Nitrogen 4622.97 4855.97 4940.70 5078.38 5189.59
Aluminum 4270.58 4014.76 3527.87 3274.11 1732.99
Phosphate rock 2798.03 2900.28 2351.83 2547.04 2584.23
Lime 2454.90 2507.13 2546.30 2389.61 2219.85
Zinc 2082.60 2120.13 2109.70 2078.43 1917.91
Iron and Steel 2153.05 2167.36 2102.98 1816.86 1645.19
Soda ash 1689.40 1750.28 1780.72 1765.50 1780.72
Alumina 1826.64 1805.74 1864.26 1897.70 1044.99
Titanium dioxide 1425.00 1600.00 1575.00 1525.00 1500.00
Diamond industrial 1279.95 1337.19 1537.53 1645.65 1721.97
Molybdenum 1415.35 1429.41 1598.12 1110.72 740.48
Silicon 1043.80 1049.15 1073.24 1100.00 1059.86
Sulfur 868.94 889.22 929.77 921.08 944.25
Silver 821.09 805.60 914.05 844.33 852.08

6.5Stage 4: total mineral value of nations

USA: Mineral Value of USA (2012-2016, in USD mn) is appended below:

Table 27 presents the mineral value of USA (2012–2016).

Table 27. Mineral value of USA (2012–2016).
USA 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Total Mineral Value (USD mn) 396391 391276 392487 388740 402423

6.5.1Algeria

Algeria: A few select minerals and their “Economic Value” (in USD mn) for the years 2010, 2012, and 2014 is given below:

Table 28 presents the mineral database for Algeria (2010, 2012, 2014).

Table 28. Mineral database for Algeria (2010, 2012, 2014).
Commodity Units Qty 2010 Qty 2012 Qty 2014 Avg price Unit of price Conv. factor Value 2010 (USD mn) Value 2012 (USD mn) Value 2014 (USD mn)
Aggregates 000 cubic meters 25,381 72,040 80,905 8.7 USD/T 353.14 78.07 221.58 248.85
Barite, crude metric tons 42,254 36,211 56,829 190.6 USD/T 1.10 8.88 7.61 11.94
Bentonite metric tons 34,126 26,278 31,510 68.8 USD/T 1.10 2.59 1.99 2.39
Bitumen 000 42-gn barrels 1,279 1,060 1,000 404.6 USD/mT 136.00 70.37 58.32 55.02
Calcite 000 metric tons 339 232 335 165.0 USD/T 1102.31 61.58 42.16 60.85
Cement, hydraulic 000 metric tons 19,100 19,000 21,000 48.8 USD/T 1102.31 1026.39 1021.01 1128.49
Common Clay metric tons 10,973 10,167 12,467 12.2 USD/T 1.10 0.15 0.14 0.17
Construction sand 000 cubic meters 3,164 2,898 2,998 8.2 USD/mT 388.45 10.08 9.23 9.55
Crushed stone 000 cubic meters 114 287 203 10.3 USD/mT 388.45 0.45 1.15 0.81
Diatomite metric tons 2,104 2,398 2,426 292.4 USD/T 1.10 0.68 0.77 0.78
Distillate fuel oil 000 42-gn barrels 55,618 51,474 69,496 151.7 USD/bbl 1000.00 8436.69 7808.09 10541.8
Dolomite metric tons 2,260 743 60 115.0 USD/mT 1.00 0.26 0.09 0.01
Feldspar 000 metric tons 164 163 230 70.2 USD/T 1102.31 12.69 12.59 17.83
Gas, natural mn cubic meters 275,579 267,794 214,200 3.2 USD/MMBtu 42380.00 36968.05 35923.72 28734.25
Gasoline, normal 000 42-gn barrels 17,436 18,944 23,105 170.1 USD/bbl 1000.00 2966.15 3222.69 3930.5
Gold, mine output kilograms 723 264 85 1223.7 USD/oz. 35.27 31.21 11.40 3.67
Gypsum 000 metric tons 1,610 1,958 2,130 8.5 USD/mT 1000.00 13.70 16.67 18.13
Helium, liquid million cubic meters 17 17 25 3.4 USD/cu m 1000000 57.72 57.72 84.88
Iron 000 metric tons 2,240 2,730 1,394 61.9 USD/T 1102.31 152.74 186.14 95.06
Kaolin metric tons 71,065 100,97 181,06 140.2 USD/T 1.10 10.98 15.60 27.98
Kerosene/ jet fuel 000 42-gn barrels 11,050 9,600 15,403 84.3 USD/bbl 1000.00 930.96 808.80 1297.70
Lime, hydraulic 000 metric tons 63 66 49 118.5 USD/T 1102.31 8.23 8.62 6.46
Limestone 000 metric tons 20,000 20,000 24,880 198.0 USD/T 1102.31 4365.15 4365.15 5430.20
Liquefied petroleum gas 000 42-gn barrels 90,874 76,572 95,120 100.2 USD/bbl 1000.00 9102.12 7669.61 9527.41

Note: Due to constraints of displayable space, the database is presented for given three years.

Explanation

  1. 1. The quantity extracted in 2010 of Liquefied Petroleum Gas is 90,874,000 42-gallon barrels.
  2. 2. The Average (Common) Price of Liquefied Petroleum Gas is 100.2 USD per 42-gallon barrel.
  3. 3. The conversion factor is 1000.
  4. 4. Economic value of LPG in 2010 is 9102.12 USD mn (90,874 * 100.2 * 1000 = 9102.12).
  5. 5. For 2012 & 2014 it is 7669.61 USD mn and 9527.41 USD mn respectively

Economic value for all minerals for Algeria is tabulated below:

Table 29 presents the economic value of minerals – Algeria (2010–2014).

Table 29. Economic value of minerals – Algeria (2010–2014).
Commodity 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Aggregates, crushed stone, gravel 78.07 169.17 221.58 224.22 248.85
Barite, crude 8.88 8.40 7.61 6.35 11.94
Bentonite 2.59 2.20 1.99 2.10 2.39
Bitumen 70.37 58.21 58.32 55.02 55.02
Calcite 61.58 61.58 42.16 48.57 60.85
Cement, hydraulic 1026.39 1021.01 1021.01 994.15 1128.49
Common Clay 0.15 0.15 0.14 0.16 0.17
Construction sand 10.08 13.06 9.23 8.39 9.55
Crushed stone 0.45 0.47 1.15 0.95 0.81
Diatomite 0.68 0.69 0.77 0.72 0.78
Distillate fuel oil 8436.69 8442.16 7808.09 7968.73 10541.85
Dolomite 0.26 0.26 0.09 0.01 0.01
Feldspar 12.69 11.45 12.59 20.02 17.83
Gas, natural 36968.05 36513.02 35923.72 35016.61 28734.25
Gasoline, normal 2966.15 3375.28 3222.69 3099.18 3930.54
Gold, mine output 31.21 19.38 11.40 6.04 3.67
Gypsum 13.70 13.70 16.67 17.69 18.13
Helium, liquid 57.72 57.72 57.72 84.88 84.88
Iron 152.74 137.26 186.14 111.26 95.06
Kaolin 10.98 10.98 15.60 6.57 27.98
Kerosene and jet fuel 930.96 749.24 808.80 1144.45 1297.70
Lime, hydraulic 8.23 8.23 8.62 6.27 6.46
Limestone 4365.15 4365.15 4365.15 4786.82 5430.20
Liquefied petroleum gas 9102.12 8349.31 7669.61 7682.33 9527.41
Lubricants 576.61 447.45 1144.50 1144.50 1362.50
Methanol 56.28 71.17 67.78 47.43 54.47
Naphtha 4134.70 3865.48 3532.20 3644.33 3667.72
Natural gas plant liquids 2616.00 2289.48 2033.00 2081.02 2079.28
Nitrogen 317.73 314.02 377.57 328.32 820.80
Petroleum, Crude 49151.12 47783.38 44727.81 45833.63 44378.60
Phosphate rock 184.36 155.50 151.08 139.06 171.32
Pig iron 263.92 136.51 132.72 113.76 113.76
Pozzolan 14.22 8.46 19.50 23.29 18.88
Residual fuel oil 2106.51 2145.03 1363.69 1537.69 2192.56
Salt, brine and sea salt 21.21 47.10 35.32 34.22 38.19
Silica sand 0.97 1.02 1.28 1.54 1.74
Silver 0.09 0.06 0.03 0.02 0.01
Steel 395.70 328.80 332.10 261.60 247.50
Stone 0.04 0.04 0.06 0.07 0.13
Sulfur 8.30 8.30 8.30 8.30 8.30
Tuff 593.31 554.43 554.43 554.43 554.43
Zinc 64.98 49.22 50.43 62.51 68.55

Total Economic Value (2010-2014) for all minerals for Algeria, i.e. the total Mineral value of Algeria is given below:

Table 30 presents the mineral value of Algeria (2010–2014).

Table 30. Mineral value of Algeria (2010–2014).
ALGERIA: Statistics 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Total Mineral Value (USD mn) 124822 121594 116003 117107 117014

6.6Summary of the database of mineral value of 64 nations

Summary of the Economic Worth (Mineral Value) for all the 64 nations used in the research for the time period 2010 to 2013 is appended below for ready reference.

Table 31 presents the mineral value of all nations (2010–2013).

Table 31. Mineral value of all nations (2010–2013).
Sr. No Mineral Value (USD mn) 2010 2011 2012 2013
1 United States 340271 358312 397016 359668
2 China 34787250 41075086 34635730 39740951
3 Japan 447848 462763 430174 345223
4 Germany 869243 882329 883093 865908
5 United Kingdom 655951 649894 588006 588958
6 India 260797 270026 279877 277234
7 France 109985 107583 96147 97871
8 Brazil 1773281 1890668 1925578 1939853
9 Italy 254909 252443 252441 216594
10 Canada 1101688 1153411 1247554 1416651
11 Russia 9760917 10103695 10863288 11643462
12 Korea 989786 1002065 1145949 1146753
13 Australia 221395 245874 234806 226740
14 Spain 1165297 1127343 881483 839692
15 Indonesia 1089 1049 1123 801
16 Mexico 3764874 4381572 4511042 4377408
17 Turkey 1303608 1090486 1223343 1099964
18 Netherlands 76003 74062 72652 72692
19 Saudi Arabia 457802 491439 451689 484879
20 Switzerland 101975 116628 98800 134277
21 Argentina 847272 877807 560316 553222
22 Taiwan 21094 22954 21334 22201
23 Sweden 1278103 1181653 1320945 1333508
24 Poland 3209459 3213026 3216311 3233018
25 Belgium 37138 35598 34987 35384
26 Thailand 147295 179833 248342 274156
27 United Arab Emirates 108744 126193 128449 136213
28 Nigeria 101455 99351 100897 97817
29 Norway 413596 437272 407472 376504
30 Austria 98985 98184 105063 104512
31 Islamic Republic of Iran 657286 721138 728533 715929
32 Israel 19672 19531 19534 19530
33 Philippines 14902 16864 20855 27646
34 South Africa 8431704 8289183 7296733 8195571
35 Malaysia 70935 71931 71466 68997
36 Colombia 47841 52375 54939 54706
37 Denmark 16022 14808 15028 14126
38 Ireland 1040709 1044782 1025009 993042
39 Egypt 86656 88746 81918 79369
40 Venezuela 940330 942309 940150 873185
41 Pakistan 48344 31609 34130 34242
42 Chile 278025 268427 253069 248712
43 Bangladesh 5413 5629 5319 5275
44 Central America 4912 5167 4711 5543
45 Finland 76329 87862 75344 76927
46 Vietnam 31600 32450 33006 32139
47 Peru 73011 74797 66389 68625
48 Portugal 41035 41299 39383 38450
49 New Zealand 7575 6866 7011 7149
50 Czech Republic 74208 84949 58516 56866
51 Greece 25032 20683 20497 18812
52 Romania 60351 47716 50589 50917
53 Iraq 92313 105654 114915 117046
54 Algeria 124822 121594 116003 117107
55 Qatar 105640 121128 128637 134091
56 Kazakhstan 80119 83849 87805 89185
57 Kuwait 107397 118067 121992 126111
58 Hungary 14270 14185 14468 13498
59 Kenya 124587 143251 152042 180204
60 Luxembourg 1409 1493 1335 1324
61 Tanzania 6607536 3103774 3078647 3257143
62 Bahrain 17684 17295 17523 16889
63 Zimbabwe 14089 14525 19582 17455
64 Central African Republic 7 7 8 5

This mineral value is the Most critical element in calculating the proposed Gross National Resource Product (GNRP)

7Critical economic data of all nations

7.1Purpose of the section

In order to calculate the proposed new Economic Growth Indicator, the required economic data critical to economic growth of a nation is:

Note: While the GDP is a measure of economic wealth of a nation acquired as a result of economic activity for a given time period, and population is considered as a multiplicative factor for boosting economic growth, land revenue is considered to be the basis for economic activity i.e. the “economic potential” of the nation.

The concept of GDP is used in this research is to compare this existing measure of economic growth with the new proposed economic growth indictor which measures economic potential of nation. This comparison is necessary to achieve two purposes:

  1. 1. To curb excess economic growth through common distribution mechanism (equalize GDP with GNRP);
  2. 2. To regulate utilization of natural resources (optimize economic potential).

For this research study, land revenue is sub-divided into sub-soil (Mineral) and supra-soil (Agriculture) Revenue.

In earlier section we have already arrived at the database of mineral value of all 64 nations used in the research. In this section, the database of the other critical economic elements (GDP, Agriculture Revenue, and Population) are collated for the 64 nations. The time period is the same as for mineral value of nations. i.e. 2010 to 2013.

7.2Gross domestic product (GDP)

GDP is a national accounting measure for economic growth. GDP is a measure of overall economic activity, co-existing and co-varying with many other economic variables. The GDP database for the 64 nations for the time period 2010-2013 is given below:

Table 32 presents the database of GDP values of 64 nations (2010–2013).

Table 32. Database of GDP values of 64 nations (2010–2013).
Sr No Country GDP 2010 (USD mn) GDP 2011 (USD mn) GDP 2012 (USD mn) GDP 2013 (USD mn)
1 USA 14964372 15517926 16155255 16691517
2 China 6100620 7572554 8560547 9607224
3 Japan 5700098 6157460 6203213 5155717
4 Germany 3417095 3757698 3543984 3752514
5 UK 2429680 2608825 2646003 2719509
6 India 1656617 1823050 1827638 1856722
7 France 2646837 2862680 2681416 2808511
8 Brazil 2208872 2616202 2465189 2472807
9 Italy 2125058 2276292 2072823 2130491
10 Canada 1613464 1788648 1824289 1842628
11 Russia 1524916 2031769 2170144 2230625
12 Korea 1094499 1202464 1222807 1305605
13 Australia 1142877 1390557 1538194 1567179
14 Spain 1431588 1488017 1335946 1361776
15 Indonesia 755094 892969 917870 912524
16 Mexico 1051129 1171188 1186598 1261982
17 Turkey 771877 832546 873982 950596
18 Netherlands 836390 893757 828947 866680
19 Saudi Arabia 528207 671239 735975 746647
20 Switzerland 581209 696279 665054 684835
21 Argentina 423627 530163 545982 552025
22 Taiwan 377529 428186 465187 475257
23 Sweden 488378 563110 543881 578742
24 Poland 479321 528820 500344 524215
25 Belgium 483549 527008 497884 520117
26 Thailand 341105 370819 397560 420529
27 UAE 289880 350908 374818 390427
28 Nigeria 369062 411744 460954 514966
29 Norway 428527 498157 509705 522746
30 Austria 390212 429037 407452 428248
31 Iran 467790 592038 587209 511621
32 Israel 233755 261375 257642 293315
33 Philippines 199591 224143 250092 271836
34 South Africa 375349 416419 396328 366624
35 Malaysia 255017 297952 314443 323277
36 Colombia 287018 335415 369660 380192
37 Denmark 321995 344003 327149 343584
38 Ireland 221343 240591 225819 239271
39 Egypt 218888 236002 279373 288586
40 Venezuela 393191 316482 381286 371006
41 Pakistan 177407 213587 224384 231219
42 Chile 218538 252252 267122 278384
43 Bangladesh 115279 128638 133356 149990
44 Central America 153541 174915 189691 202286
45 Finland 247800 273674 256706 269980
46 Vietnam 115932 135539 155820 171222
47 Peru 147529 171762 192649 201218
48 Portugal 238303 244895 216368 226073
49 New Zealand 146581 168462 176193 190521
50 Czech Republic 207016 227948 207376 209402
51 Greece 299362 287798 245671 239862
52 Romania 167998 185363 171665 191549
53 Iraq 138517 185750 218001 234648
54 Algeria 161207 200013 209047 209784
55 Qatar 125122 167775 186834 198728
56 Kazakhstan 148047 192627 207999 236635
57 Kuwait 115419 154028 174070 174161
58 Hungary 130256 140092 127321 134680
59 Kenya 40000 41953 50413 55097
60 Luxembourg 53212 60005 56678 61808
61 Tanzania 31408 33879 39088 44333
62 Bahrain 25713 29157 30749 32899
63 Zimbabwe 10052 12072 14058 15224
64 Central Africa 1986 2213 2184 1519

Source of data: The World Bank

8Relationship between ecology and economy

The relationship between ecology and economy is best summed by Mike Nickerson in his book “Planning for Seven Generations” (1993) xxvii wherein he states:

8.1Economy is three-fifths of ecology

The progress of mankind can be charted on three axes- Social, Economic and Environmental. Economy is a subset of human society, and society in turn is wholly contained within the biophysical environment of the planet (see figure 1.A)

Figure 2 shows the embedded structure of ecology.

Embedded structure of ecology.
Figure 2. Embedded structure of ecology.

Table 33 presents the comparison of environmental vs ecological economics.

Table 33. Comparison of environmental vs ecological economics.
Environmental Economics Ecological Economics
applies tools of economics to address environmental problems focuses on long-term environmental sustainability, issues of scale, nature, justice, and time (Malte Faber xxv)
mainstream economic analysis of the environment addresses interdependence and coevolution of human economies and natural ecosystems over time and space
Emphasizes cost-benefit analysis Emphasizes upon preserving natural capital, non-substitutable by human capital
Stresses separability of economic values from scientific research Stresses on strong sustainability and positional analysis
technological optimists technological sceptics
welfare economics well-being economics

8.2Nature and ecology

Ecological economics consists of a complex circular flow of inputs in the form of natural resources and environmental services used as units of production. Once consumed, natural inputs pass out of the economy as pollution and waste. This concept is useful in understanding the planet as a closed economic system with natural resources as the input into the business cycle, and GDP as indicator of economic wealth produced as output.

Figure 3 shows the planet Earth: closed economic system.

Planet Earth: closed economic system.
Figure 3. Planet Earth: closed economic system.

8.3Economic valuation of the global ecosystem

This research attempts to evaluate world economy in order to arrive at a universal solution for global economic problems. The economic value of natural capital and ecosystem services is accepted by both environmental and ecological economics. The prerequisite condition is to maintain a stable environment before assessing the cost in dollar terms. This idea is central to the research undertaken, wherein a steady economic-environmental equilibrium state is proposed after valuation of the natural resources.

In 1997, Robert Costanza attempted valuation of the global ecosystem at $33 trillion with a range from $16 trillion to $54 trillion. In 1997, total global GDP was $27 trillion. The work was criticized by articles in Ecological Economics, Volume 25, Issue 1, but the critics acknowledged the positive potential for economic valuation of the global ecosystem.

The research evaluates management concepts of utility, efficiency, and cost-benefits such as positional analysis or multi-criteria analysis for sustainable development. It singularly addresses the underlying problems associated with mainstream economics such as growth, market capitalism and monetary valuation of the environment. A more meaningful relationship with nature and the non-human world is established, overriding shallow ecology (defn 40) and commodification of everything external to the market system.

Conclusion: This section addresses the topic of Environmental Economics as a broad area covering the symbiotic relationship between ecology and economy. The concept of the planet as a closed economic system is presented in this section.

9Basic critical economic concepts discussed in the research

A brief review of the socio-economic concepts and issues dealt with during this research process is presented in this section, offering a holistic view of the research problem. This section covers the role of economics as a science, and economic activity as an anthropogenic function. An insight is offered into basic economic concepts like indicators of economic growth and their inadequacy, economic growth models, role of aggregation in economics, and the role of national accounting systems (SNA). The relation between economics and environment is explained in this section. Finally, the concept of sustainable growth is introduced.

9.1Role of economic activity in human development

The anthropocentric aim of economic activity is maximizing profit. Adam Smith (1776) expounds the profit-only theory, while John Maynard Keynes (1936) propagates a more socioeconomic viewpoint. Economic activity enhances wealth and consumerism and increases well-being and prosperity.

Environmentalists consider ‘human well-being in the present and future’ as the final goal of economic systems.

Synergetic economic effects of cities extend to nation-state, successively forming medieval city economies, then national economies, and finally the phenomenon of “globalization” (Polanyi, 1957).

9.2Economic growth and development

The scale of world economy in 1900 was USD 600 bn/year. At present, it is USD 16 trillion/year, expected to be 5 times by the next generation (source: WCED 1987, Brundtland commission).

The evolutionary anthropocentric growth engine considers environment as an infinite resource-provider for growth, and a perennial sink for waste and pollutants.

Hsieh and Hsing determine that economic growth brings mixed outcomes and is prerequisite to achieving the utopian state of economic equality. William Lyakurwa stresses the need to integrate development, climate change and environmental sustainability. Emil Urhammer states that economic growth is a powerful agent that determines policies regarding issues such as climate change, loss of biodiversity and pollution.

9.3Defining economic growth

In the course of the history of anthropogenic development, mankind has reached a stage where economic growth is good for “economic” development, but unhealthy for “human” development. This economic growth is merely a market-friendly development which favors the rich and remains perennially unfair to the marginalized poor.

Economics is the art of managing resources.

Resources are necessary for growth. Managing resources is necessary because they are finite and scarce. Growth must therefore be limited.

Management of people, of businesses, of economy, is an outward, unattached, dis-involved process of man’s outlook towards human growth and happiness. Managing of resources, on the other hand, is an inward, attached, involved process that creates harmony between man and nature, the primary stakeholders.

The ultimate purpose of growth is happiness of mankind. An integrated approach is necessary to achieve this goal.

Ecological Economics defines growth as a quantitative increase in economic output, and development as a qualitative improvement of the quality of life. But beyond modest levels, increased per-capita consumption does not lead to improvement in human well-being; rather it has harmful effects on the environment and social well-being on a larger scale. Economic and environmental objectives are often considered as contradictory, but this thesis attempts to prove that they can be achieved concurrently; i.e. economy and environment can go together.

In the context of this study, a business cycle is no more a cycle, but a race. It is an unending competition, wherein the nations with the highest GDP is the winner, and the ones with lower GDP remain marginalized, unless and until they obtain hefty loans from the IMF and the WB, just to remain significant in the (human) race. Thus, they are perennially entrapped in the vicious circle of poverty.

9.4Real purpose of economic growth

Economic system enhances wealth and consumerism. Satisfaction of wants must lead to happiness. Instead, it is observed globally that there is misery due to skewed patterns of consumption and distribution of wealth.

Table 34 presents the desirable and undesirable effects of modern economic systems.

Table 34. Desirable and undesirable effects of modern economic systems.
Undesirable Effects Desirable Effects
Greater inequality Well-being of those deprived
Environmentally harmful Resource conservation
Socially undesirable Produce happiness

Environmentalists consider ‘human well-being in the present and future’ as the final goal of economic systems. Increased production and consumption are mere intermediaries.

Happiness is only marginally related to wealth; what matters are personality traits, security, relativity and temporal adjustments to changes in circumstances, and fairness in resource distribution. Human well-being is characterized by security, happiness, fairness, freedom, and participation. Sustainable development means undertaking economic activities that maintain or increase essential capital stock necessary for production.

The three Growth Goals are:

9.5Real growth

Globally, the ever-changing flux of macro dynamics, and the sterile inertness of macro statics cause economic disturbances, giving rise to cyclic business disruptions. These cause recessions and depressions, booms and busts, economic disruptions which play havoc with micro level economies of nations, while destroying families and individuals.

The need of the hour is a middle path of macro constancy based on equilibrium economics. This study proposes a “Wealth Redistribution Model” for equitable growth at equilibrium point: the E3 concept.

Equilibrium Growth is the proposed Real Growth.

9.6Drawbacks of economic growth

It makes sense to work with nature rather than mastering it (Ehrenfeld, 1978; Maffe, 1992)

The most sensitive aspect of economic growth concerns the distribution of wealth and the role of economic power in society. The biggest threat evolving out of economic growth is the human transformation of the natural environment. The biggest failure of economic progress is the “Ecological Footprint” that man leaves behind on the planet.

Friedman’s ‘Free Market theory’ is misinterpreted by people who consider that increasing wealth is the “only legitimate purpose” of business; and that continuously rising GDP maintains a strong and vital economy.

Calista Rajasingham writes about the causes leading to exploitation of the third world, while Jalali-Naini attributes causal factors for stagnant economies. Differentiation and disparity cause socioeconomic inequality. Li Yining states that social conflicts offset the economic progress made to improve living conditions.

The Alesina and Rodrik model demonstrates that greater inequality leads to lower equilibrium growth rate, while Banerjee and Duflo state that change in income distribution in any direction would reduce economic growth. Easterly and Levine both believe that the cause of declining economic growth is ethnic or cultural fractionalization.

In defining economic growth, value is reduced to economic value, development to economic development, success to economic success, utility to economic utility. Neglect of ecologically important distinctions such as location and regional differences create an “under‐socialized” (Biesecker, 1994) and under‐ecologized individual. No individual is expected to accept responsibility for social or environmental spillovers or externality.

9.7GDP: accepted indicator of economic growth

While the GDP and the rest of the national income accounts may seem to be arcane concepts, they are truly among the great inventions of the twentieth century.

……………Paul A. Samuelson and William D. Nordhaus

9.8Correlation between economic growth and happiness

A growing economy increases human well-being. GDP is a measure of economic growth, not well-being. Well-being is measured by other alternative indicators of growth like Happiness Index (HI), Human Development Index (HDI), and Environmental Protection Index (EPI). Purchasing Power (PP) is another measure of economic activity which accounts for consumerism.

In order to understand the relation between GDP as an indicator of economic growth and other indicators of real growth (HDI and HI), consider the following data table for of the growth indicators for various nations for year 2014.

Table 35 presents the GDP, HDI & HI.

Table 35. GDP, HDI & HI.
Rank GDP 2014 HDI 2014 HI 2014
1 United States Norway Switzerland
2 China Australia Iceland
3 Japan Switzerland Denmark
4 Germany Netherlands Norway
5 United Kingdom United States Brazil
6 France Germany Finland
7 Brazil New Zealand Netherlands
8 Italy Canada Sweden
9 India Singapore New Zealand
10 Russia Denmark Australia

Different nations are highest ranked for GDP, HDI, and HI in the same year 2014.

Inference: High GDP does not mean more well-being.

Table 36 presents the statistical data: GDP, HDI & HI.

Table 36. Statistical data: GDP, HDI & HI.
GDP v/s Happiness Index HDI EPI
Correlation 0.21 0.322 -0.06
Co-variance 30640243381 30640243381 -2.97395E+11
R Square 0.04 0.103880239 0.0036

The statistical relationship for correlation and co-variance between GDP and indicators of well-being (HI, HDI, and EPI) show weak correlation for HI and HDI, and negative for EPI.

Inference: Higher Economic Growth results in more Environmental degradation.

Table 37 presents the statistical data: PPP, HDI & EPI.

Table 37. Statistical data: PPP, HDI & EPI.
PPP v/s Happiness Index HDI EPI
Correlation 0.44 0.07 0.47
Co-variance 448.89 11.79 14023.20

The statistical relationship between PPP and well-being also show weak correlation for HI, HDI, and EPI.

Inference: More Consumerism does not mean more well-being. It also means more Environmental degradation.

9.9National accounting systems (SNA)

National income is calculated to assess the value and amount of commodity production in an economy. It is the total income of production of commodities in a given time period. Robert Repetto states that current System of National Accounting undermines the idea of sustainable development promoted by the WECD (World Commission on Environment and Development).

9.10Deficiency: growth indicators and SNAs

GDP, a measure of economic growth, is misinterpreted as a measure of human well-being. Ricardo Aguado and Jabier Martinez highlight the inconvenience and unsuitability of using GDP as a proper indicator for economic sustainability, while Simon Kuznets criticized the use of GDP as an indicator of wellbeing, since it measures only level of production. Fleurbaey points out that GDP ignores wealth distribution and variation, environmental damage, the quality of social relationships, health and economic and personal security.

Certain GDP-based reports chart India in Lower Middle-Income economies although World Bank’s Report (2012) ranks India at No 4 with PPP at 4.06 Trillion. The same report charts Britain as the fifth largest economy although it includes Prostitution and Narcotics Industry income in measuring GDP.

9.11Concept of sustainability

Economic growth and social sustainability must be combined with environmental sustainability in order to guarantee a better future for future generations

UN World Summit 2005 defines the three pillars of growth as economic, social and environmental. Sustainability enforces equality between the present and the future, and creates a balance between ecological, social and economic needs. As per Brundtland Report (1987), sustainable development is the development that meets the needs of the present without jeopardizing the needs of the future generations.

UN World Summit 2005 defines the three pillars of growth as economic, social and environmental. Sustainability enforces equality between the present and the future, and creates a balance between ecological, social and economic needs. As per Brundtland Report (1987), sustainable development is the development that meets the needs of the present without jeopardizing the needs of the future generations.

Hazel Henderson examines the conventional economic models, policy models, assumptions, institutional inertia and cultural values that are driving the world toward increasing unsustainability.

Li Yining proposes that sustainable development demands both natural and social harmony, while Ancy Treesa and Jincy Joseph recommend using resources judiciously. Stern explores limits to substitution between inputs in production, and their implications for sustainability.

9.12Resource depletion and optimal management

The global ecosystem and the economic subsystem are finite due to physical limitations of resources. Mankind lives on a planet with finite resources, where consumption pattern of each inhabitant varies. Developing nations do not consume at the same rate as the industrialized nations.

The current rate of resource consumption and waste production is unsustainable. Sustainable growth requires setting limits on consumption, but the prerequisite condition is setting limits on utilization of natural resources. Our society must transform into one that utilizes a fraction of current energy and resources.

9.13Misconceptions about natural resources

9.14Resource scarcity

Hervé Boulhol et al finds that natural resources endowment is responsible for the variation in economic performance of nations. Surowiecki has proved that the “curse of natural resources” is real, while Sachs and Warner have empirically demonstrated its existence despite commodity price controls.

9.15Resource endowment

Factors of non-renewable resource supply have reduced the scarcity effect of depleting existing deposits. Hotelling’s assumption of a known, fixed resource stock has been falsified by new discoveries and technological advances in the search, extraction and utilization of minerals.

9.16Valuation of natural resources

Mankind depends heavily on natural resources in world trade and hence is vulnerable to the biodiversity loss that could result from climate change (IPCC, 2001). Assigning monetary value to natural resources is a key process in influencing economic practices, policy, and decision-making. The economic value of natural capital accepted by mainstream environmental economics is of special significance in ecological economics. Natural Capitalism describes the global economy as being dependent on natural resources and ecosystem services that nature provides. Traditional industrial capitalism fails to assign any value to the natural resources. Ecological economic analysis and valuation continue to be guided by issues of intergenerational equity, irreversibility of environmental change, uncertainty of long-term outcomes, and sustainable development. This research study aims to overcome this deficiency by laying emphasize on assessing the economic value of the environment. Generally, the values related to direct and indirect use are estimated based on observed prices. Non-use values are estimated using a variant of “Choice modelling” method. The econometric model in this research attempts to model the decision process via "utility" preference made in the context of utility maximization and resource optimization.

9.17Resource conservation

Natural resource economics deals with the optimal commercial exploitation of natural resource stocks. Both environmental and natural resource economics are associated with sustainability. The theory of natural capitalism (Hawken, Lovins, Lovins) is concerned with resource conservation in production and considers natural services on par with physical capital.

9.18Common ownership of natural resources and wealth

The planet provides natural resources freely and abundantly to mankind for basic consumption needs and for economic activity for satisfying desires, wants and comforts. Nations bound by geo-political boundaries are merely custodians and guardians of the resources. All wealth derived from utilization of resources is common property of mankind and must be distributed equally among all nation for the common good.

9.19Wealth distribution

Amid rising concerns about globalization benefitting the world’s richest more, India’s wealthiest man Mukesh Ambani favors the free market economic model. He advocates that wealth creation should not be constrained as it is a precursor to the distribution of wealth.

Unscrupulous exploitation of natural resources and the environment degrades the quality of life; it destroys cultures and sinks the poor in misery. From social point of view, it is suggested that the profits of economic growth must be distributed among all the population.

Neoclassical theory relates distribution to production. Adam Smith explains how the “invisible hand” favors income distribution but not factor-price equalization, by arguing that the rich have a limited consuming capacity and hence are forced to share wealth with the poor. Gillian B. White discovers that wealth redistribution policies find little support from those very economically vulnerable groups who need income equality the most. Vivekinan Ashok observes the failure of redistribution methods to resolve increasing inequality.

9.20Common wealth pool

Common ownership of resources and wealth mandates sharing the onus of the responsibility for managing the resources and creation of wealth through economic activity. A fair and equal wealth distribution mechanism is required to establish economic justice and parity.

In order to achieve this, this research study proposes two concepts:

9.21Dynamism and flux in economic behaviour

A dynamic economy is characterized by incessant and unpredictable changes of technology, consumers’ preferences and the availability of natural resources, and endogenizes innovation, uncertainty and adaptation, part of the evolutionary process of the economy and society.

Economic systems are subject to dynamic behavior characterized by time lags and adjustments. Ragnar Frisch’s theory of constant flux propounds a state of “dynamic macroeconomics” in which rates of adjustment are fast enough to create constant equilibrium.

Nobel laureates Finn E. Kydland and Edward C. Prescott researched on the time consistency of economic policy and the driving forces behind business cycles in dynamic and static macroeconomics. Carmen M. Reinhart et al state that capital flow and commodity cycles have a causal relationship with economic crises. Classical economists attribute economic stability to the invisible hand of market forces, while Keynes attributes economic fluctuations to instability in monetary and credit system. Schumpeterian economics consider innovations as originating cause of cyclic fluctuations. J.M. Clark (Multiplier-Accelerator Interaction Theory) emphasizes the role of accelerators and multipliers in business fluctuation. This concept is manifested in the research wherein population of a nation is considered as a multiplier factor in deriving the economic wealth potential of a nation.

Conclusion: This section gave a brief review of the socio-economic concepts and the role of economics as a science. The relation between economics and environment and the concept of sustainable growth is introduced.

9.22Pillars of sustainability

World Summit (UN, 2005) stated three mutually and interdependent reinforcing pillars of sustainable development: economic development, social development and environmental protection. Following figure describes these three main pillars of sustainability.

Figure 4 shows the the three pillars of sustainability.

The three pillars of sustainability.
Figure 4. The three pillars of sustainability.

Figure 5 shows the the nested system of sustainability.

The nested system of sustainability.
Figure 5. The nested system of sustainability.

9.23Ideal economic equilibrium state

The most robust, self-sustaining, self-sufficient, and efficient form of economy in an ideal economic equilibrium state is when output is equivalent to the GDP.

9.24Dynamism and flux in economic behaviour (time lags and adjustments)

Economic systems are subject to dynamic behavior characterized by time lags and adjustments. Ragnar Frisch’s theory of constant flux propounds a state of “dynamic macroeconomics” in which rates of adjustment are fast enough to create constant equilibrium. Nobel laureates Finn E. Kydland and Edward C. Prescott researched on the time consistency of economic policy and the driving forces behind business cycles in dynamic and static macroeconomics. Carmen M. Reinhart et al state that capital flow and commodity cycles have a causal relationship with economic crises. Classical economists attribute economic stability to the invisible hand of market forces, while Keynes attributes economic fluctuations to instability in monetary and credit system. Schumpeterian economics consider innovations as originating cause of cyclic fluctuations. Clark emphasizes the role of accelerators and multipliers in business fluctuation.

9.25Equilibrium/steady economic state

The most robust, self-sustaining, self-sufficient, and efficient form of economy in an ideal economic equilibrium state is when output is equivalent to the GDP.

The “Balance of Nature” theory proposes that ecological systems are usually in a stable equilibrium, governing the management of natural resources. Keynes emphasizes the need for stability and an equilibrium state of economy. Boedo and Hernan considers macroeconomic equilibrium too statistical for a larger scope of demography or ethnicity. Debreu & Scarf explained the relationship between core and competitive equilibrium in determining prices. The neoclassic general economic equilibrium model suggests that the solution for economic equilibrium is the fixed-point theorem Note 7. Kakutam’s “Fixed Point theorem” determines equilibrium prices along with production and distribution plans in an equilibrium model. Charles Perrings discusses analysis of change in economy-environment systems and linkages between resilience and stability of dynamical systems.

9.26Common pricing

Consider the basic formula for GNP, given in Equation (10):

G N P = Price × Quantity (10)

Real GNP is an index of change in quantity. Regulation of the “Quantity” factor will ensure a static physical static state for economic equilibrium. For achieving the economic state of constancy, it is proposed to remove the dynamic influence of the “Price” factor (change in price), by introducing the concept of “Constant Pricing” or “Common Pricing”.

The Theory of Utility supports common pricing. At constant prices, most of these fluctuations would cease, gradually leading to a state of economic equilibrium. In General Equilibrium model, approximation of fixed points of continuous mapping determines equilibrium prices and activity levels. The use of price-adjustment technique based on supply-demand function sets the final condition for algorithm to calculate equilibrium prices and production plans. This concept is applied in the research by proposing a constant price scalar in order to achieve the proposed equilibrium state.

10Central research problem and research questions

The central research problem concerns economic disequilibrium, unsustainable growth, and resource depletion. The basic questions that the research proposes to seek answers to are:

10.1Purpose of research

The subject of the research is a lively and vibrant topic of international academic interest, adding socio-economic value in intellectual circuits globally. The driving force is the pursuit of knowledge about a subject that deeply affects humanity and the planet, and the possibility of contributing an evolutionary dimension to the existing economic dynamics and adding to the existing knowledge base on the subject, at the same time, gaining meaningful insight about the multi-faceted aspect of the planet’s economic environment.

The purpose of the research is a studious commitment to learn the inter-disciplinary approach, to explore new patterns of collective thinking, and to facilitate direction and implementation of new economic and environmental policies.

10.2Research aims and objectives

The research aims to introduce new evolutionary concepts in economics by designing a system wherein economic growth and environmental decline will be balanced at equilibrium point, and to develop a model of distribution of wealth created out of economic activity, through the optimal utilization of natural resources, in order to achieve and maintain sustainability of ecosystem. The aim of this research is primarily to discover the equilibrium point at which planned resource utilization sustains world economic growth. The research tries to establish the linkage between world economic system and environmental ecosystem based on valuation of the natural resources of the world and assigning a constant Universal Economic Index. The study involves research about the world’s economy and ecosystem for a dynamic world over a 10-year time horizon. The main objective of the research is to formulate an economic growth indicator accounting for utilization and valuation of natural resources; which, in turn, would form the foundation for an econometric decision model based on Law of Conservation of Energy to maintain constant equilibrium point between Economic Growth and Ecosystem sustainability, and to make it operational for predicting future economic growth.

10.2.1Primary objectives

  1. 1. To formulate an econometric model for equilibrium between economic growth and environmental decline: Economic-Environmental Equilibrium (E3) model
  2. 2. To derive a distributive model of wealth created from economic activity as well as environmental resource evaluation: Wealth Distribution (WDM) Model
  3. 3. To propose an alternative indicator of economic growth potential based on valuation of environmental resources: Gross Natural Resource Product (GNRP)

10.2.2Secondary objectives

Mathematically, the result expected from the study is: UGNRP equals UGDP.

10.3Relationships between variables/constructs used in the model

Figure 6 shows the relationships between variables/constructs used in the model.

Relationships between variables/constructs used in the model.
Figure 6. Relationships between variables/constructs used in the model.

11Statistical framework and sample design

11.1General framework

Type of Research: It is an exploratory type of research using secondary data from panel data framework which makes it possible to allow for differences in the form of unobservable individual country effects and ability to control for individual heterogeneity. Panel studies are able to control for state and time‐invariant variables. Method of sampling used is non-probability, judgment, convenience sampling.

Statistical methods used: Regression analysis is the method adopted to reflect correlation between GDP growth and various factors of production. Correlation analysis is used for inferring correlation between GDP (dependent variable) and Land, Agriculture, Population, and Minerals (independent variables). The paper presented titled “Derivation of Constant UGDP using Econometric Models; Calculating Real GDP using Valuation of Key Natural Resources” presented at the 4th IRC at IIM-Ahmedabad- 'ICADABAI- 2015highlighted these methods.

Table 38 presents the factors of production for derivation of UGNRP and UGDP.

Table 38. Factors of production for derivation of UGNRP and UGDP.
1. GDP 4. Agriculture Revenue
2. Total population 5. Mineral Output
3. Surface area (Land) 6. Common Price Mechanism Note 8

Wealth Distribution Model (WDM) and Economic-Environmental Equilibrium Growth Model (E3 model) are proposed in the research, which also aims to establish the “Equilibrium Point for Sustainable Growth” (at which the E3 Growth model becomes functionally viable).

11.2Sample design

11.2.1Part I: data compilation

Data Collection Method: Secondary data is used for statistical analysis of macroeconomic components of the various factors of economics from various sources. The characteristics of the data for statistical purpose are presented in tabular form as follows:

Table 39 presents the characteristics of the data used in the research study.

Table 39. Characteristics of the data used in the research study.
Type of data Pooled cross-sectional and Time series data (Panel data)
Periodicity Annual
Unit of Analysis Nations (the level of aggregation of data)
Study Setting Contrived, Artificial, Stimulated
Time Horizon One shot/cross-sectional
Variables (Objects) Economic Growth potential of Nations of the World
Attributes/Characteristics Land area, Population, Agriculture Revenue, Mineral Revenue (derived), GDP

Aggregation of Data: Data is aggregated for statistical analysis purpose as follows:

Table 40 presents the aggregation of data for statistical analysis.

Table 40. Aggregation of data for statistical analysis.
Over different Time periods Time Series data
Group of Nations in one year Cross –section data
Group of Nations over many years Panel data
Multivariate data over several geographic areas aggregate cross section data
developed, developing, transient economies strata of nations
Multivariate data over time for all Universe aggregate time series data

11.2.2Sampling method

The type of sampling used is non-probability sampling. The samples used are convenience samples based on data availability. Judgment sampling is used for selecting nations having significant economic growth in relation to world GDP.

11.2.3Sample size

i) Nations’ database

The universal sample size is 191 is Countries/Economies. The database contains projected GDP’s of the 191 Countries/ Economies in current prices (U.S. dollars) of year 2017 and 2022. Data is based on projection by IMF outlook April 2017. Gross World Product in 2017 is projected at $77.99 trillion, and its GDP (PPP) is forecasted at $126.69 trillion.

The list of nations is derived from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) which is an organization of 189 countries, working to foster global monetary cooperation, secure financial stability, facilitate international trade, promote high employment and sustainable economic growth, and reduce poverty around the world.

Following table lists the sample size for the research.

Table 41 presents the sample of 64 nations used in the research.

Table 41. Sample of 64 nations used in the research.
S. No. Country/Economy Sr. No Country/Economy Sr. No Country/Economy
1 United States 23 Sweden 45 Finland
2 China 24 Poland 46 Vietnam
3 Japan 25 Belgium 47 Peru
4 Germany 26 Thailand 48 Portugal
5 United Kingdom 27 United Arab Emirates 49 New Zealand
6 India 28 Nigeria 50 Czech Republic
7 France 29 Norway 51 Greece
8 Brazil 30 Austria 52 Romania
9 Italy 31 Iran 53 Iraq
10 Canada 32 Israel 54 Algeria
11 Russia 33 Philippines 55 Qatar
12 Korea 34 South Africa 56 Kazakhstan
13 Australia 35 Malaysia 57 Kuwait
14 Spain 36 Colombia 58 Hungary
15 Indonesia 37 Denmark 59 Kenya
16 Mexico 38 Ireland 60 Luxembourg
17 Turkey 39 Egypt 61 Tanzania
18 Netherlands 40 Venezuela 62 Bahrain
19 Saudi Arabia 41 Pakistan 63 Zimbabwe
20 Switzerland 42 Chile 64 Central African Republic
21 Argentina 43 Bangladesh
22 Taiwan Province of China 44 Central America

The Region-wise breakup of the sample size of 64 economies is as follows:

Table 42 presents the region-wise breakup of the sample of 64 economies.

Table 42. Region-wise breakup of the sample of 64 economies.
Region/Area Number of Economies
Europe 23
Africa 16
Asia 15
South Americas 6
North Americas 3
USA 1
Total 64

Top five economies account for 53.82 %, top ten accounts for approx. 67.19 %, top 20 economies add up to over 80% of World GDP. The sample size for the research is 64 Countries/Economies, as this sample size represents 95.63 % of the World GDP (in 2017).

Table 43 presents the share of the top economies in world GDP.

Table 43. Share of the top economies in world GDP.
Economy Unit GDP (USD bn) % of Ttl
Cumulative 64 74,577 95.63
World 77,988

ii) Minerals database

The total number of commodities/minerals used in the research is 238.

Table 44 presents the commodities/minerals used in the research (238).

Table 44. Commodities/minerals used in the research (238).
No Commodity No Commodity No Commodity
1 Abrasives 41 Calcareous 81 Ferronickel magnesium
2 Acid Clay 42 Calcite 82 Ferroniobium
3 Agate 43 Calcium carbonate (lime) 83 Ferrophosphorus
4 Aggregates 44 Carbon 84 Ferrosilicon
5 Alabaster 45 Caustic Soda 85 Ferrovanadium
6 Alexandrite 46 Cement 86 Fire Clay
7 Alginate 47 Chalk 87 Flagstone
8 Alumina 48 Chromite 88 Fluorspar
9 Aluminum 49 Clay 89 Fuel oil
10 Amethyst 50 Clinker 90 Fuller's Earth
11 Ammonia 51 Coal 91 Gabbro
12 Amphibolite 52 Cobalt 92 Gallium
13 Andalusite 53 Coke, metallurgical 93 Garnet
14 Anthracite Coal 54 Construction sand 94 Gas Oil
15 Antimony 55 Copper 95 Gasoline
16 Apatite 56 Copper sulfate 96 Gemstones
17 Aquamarine 57 Coquina 97 Gemstones Crude
18 Aromatic Tar 58 Cordierite, Iolite 98 Geniss (feldspar)
19 Arsenic 59 Crude Oil 99 Germanium
20 Asbestos 60 Crushed & broken Stone 100 Glauberite
21 Asphalt 61 Cyclohexane 101 Gold
22 Attapulgite clay 62 Diamond 102 Granite
23 Avigas 63 Diaspore 103 Graphite
24 Ball (Clay) 64 Diatomite 104 Gravel
25 Barite 65 Diesel 105 Greywacke
26 Basalt 66 Dimension stone 106 Guano
27 Bauxite 67 Distillate fuel oil 107 Gypsum
28 Bentonite 68 Dolomite 108 Helium
29 Beryllium 69 Dunnite 109 Igneous rock
30 Biotite 70 Electrolytic, cathode4 110 Ilmenite
31 Bismuth 71 Emerald 111 Indium
32 Bitumen fuel 72 Ethane 112 Iodine
33 Bituminous Coal 73 Fe content 113 Iolite
34 Blister Copper 74 Feldspar 114 Iridium
35 Boron 75 Felsite 115 Iron
36 Brine, salt 76 Ferro Titanium 116 Iron Oxide pigments
37 Briquets (Peat) 77 Ferrochromium 117 Jadeite
38 Bromine 78 Ferrochromium silicon 118 Jasper
39 Butane 79 Ferromanganese 119 Kaolin
40 Cadmium 80 Ferromolybdenum 120 Kerosene and jet fuel
121 Kyanite 161 Phosphate rock 201 Silica
122 Lead 162 Phosphatic Fertilizer 202 Siliceous earth
123 Leonardite 163 Phosphoric acid 203 Silicomanganese
124 Leucoxene 164 Phosphorite 204 Silicon
125 Lignite 165 Pig iron 205 Sillimanite
126 Lime 166 Pigments, Iron oxide 206 Silver
127 Limestone 167 Platinum 207 Slate
128 Liquefied petroleum gas 168 Porphyry 208 Soda ash
129 Lithium 169 Potash 209 Sodium Sulfate
130 Lubricants 170 Potassium Nitrate 210 Solvent (Toluene)
131 Magnesite 171 Pottery Clay 211 Sponge iron
132 Magnesium 172 Pozzolan 212 Steatite
133 Manganese 173 Propane 213 Steel, crude
134 Marble 174 Pumice, pumicite 214 Stone
135 Marl (lime) 175 Pyrite 215 Strontium
136 Mercury 176 Pyrochlore (niobium) 216 Sulfur
137 Methanol 177 Pyrope 217 Sulfuric acid
138 Mica 178 Pyrophyllite (Talc) 218 Talc
139 Moldavite 179 Pyroxenite 219 Tantalum
140 Moler (Diatomite) 180 Quartz and quartzite 220 Tanzanite
141 Molybdenum 181 Rare-earths 221 Tellurium
142 Monazite 182 Refinery gas 222 Tin
143 Naphtha 183 Residual fuel oil 223 Titanium, slag
144 Natural Gas 184 Rhenium 224 Topaz
145 Natural gas liquid 185 Rhodium 225 Tourmaline
146 Nepheline syenite 186 Rhodochrosite 226 Travertine
147 Nickel 187 Rock salt 227 Tuff
148 Niobium 188 Ruby 228 Tungsten
149 Nitrogen 189 Ruthenium 229 Ulexite
150 Obsidian 190 Rutile 230 Uranium
151 Olivine 191 Salable crude 231 Vanadium
152 Onyx 192 Salt 232 Vermiculite
153 Palladium 193 Sandstone 233 Volcanic sand
154 Paludal mud (clay) 194 Sapphire 234 White clay (kaolin)
155 Paraffin wax 195 Schist 235 Wollastonite
156 Peat 196 Selenite 236 Zeolite
157 Pentane 197 Selenium 237 Zinc
158 Perlite 198 Sepiolite clay 238 Zirconium
159 Petroleum Crude 199 Serpentine
160 Petroleum Refinery 200 Shale

Source of Mineral data: The research relies heavily on the mineral data from the secondary source of “USGS: Mineral Commodity Summaries”, which is the National Minerals Information Centre website of United States Geological Survey of the U.S. Department of Interior (URL: minerals.usgs.gov/minerals). The website is: https://minerals.usgs.gov/minerals/ which gives information about the U.S. Geological Survey's National Minerals Information Center, including minerals information, commodity statistics and other information.

iii) Pricing of Minerals

Source: To ensure the tenets of Common Price mechanism, the Pricing structure for each mineral is given as follows for few sample nations.

Method 1: Price per unit for the period 2012 to 2016 is collated from USGS: Mineral Commodity Summaries, Jan 2017 database, and the average is calculated as base price.

Table 45 presents the average annual price of selected minerals (2012–2016).

Table 45. Average annual price of selected minerals (2012–2016).
Commodity 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Average Unit
Abrasives 988 1030 1020 584 468 818.0 USD/T
Aluminum 101 94.2 104.5 88.2 80 424.5 USD/T
Antimony 565 463 425 327 300 1886.9 USD/T
Arsenic 75 72 75 84 88 1737.2 USD/T
Asbestos 931 1570 1510 1830 1610 1630.0 USD/T
Ball (Clay) 46 43 44 46 45 44.8 USD/T
Barite 187 180 191 197 198 190.6 USD/T
Bauxite 28 27 27 28 29 27.8 USD/T

Method 2: For other minerals, following source for Price per unit is adopted as per table given below (few sample nations from database):

Table 46 presents the other sources of price per unit of minerals.

Table 46. Other sources of price per unit of minerals.
Commodity Avg Unit Source
Acid Clay 250.0 USD/mT https://www.alibaba.com › Minerals & Metallurgy › bleaching earth
Alabaster 3.5 USD/lb. https://www.sculpturehouse.com/s-267-alabaster.aspx
Alginate (sodium) 3750.0 USD/mT https://www.alibaba.com › Chemicals › alginate › sodium alginate
Amethyst 25.5 USD/carat https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/value-of-amethyst.117307/
Ammonia 425.0 USD/T farmdocdaily.illinois.edu
Andalusite 40.0 USD/carat www.ebay.com/gds/Andalusite-Gemstone-Value-Price-and-Jewelry.../g.html
Anthracite Coal 42.6 USD/T https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/index.cfm?page=coal_prices
Aquamarine 175.0 USD/carat https://www.ajsgem.com/articles/aquamarine-prices.html
Aromatic Tar 425.0 USD/mT https://www.alibaba.com › Energy › oil
Asphalt 117.5 USD/T https://sciencing.com/how-6558396-calculate-asphalt-prices.html
Attapulgite clay 250.0 USD/mT https://www.alibaba.com/showroom/attapulgite-clay-price.html
Avigas 305.6 USD/bbl aviationweek.com/bca/jet-and-avgas-fuel-prices-august-2015

The final consolidated pricing structure for the 242 minerals is as given below:

Table 47 presents the consolidated pricing structure of all minerals.

Table 47. Consolidated pricing structure of all minerals.
Commodity Avg Unit Commodity Avg Unit Commodity Avg Unit
Abrasives 818.0 USD/T Cadmium 1735.0 USD/T Ferromanganese 2281.8 USD/T
Acid Clay 250.0 USD/mT Calcareous 10.3 USD/mT Ferromolybdenum 5.6 USD/kg
Agate 0.5 USD/Ct Calcite 165.0 USD/T Ferronickel magnesium 8551.4 USD/T
Aggregates 8.7 USD/T Calcium carbonate (lime) 118.5 USD/T Ferroniobium 33.5 USD/Kg
Alabaster 3.5 USD/lb. Carbon 26.0 USD/T Ferro Phosphorous 612.0 USD/T
Alexandrite 15000.0 USD/carat Caustic Soda 425.0 USD/mT Ferrosilicon 1380.0 USD/T
Alginate (sodium) 3750.0 USD/mT Cement 48.8 USD/T Ferrovanadium 22.6 USD/Kg
Alumina 283.1 USD/T Chalk 118.5 USD/T Fire Clay 17.4 USD/T
Aluminum 424.5 USD/T Chromite 270.0 USD/T Flagstone 400.0 USD/T
Amethyst 25.5 USD/carat Clay 12.2 USD/T Fluorspar 325.0 USD/T
Ammonia 425.0 USD/T Clinker 30.8 USD/T Fuel oil 2.7 USD/gn
Amphibolite (feldspar) 70.2 USD/T Coal 71.4 USD/T Fuller's Earth 94.2 USD/T
Andalusite 40.0 USD/carat Cobalt 14.2 USD/T Gabbro (Dimension stone) 10.3 USD/mT
Anthracite Coal 42.6 USD/T Coke, metallurgical 200.0 USD/T Gallium 422.2 USD/Kg
Antimony 1886.9 USD/T Construction sand 8.2 USD/mT Garnet 365.0 USD/T
Apatite (Phosphate rock) 84.3 USD/T Copper 5593.7 USD/T Gas Oil 56.0 USD/bbl
Aquamarine 175.0 USD/carat Copper sulfate 2000.0 USD/mT Gasoline 170.1 USD/bbl
Aromatic Tar 425.0 USD/mT Coquina 45.9 USD/T Gemstones 2005.0 USD/carat
Arsenic 1737.2 USD/T Cordierite, Iolite 450.0 USD/Mt Gemstones Crude 500.0 USD/carat
Asbestos 1630.0 USD/T Crude Oil 54.4 USD/bbl Geniss (feldspar) 70.2 USD/T
Asphalt 117.5 USD/T Crushed & broken Stone 10.3 USD/mT Germanium 1528.0 USD/Kg
Attapulgite clay 250.0 USD/mT Cyclohexane 1065.0 USD/mT Glauberite 90.0 USD/T
Avigas 305.6 USD/bbl Diamond 1400.0 USD/carat Gold 1223.7 USD/oz
Ball (Clay) 44.8 USD/T Diaspore 581.8 USD/T Granite 242.0 USD/T
Barite 190.6 USD/T Diatomite 292.4 USD/T Graphite 366.4 USD/T
Basalt 92.5 USD/mT Diesel 121.8 USD/bbl Gravel 8.7 USD/mT
Bauxite 27.8 USD/T Dimension stone 10.3 USD/mT Greywacke (sandstone) 130.0 USD/T
Bentonite 68.8 USD/T Distillate fuel oil 151.7 USD/bbl Guano 242.5 USD/mT
Beryllium 230.0 USD/lb. Dolomite 115.0 USD/mT Gypsum 8.5 USD/mT
Biotite 450.0 USD/mT Dunite 46.5 USD/T Helium 3.4 USD/cu m
Bismuth 8.2 USD/lb. Electrolytic, cathode4 220.0 USD/T Igneous rock 6.0 USD/lb.
Bitumen fuel 404.6 USD/mT Emerald 800.0 USD/carat Ilmenite 187.0 USD/mT
Bituminous Coal 46.7 USD/T Ethane 11.8 USD/bbl Indium 535.0 USD/kg
Blister Copper 4756.0 USD/T Fe content 90.4 USD/mT Iodine 34.6 USD/kg
Boron 453.0 USD/T Feldspar 70.2 USD/T Iolite 97.5 USD/carat
Brine, salt 140.0 USD/T Felsite 69.7 USD/mT Iridium 22943.1 USD/kg
Briquets (Peat) 56.6 USD/T Ferro Titanium 3770.0 USD/T Iron 61.9 USD/T
Bromine 4025.0 USD/T Ferrochromium 2480.0 USD/T Iron Oxide pigments 950.0 USD/T
Butane 51.2 USD/bbl Ferrochromium silicon 31325.0 USD/T Jadeite 5000.0 USD/carat
Jasper 33069.4 USD/T Perlite 26.0 USD/T Sepiolite clay 1835.0 USD/T
Kaolin 140.2 USD/T Petroleum Crude 79.7 USD/bbl Serpentine 1250.0 USD/mT
Kerosene and jet fuel 84.3 USD/bbl Petroleum Refinery 47.6 USD/bbl Shale 50.0 USD/bbl
Kyanite 294.0 USD/mT Phosphate rock 84.3 USD/T Silica 107.0 USD/mT
Lead 2169.3 USD/T Phosphatic Fertilizer 425.0 USD/T Siliceous earth 9.3 USD/T
Leonardite 200.0 USD/mT Phosphoric acid 600.0 USD/T Silicomanganese 948.4 USD/T
Leucoxene 778.0 USD/T Phosphorite 125.0 USD/T Silicon 267.6 USD/Kg
Lignite 45.0 USD/mT Pig iron 344.0 USD/T Sillimanite 475.0 USD/T
Lime 118.5 USD/T Pigments, Iron oxide 1.5 USD/kg Silver 17.5 USD/oz.
Limestone 198.0 USD/T Platinum 41724.8 USD/kg Slate 605.0 USD/T
Liquefied petroleum gas 100.2 USD/bbl Porphyry 40.0 USD/kg Soda ash 138.1 USD/T
Lithium 6690.0 USD/mT Potash 546.0 USD/T Sodium Sulfate 135.2 USD/T
Lubricants 545.0 USD/bbl Potassium Nitrate 675.0 USD/mT Solvent (Toluene) 157.5 USD/bbl
Magnesite 130.0 USD/mT Pottery Clay 25.5 USD/T Sponge iron 311.1 USD/T
Magnesium 2467.0 USD/mT Pozzolan 60.0 USD/mT Steatite 167.0 USD/mT
Manganese 187.1 USD/T Propane 68.9 USD/bbl Steel, crude 300.0 USD/mT
Marble 304.0 USD/T Pumice, pumicite 34.1 USD/T Stone 10.3 USD/mT
Marl (lime) 118.5 USD/T Pyrite 475.0 USD/mT Strontium 54.2 USD/T
Mercury 2476.2 USD/flask Pyrochlore (niobium) 24.6 USD/Kg Sulfur 87.6 USD/T
Methanol 549.0 USD/T Pyrope 5000.0 USD/T Sulfuric acid 280.0 USD/mT
Mica 285.0 USD/mT Pyrophyllite (Talc) 167.0 USD/mT Talc 167.0 USD/mT
Moldavite 20000.0 USD/Kg Pyroxenite 54.0 USD/T Tantalum 221.2 USD/Kg
Moler (Diatomite) 292.4 USD/T Quartz and quartzite 220000.0 USD/T Tanzanite 675.0 USD/carat
Molybdenum 21.3 USD/Kg Rare-earths 102712.1 US$/T Tellurium 98.4 USD/Kg
Monazite 9.1 USD/T Refinery gas 84.0 USD/bbl Tin 20638.7 USD/T
Naphtha 549.5 USD/T Residual fuel oil 43.1 USD/bbl Titanium, slag 716.8 USD/T
Natural Gas 3.2 USD/MMBtu Rhenium 2980.0 USD/Kg Topaz 20.0 USD/carat
Natural gas liquid 8.1 USD/MMBtu Rhodium 33071.6 USD/kg Tourmaline 400.0 USD/carat
Nepheline syenite 70.2 USD/T Rhodochrosite 30000.0 USD/Kg Travertine (limestone) 198.0 USD/T
Nickel 14109.0 USD/mT Rock salt 113.3 USD/mT Tuff 923.5 USD/T
Niobium 24.6 USD/Kg Ruby 1650.0 USD/carat Tungsten 301.6 USD/mT
Nitrogen 480.4 USD/T Ruthenium 2203.3 USD/kg Ulexite 754.1 USD/mT
Obsidian 4409.2 USD/T Rutile 822.6 USD/T Uranium 25.7 USD/lb..
Olivine 145.0 USD/T Salable crude 61.5 USD/bbl Vanadium 5.1 USD/lb..
Onyx 599.0 USD/T Salt 179.5 USD/T Vermiculite 338.5 USD/T
Palladium 22497.3 USD/kg Sandstone 130.0 USD/T Volcanic sand 190.0 USD/mT
Paludal mud (clay) 12.2 USD/T Sapphire 4000.0 USD/carat White clay (kaolin) 140.2 USD/T
Paraffin wax 1085.0 USD/mT Schist 75.0 USD/T Wollastonite 360.0 USD/T
Peat 56.6 USD/T Selenite 55000.0 USD/T Zeolite 437.0 USD/mT
Pentane 95.8 USD/bbl Selenium 72977.5 USD/T Zinc 2739.7 USD/T
Zirconium 75000.0 USD/T

iv) Production of Minerals: Nation/Economy-wise

The aggregate production of minerals per nation/economy is considered for all 64 sample nations for the time period of 2010-2013 for analysis purpose. As example for Algeria is given below:

Table 48 presents the mineral production of Algeria.

Table 48. Mineral production of Algeria.
Commodity Units 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Aggregates, crushed stone, gravel thousand cubic meters 25,381 55,000 72,040 72,898 80,905
Barite, crude metric tons 42,254 40,000 36,211 30,245 56,829
Bentonite metric tons 34,126 29,000 26,278 27,668 31,510
Bitumen thousand 42-gallon barrels 1,279 1,058 1,060 1,000 1,000
Calcite thousand metric tons 339 339 232 267 335
Cement, hydraulic thousand metric tons 19,100 19,000 19,000 18,500 21,000
Common Clay metric tons 10,973 11,000 10,167 11,829 12,467
Construction sand thousand cubic meters 3,164 4,100 2,898 2,635 2,998
Crushed stone thousand cubic meters 114 119 287 239 203
Diatomite metric tons 2,104 2,132 2,398 2,224 2,426
Distillate fuel oil thousand 42-gallon barrels 55,618 55,654 51,474 52,533 69,496
Dolomite metric tons 2,260 2,260 743 60 60
Feldspar thousand metric tons 164 148 163 259 230
Gas, natural million cubic meters 275,579 272,187 267,794 261,032 214,200
Gasoline, normal thousand 42-gallon barrels 17,436 19,841 18,944 18,218 23,105
Gold, mine output kilograms 723 449 264 140 85
Gypsum thousand metric tons 1,610 1,610 1,958 2,078 2,130
Helium, liquid million cubic meters 17 17 17 25 25

12Data analysis and interpretation

12.1Economic worth of a nation: GNRP

Having tabulated the database about the nations, minerals, the production of minerals nation-wise, and the average price of minerals (for common pricing mechanism), the next step is to evaluate the economic worth of a nation based on its mineral composition and the common price. This will eliminate the cyclic economic fluctuations between nations caused by differential pricing.

Stage 1: For this purpose, the first step is to common-rate the differential units of measurement between quantitative and pricing units. This is achieved by conversion mechanism as tabulated below:

Table 49 presents the conversion factors between units of measurement and pricing units.

Table 49. Conversion factors between units of measurement and pricing units.
Unit of Measurement Unit Conversion factor Unit of Measurement Unit Conversion factor
cubic meters T 0.35 flask lbs. 76
cubic meters mT 0.39 million cubic meters MMBtu 42380.00
kilograms flask 0.02632 million cubic meters bbl 7634.16
kilograms T 0.00100 million cubic meters T 350000.00
kilograms mT 0.00091 million cubic meters mT 317515.04
kilograms ounce 35.27 42-gallon barrels mT 0.14
kilograms bbl 0.007 42-gallon barrels T 0.12
kilograms carat 5000.00 thousand 42-gallon barrels mT 136.00
Metric tons carat 5511550 thousand 42-gallon barrels T 123.38
Metric tons flask 29.01 thousand 42-gallon barrels MMBtu 5551.37
Metric tons T 1.10 thousand carats Kg 0.20
Metric tons Kg 1102.31 thousand carats T 0.0002205
Metric tons Lbs. 2204.62 thousand carats mT 0.0002
Metric tons mT 1.00 thousand cubic meters MMBtu 42.38
Metric tons Oz. 35274.00 thousand cubic meters T 353.14
Metric tons bbl 8.10 thousand cubic meters mT 388.45
Ton flask 26.32 thousand metric tons barrels 8101.98
Ton carat 5000000 thousand metric tons MMBtu 133.47
Ton bbl 7.35 thousand metric tons T 1102.31

Stage 2: The next step is to obtain the year-wise economic value for the particular commodity/mineral by multiplying the production quantity with the average price, using the conversion factor for neutralizing the difference in units of measurement.

An example of the nation Algeria is produced below. The product of (i) the quantity of commodity produced, (ii) the average price, and (iii) the Conversion factor, gives the economic value of that commodity for that year.

The Economic Value (in USD mn) for the years 2010, 2012, and 2014 are given below:

Table 50 presents the economic value of minerals for Algeria (2010, 2012 and 2014).

Table 50. Economic value of minerals for Algeria (2010, 2012 and 2014).
Commodity Units Qty 2010 Qty 2012 Qty 2014 Avg price Unit of price Conv. factor Value 2010 (USD mn) Value 2012 (USD mn) Value 2014 (USD mn)
Aggregates, 000 cubic meters 25,381 72,040 80,905 8.7 USD/T 353.14 78.07 221.58 248.85
Barite, crude metric tons 42,254 36,211 56,829 190.6 USD/T 1.10 8.88 7.61 11.94
Bentonite metric tons 34,126 26,278 31,510 68.8 USD/T 1.10 2.59 1.99 2.39
Bitumen 000 42-gn barrels 1,279 1,060 1,000 404.6 USD/mT 136.00 70.37 58.32 55.02
Calcite 000 metric tons 339 232 335 165.0 USD/T 1102.31 61.58 42.16 60.85
Cement, hydraulic 000 metric tons 19,100 19,000 21,000 48.8 USD/T 1102.31 1026.39 1021.01 1128.49
Common Clay metric tons 10,973 10,167 12,467 12.2 USD/T 1.10 0.15 0.14 0.17
Construction sand 000 cubic meters 3,164 2,898 2,998 8.2 USD/mT 388.45 10.08 9.23 9.55
Crushed stone 000 cubic meters 114 287 203 10.3 USD/mT 388.45 0.45 1.15 0.81
Diatomite metric tons 2,104 2,398 2,426 292.4 USD/T 1.10 0.68 0.77 0.78
Distillate fuel oil 000 42-gn barrels 55,618 51,474 69,496 151.7 USD/bbl 1000.00 8436.69 7808.09 10541.8
Dolomite metric tons 2,260 743 60 115.0 USD/mT 1.00 0.26 0.09 0.01
Feldspar 000 metric tons 164 163 230 70.2 USD/T 1102.31 12.69 12.59 17.83
Gas, natural mn cubic meters 275,579 267,794 214,200 3.2 USD/MMBtu 42380.00 36968.05 35923.72 28734.25
Gasoline, normal 000 42-gn barrels 17,436 18,944 23,105 170.1 USD/bbl 1000.00 2966.15 3222.69 3930.5
Gold, mine output kilograms 723 264 85 1223.7 USD/oz. 35.27 31.21 11.40 3.67
Gypsum 000 metric tons 1,610 1,958 2,130 8.5 USD/mT 1000.00 13.70 16.67 18.13
Helium, liquid million cubic meters 17 17 25 3.4 USD/cu m 1000000 57.72 57.72 84.88
Iron 000 metric tons 2,240 2,730 1,394 61.9 USD/T 1102.31 152.74 186.14 95.06
Kaolin metric tons 71,065 100,97 181,06 140.2 USD/T 1.10 10.98 15.60 27.98
Kerosene/ jet fuel 000 42-gn barrels 11,050 9,600 15,403 84.3 USD/bbl 1000.00 930.96 808.80 1297.70
Lime, hydraulic 000 metric tons 63 66 49 118.5 USD/T 1102.31 8.23 8.62 6.46
Limestone 000 metric tons 20,000 20,000 24,880 198.0 USD/T 1102.31 4365.15 4365.15 5430.20
Liquefied petroleum gas 000 42-gn barrels 90,874 76,572 95,120 100.2 USD/bbl 1000.00 9102.12 7669.61 9527.41

Stage 3: Carrying this further, the cumulative economic value for ALL minerals for the nation Algeria for the years 2010, 2012, and 2014 are calculated as tabulated below:

Table 51 presents the cumulative economic value of all minerals for Algeria.

Table 51. Cumulative economic value of all minerals for Algeria.
ALGERIA: MINERALS Economic Value (USD mn) Economic Value (USD mn) Economic Value (USD mn)
Commodity 2010 2012 2014
Aggregates, crushed stone, gravel 78.07 221.58 248.85
Barite, crude 8.88 7.61 11.94
Bentonite 2.59 1.99 2.39
Bitumen 70.37 58.32 55.02
Calcite 61.58 42.16 60.85
Cement, hydraulic 1026.39 1021.01 1128.49
Common Clay 0.15 0.14 0.17
Construction sand 10.08 9.23 9.55
Crushed stone 0.45 1.15 0.81
Diatomite 0.68 0.77 0.78
Distillate fuel oil 8436.69 7808.09 10541.85
Dolomite 0.26 0.09 0.01
Feldspar 12.69 12.59 17.83
Gas, natural 36968.05 35923.72 28734.25
Gasoline, normal 2966.15 3222.69 3930.54
Gold, mine output 31.21 11.40 3.67
Gypsum 13.70 16.67 18.13
Pig iron 263.92 132.72 113.76
Pozzolan 14.22 19.50 18.88
Residual fuel oil 2106.51 1363.69 2192.56
Salt, brine and sea salt 21.21 35.32 38.19
Silica sand 0.97 1.28 1.74
Silver 0.09 0.03 0.01
Steel 395.70 332.10 247.50
Stone 0.04 0.06 0.13
Sulfur 8.30 8.30 8.30
Tuff 593.31 554.43 554.43
Zinc 64.98 50.43 68.55
124,822 116,003 117,014

Economic Value for 2010-2014 for minerals for the nation Algeria is calculated as below:

Table 52 presents the economic value of minerals for Algeria (2010–2014).

Table 52. Economic value of minerals for Algeria (2010–2014).
ALGERIA: Statistics 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Total Mineral Value (USD mn) 124822 121594 116003 117107 117014

Note: Some nations may have economic value data for the time period 2009-2013, and some for 2010-2014. This is due to data availability constraints, either for mineral production data or for mineral pricing data. But for the research purpose, only three-year common over-lapping time period of 2010 to 2013 is utilized. A special case for the USA is made where-in the Economic Value data for the time period 2009 to 2016 is presented.

Table 53 presents the economic value of minerals for the USA (2009–2016).

Table 53. Economic value of minerals for the USA (2009–2016).
USA: Statistics 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Total Mineral Value (USD mn) 306590 340271 358312 397016 359668 362258 349802 357392

The cumulative database for the Economic Value (Mineral Value) for all the 64 sample nations is given below:

Table 54 presents the mineral value of the 64 sample nations (2010–2013).

Table 54. Mineral value of the 64 sample nations (2010–2013).
Sr. No Mineral Value (USD mn) 2010 2011 2012 2013
1 United States 340271 358312 397016 359668
2 China 34787250 41075086 34635730 39740951
3 Japan 447848 462763 430174 345223
4 Germany 869243 882329 883093 865908
5 United Kingdom 655951 649894 588006 588958
6 India 260797 270026 279877 277234
7 France 109985 107583 96147 97871
8 Brazil 1773281 1890668 1925578 1939853
9 Italy 254909 252443 252441 216594
10 Canada 1101688 1153411 1247554 1416651
11 Russia 9760917 10103695 10863288 11643462
12 Korea 989786 1002065 1145949 1146753
13 Australia 221395 245874 234806 226740
14 Spain 1165297 1127343 881483 839692
15 Indonesia 1089 1049 1123 801
16 Mexico 3764874 4381572 4511042 4377408
17 Turkey 1303608 1090486 1223343 1099964
18 Netherlands 76003 74062 72652 72692
19 Saudi Arabia 457802 491439 451689 484879
20 Switzerland 101975 116628 98800 134277
21 Argentina 847272 877807 560316 553222
22 Taiwan 21094 22954 21334 22201
23 Sweden 1278103 1181653 1320945 1333508
24 Poland 3209459 3213026 3216311 3233018
25 Belgium 37138 35598 34987 35384
26 Thailand 147295 179833 248342 274156
27 United Arab Emirates 108744 126193 128449 136213
28 Nigeria 101455 99351 100897 97817
29 Norway 413596 437272 407472 376504
30 Austria 98985 98184 105063 104512
31 Islamic Republic of Iran 657286 721138 728533 715929
32 Israel 19672 19531 19534 19530
33 Philippines 14902 16864 20855 27646
34 South Africa 8431704 8289183 7296733 8195571
35 Malaysia 70935 71931 71466 68997
36 Colombia 47841 52375 54939 54706
37 Denmark 16022 14808 15028 14126
38 Ireland 1040709 1044782 1025009 993042
39 Egypt 86656 88746 81918 79369
40 Venezuela 940330 942309 940150 873185
41 Pakistan 48344 31609 34130 34242
42 Chile 278025 268427 253069 248712
43 Bangladesh 5413 5629 5319 5275
44 Central America 4912 5167 4711 5543
45 Finland 76329 87862 75344 76927
46 Vietnam 31600 32450 33006 32139
47 Peru 73011 74797 66389 68625
48 Portugal 41035 41299 39383 38450
49 New Zealand 7575 6866 7011 7149
50 Czech Republic 74208 84949 58516 56866
51 Greece 25032 20683 20497 18812
52 Romania 60351 47716 50589 50917
53 Iraq 92313 105654 114915 117046
54 Algeria 124822 121594 116003 117107
55 Qatar 105640 121128 128637 134091
56 Kazakhstan 80119 83849 87805 89185
57 Kuwait 107397 118067 121992 126111
58 Hungary 14270 14185 14468 13498
59 Kenya 124587 143251 152042 180204
60 Luxembourg 1409 1493 1335 1324
61 Tanzania 6607536 3103774 3078647 3257143
62 Bahrain 17684 17295 17523 16889
63 Zimbabwe 14089 14525 19582 17455
64 Central African Republic 7 7 8 5

This Mineral Value is the critical element in calculating the proposed Gross National Resource Product (GNRP).

Note: The production of mineral commodities is based on historical data. For forecasting purpose, the anticipated production is used as a control factor.

12.2Comparison for derivation

4th Step: Having completed the evaluation of the mineral value for the nations, the next process involves the data collection of the other national level statistics data relevant to the research i.e. the Agriculture Revenue, the Population, the Land Area, and the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) for the same time period (2010-2013). Source: The World Bank.

The Gross Domestic Product (GDP) database for 2010-2013 is given below:

Table 55 presents the GDP of the nations (2010–2013).

Table 55. GDP of the nations (2010–2013).
Sr. No GDP (Current USD mn) 2010 2011 2012 2013
1 United States 14964372 15517926 16155255 16691517
2 China 6100620 7572554 8560547 9607224
3 Japan 5700098 6157460 6203213 5155717
4 Germany 3417095 3757698 3543984 3752514
5 United Kingdom 2429680 2608825 2646003 2719509
6 India 1656617 1823050 1827638 1856722
7 France 2646837 2862680 2681416 2808511
8 Brazil 2208872 2616202 2465189 2472807
9 Italy 2125058 2276292 2072823 2130491
10 Canada 1613464 1788648 1824289 1842628
11 Russia 1524916 2031769 2170144 2230625
12 Korea 1094499 1202464 1222807 1305605
13 Australia 1142877 1390557 1538194 1567179
14 Spain 1431588 1488017 1335946 1361776

Agriculture Revenue as a percentage of the GDP for the nations is tabulated below:

Table 56 presents the agriculture revenue as a percentage of GDP (2010–2013).

Table 56. Agriculture revenue as a percentage of GDP (2010–2013).
Sr. No Country/Economy 2010 2011 2012 2013
1 United States 175695 212096 200552 238079
2 China 581401 714433 806399 893010
3 Japan 62983 66550 71201 57279
4 Germany 24579 30901 27722 35428
5 United Kingdom 17746 17711 17644 19443
6 India 312781 337750 332673 345140
7 France 47164 52694 48775 45699
8 Brazil 106960 133623 120840 130483
9 Italy 41841 47807 45375 49591
10 Canada 22964 30654 32108 33943
11 Russia 58975 80503 79628 85304
12 Korea 27046 30265 30071 30492
13 Australia 27148 34238 37560 38763
14 Spain 36520 36895 33634 37476
15 Indonesia 105179 120661 122756 121883

Land Area of the Nations (Sq. Km) is as given below for the nations:

Table 57 presents the land area of the nations (sq. km).

Table 57. Land area of the nations (sq. km).
Sr. No Land Area (Sq. Km) 2010 2011 2012 2013
1 United States 9831510 9831510 9831510 9831510
2 China 9562911 9562911 9562911 9562911
3 Japan 377950 377955 377960 377962
4 Germany 357127 357140 357170 357340
5 United Kingdom 243610 243610 243610 243610
6 India 3287260 3287260 3287260 3287260
7 France 549087 549087 549087 549087
8 Brazil 8515770 8515770 8515770 8515770
9 Italy 301340 301340 301340 301340
10 Canada 9984670 9984670 9984670 9984670
11 Russia 17098250 17098250 17098250 17098250
12 Korea 100030 100030 100150 100266
13 Australia 7741220 7741220 7741220 7741220
14 Spain 505600 505600 505940 505940
15 Indonesia 1910930 1910930 1910930 1910930

Population (in millions) of the nations is tabulated below:

Table 58 presents the population of the nations (millions).

Table 58. Population of the nations (millions).
Sr. No Population (million) 2010 2011 2012 2013
1 United States 309 312 314 316
2 China 1338 1344 1351 1357
3 Japan 128 128 128 127
4 Germany 82 80 80 81
5 United Kingdom 63 63 64 64
6 India 1231 1247 1263 1279
7 France 65 65 66 66
8 Brazil 197 199 201 202
9 Italy 59 59 60 60
10 Canada 34 34 35 35
11 Russia 143 143 143 144
12 Korea 50 50 50 50
13 Australia 22 22 23 23
14 Spain 47 47 47 47
15 Indonesia 243 246 249 252

The Total Land Revenue (sub-soil and supra-soil) is the sum of the Mineral Revenue and Agriculture Revenue. It is tabulated below:

Table 59 presents the total land revenue (sub-soil and supra-soil) of the nations.

Table 59. Total land revenue (sub-soil and supra-soil) of the nations.
Sr. No Total Land Revenue (USD mn) 2010 2011 2012 2013
1 United States 515966 570408 597568 597747
2 China 35368652 41789519 35442129 40633961
3 Japan 510831 529313 501375 402502
4 Germany 893823 913230 910814 901336
5 United Kingdom 673696 667605 605650 608401
6 India 573578 607777 612550 622374
7 France 157149 160277 144922 143570
8 Brazil 1880241 2024291 2046418 2070336
9 Italy 296750 300250 297816 266185
10 Canada 1124652 1184065 1279663 1450594
11 Russia 9819892 10184198 10942916 11728765
12 Korea 1016832 1032330 1176019 1177246
13 Australia 248543 280112 272366 265503
14 Spain 1201817 1164237 915117 877167
15 Indonesia 106267 121710 123878 122684

12.3Stage 5: concept of gross natural resource product (GNRP)

The database for all nations (sample size 64) regarding GDP, Agriculture Revenue, Population, Land Area, and the Mineral Value of the nations is thus collated.

Total land revenue = Mineral revenue + Agriculture revenue (11)

The Gross Natural Resource Product is the Total Land Revenue adjusted for the population considered as a multiplicative factor (pf: population factor).

G N R P = Total land revenue × Population (12)

For example, consider the economy of the USA.

Step 1: Land Revenue = Mineral Value + Agriculture Revenue

Table 60 presents the land revenue of the USA (step 1).

Table 60. Land revenue of the USA (step 1).
USA 2010 2011 2012 2013
(a) Total Mineral Value (USD mn) 340271 358312 397016 359668
(b) Agriculture Revenue (USD mn) 175695 212096 200552 238079
(x) Total Land Revenue (USD mn): {x= a + b} 515966 570408 597568 597747

Step 2: GNRP = Land Revenue * Population in bn

Table 61 presents the GNRP of the USA (step 2).

Table 61. GNRP of the USA (step 2).
USA 2010 2011 2012 2013
(c) Population (mn) 309.35 311.66 314.0 316.2
(d) Population (billion): (c) /1000 0.309 0.312 0.314 0.316
(x) Total Land Revenue (USD mn) 515966 570408 597568 597747
(z) GNRP (USD mn pf) [ z = x * d] 159613 177775 187635 189010

The GNRP value for the sample size of 64 nations is provided below:

Table 62 presents the GNRP of the 64 sample nations (USD mn).

Table 62. GNRP of the 64 sample nations (USD mn).
Sr No GNRP (USD mn pf) 2010 2011 2012 2013
1 United States 159613 177775 187635 189010
2 China 47312822 56170547 47871506 55155726
3 Japan 65422 67664 63990 51297
4 Germany 73094 73310 73253 72689
5 United Kingdom 42285 42232 38580 39016
6 India 706063 758041 773691 795743
7 France 10219 10473 9516 9475
8 Brazil 370024 402200 410432 419054
9 Italy 17591 17829 17732 16033
10 Canada 38244 40664 44469 50996
11 Russia 1402766 1455942 1567044 1683159
12 Korea 50388 51551 59036 59367
13 Australia 5476 6258 6190 6138
14 Spain 55977 54420 42803 40894
15 Indonesia 25772 29905 30831 30920
16 Mexico 445958 526477 550110 541838
17 Turkey 100017 85773 96949 88894
18 Netherlands 1528 1486 1461 1499
19 Saudi Arabia 12938 14289 13583 15002
20 Switzerland 831 963 827 1126
21 Argentina 36413 38406 25172 25227
22 Taiwan 636 690 690 723
23 Sweden 12061 11252 12652 12879
24 Poland 122629 122947 122996 123630
25 Belgium 450 435 438 441
26 Thailand 12312 15048 19952 21926
27 United Arab Emirates 899 1094 1143 1227
28 Nigeria 30072 31130 33887 35387
29 Norway 2059 2203 2077 1952
30 Austria 875 882 938 938
31 Islamic Republic of Iran 51404 57067 59235 59016
32 Israel 150 152 155 157
Sr. No GNRP (USD mn pf) 2010 2011 2012 2013
33 Philippines 3700 4323 4887 5735
34 South Africa 430347 429340 383627 437378
35 Malaysia 2718 3037 2983 2925
36 Colombia 3132 3497 3672 3685
37 Denmark 114 112 119 108
38 Ireland 4756 4797 4713 4581
39 Egypt 9864 10566 9919 9970
40 Venezuela 27957 28270 28728 27077
41 Pakistan 14792 12742 15627 15892
42 Chile 4870 4777 4548 4523
43 Bangladesh 3948 4373 4378 4678
44 Central America 849 968 970 1021
45 Finland 446 514 446 462
46 Vietnam 4865 5483 5885 5956
47 Peru 2468 2620 2430 2548
48 Portugal 489 490 464 458
49 New Zealand 93 96 92 111
50 Czech Republic 814 949 672 657
51 Greece 387 337 326 301
52 Romania 1435 1235 1198 1252
53 Iraq 2840 3352 3767 3966
54 Algeria 5034 5111 5096 5346
55 Qatar 188 237 272 302
56 Kazakhstan 1423 1563 1637 1718
57 Kuwait 323 379 416 456
58 Hungary 189 206 202 195
59 Kenya 5612 6608 7277 8805
60 Luxembourg 1 1 1 1
61 Tanzania 305061 148154 151746 165678
62 Bahrain 22 22 23 22
63 Zimbabwe 217 229 311 286
64 Central African Republic 5 5 5 3

Stage 6: Having obtained the key statistical data for all nations, it is now time for the final results: To find the equilibrium point between economic growth and environmental disruption.

The database for GNRP (Resource value, economic potential of a nation at the beginning of economic cycle), and GDP (Created wealth, achieved economic performance at the end of the economic cycle) is tabulated for few sample nations as below:

Table 63 presents the GNRP and GDP of selected nations.

Table 63. GNRP and GDP of selected nations.
GNRP USA CHINA JAPAN GERMANY UK INDIA
2009 140775 68883 599635
2010 159613 47312822 65422 73094 42285 706063
2011 177775 56170547 67664 73310 42232 758041
2012 187635 47871506 63990 73253 38580 773691
2013 189010 55155726 51297 72689 39016 795743
2014 184761 51525965 47724 42337
2015 173151
2016 184482
GDP(Current) USA CHINA JAPAN GERMANY UK INDIA
2009 14418739 3418005 1323940
2010 14964372 6100620 5700098 3417095 2429680 1656617
2011 15517926 7572554 6157460 3757698 2608825 1823050
2012 16155255 8560547 6203213 3543984 2646003 1827638
2013 16691517 9607224 5155717 3752514 2719509 1856722
2014 17393103 10482371 4848733 2998834
2015 18036648
2016 17069131
GNRP FRANCE BRAZIL ITALY CANADA RUSSIA
2009 9396 326996 17320 1420388
2010 10219 370024 17591 38244 1402766
2011 10473 402200 17829 40664 1455942
2012 9516 410432 17732 44469 1567044
2013 9475 419054 16033 50996 1683159
2014 63986
2015
2016
GDP(Current) FRANCE BRAZIL ITALY CANADA RUSSIA
2009 2693827 1667020 2185160 1222644
2010 2646837 2208872 2125058 1613464 1524916
2011 2862680 2616202 2276292 1788648 2031769
2012 2681416 2465189 2072823 1824289 2170144
2013 2808511 2472807 2130491 1842628 2230625
2014 1792883
2015
2016

The Cumulative and Mean values of UGNRP and UGDP are tabulated below:

Table 64 presents the cumulative and mean values of UGNRP and UGDP.

Table 64. Cumulative and mean values of UGNRP and UGDP.
YEAR 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
CUMULATIVE GNRP (USD mn) 52005948 60953496 52785407 60267473 56432279
MEAN GNRP (USD mn) 812593 952398 824772 941679 881754
CUMULATIVE GDP (USD mn) 57213537 66370096 58199201 66007905 61914777
MEAN GDP (USD mn) 922799 1070485 938697 1064644 998625

The difference between GNRP and mean GNRP for few nations is tabulated below:

Table 65 presents the difference between GNRP and mean GNRP for selected nations.

Table 65. Difference between GNRP and mean GNRP for selected nations.
DIFFERENCE GNRP (USD mn) 2010 2011 2012 2013
USA -640509 -760002 -624479 -738212
CHINA 46512700 55232770 47059392 54228503
JAPAN -734700 -870113 -748124 -875926
GERMANY -727028 -864468 -738861 -854534
UNITED KINGDOM -757837 -895545 -773534 -888207

The difference between GDP and mean GDP for few nations is tabulated below:

Table 66 presents the difference between GDP and mean GDP for selected nations.

Table 66. Difference between GDP and mean GDP for selected nations.
DIFFERENCE GDP (USD mn) 2010 2011 2012 2013
USA 13999456 14446371 15061107 15568050
CHINA 5135705 6500999 7466398 8483757
JAPAN 4735183 5085905 5109065 4032250
GERMANY 2452179 2686143 2449836 2629046
UNITED KINGDOM 1464765 1537270 1551854 1596042
INDIA 691701 751495 733489 733255
FRANCE 1681922 1791125 1587268 1685044
BRAZIL 1243956 1544647 1371040 1349340
ITALY 1160143 1204738 978675 1007024
CANADA 648549 717093 730140 719161
RUSSIA 560001 960214 1075995 1107158

NOTE: It is necessary to understand the concept of the “Difference between UGNRP and UGDP”, as this concept is the basic fulcrum on which rests the idea of equilibrium point between economic potential based on valuation of natural resources (UGNRP), and economic achievement (prevalent concept of UGDP as the value of all goods and services). This elusive point is the sought after Economic-Environmental-Equilibrium Point.

UGNRP is the value of all the natural resources (subsoil and supra-soil) which includes mineral revenue at common price and the agriculture revenue, adjusted for the population as multiplicative factor. It is an expected revenue potential calculated at the beginning of the economic cycle, and on which we have complete control.

In contrast to this, UGDP value is the value of economic performance at the end of the business cycle. It is a projected value, and as such, is subject to numerous variations during the course of the business cycles. The final UGDP value is often always in variation with the projected value, and this variation is the root cause of business cycles. The microeconomic fluctuations that give rise to cyclic variation are responsible for the economic disparity and discontent world over. Often, the victim of the uncontrolled economic growth engine is the environment.

This effect is manifested in the valuation of the UGNRP for the next year.

Only when the difference between the UGNRP and the UGDP is reduced to zero (nil), the Economic-Environmental-Equilibrium Point can be considered to have been achieved.

This stage implies that the cumulative value of the economic worth of the world at the beginning of the economic cycle is the same as (equal to) the economic worth at the end of the business cycle. There is no difference between expected and achieved economic worth. This is the state at which there is no profit-no loss for the world.

At this stage, all incentives for unplanned, uncontrollable, irregular, and false reporting of growth are neutralized.

The method to actualize this is:

  1. 1. Check the difference between the GDP and the mean UGDP for a nation for a particular year for the nation/economy (GDP – mean UGDP).
  2. 2. If the difference is a positive value, the difference (excess GDP) is to be added to the GNRP of that nation in the subsequent year (INJECT).
  3. 3. If the difference is a negative value, no action is to be taken for subsequent year.
  4. 4. The addition of excess GDP to the GNRP of that nation in the next year would ensure that the excess wealth created is ploughed back into the nation’s economy for the next year. This will inflate the nation’s wealth and subsequently get added onto the common wealth pool (UGNRP) of the next year.

This will ensure further dis-incentivization for unplanned and unwanted economic growth, and ensure re-distribution of created wealth.

For example, consider the table below for the year 2010 (base year)

Table 67 presents the excess growth and decision for the base year 2010.

Table 67. Excess growth and decision for the base year 2010.
DIFFERENCE (GDP-mean GDP) 2010 DIFFERENCE (GDP-mean GDP) 2010 DECISION EXCESS GROWTH
DIFFERENCE (GDP-mean GDP) 2010 DIFFERENCE (GDP-mean GDP) 2010 DECISION EXCESS GROWTH
USA 13984411 INJECT 13984411
CHINA 5120659 INJECT 5120659
JAPAN 4720137 INJECT 4720137
GERMANY 2437134 INJECT 2437134
UNITED KINGDOM 1449719 INJECT 1449719
INDIA 676656 INJECT 676656
FRANCE 1666876 INJECT 1666876
BRAZIL 1228911 INJECT 1228911
ITALY 1145097 INJECT 1145097
CANADA 633503 INJECT 633503
RUSSIA 544955 INJECT 544955
Rep of KOREA 114538 INJECT 114538
AUSTRALIA 162916 INJECT 162916
SPAIN 451627 INJECT 451627
INDONESIA -224867 - 0
MEXICO 71168 INJECT 71168
TURKEY -208084 - 0
NETHERLANDS -143571 - 0
SAUDI ARABIA -451754 - 0
SWITZERLAND -398752 - 0

The decision for the next consecutive year (2011) for the nations is as tabulated below:

Table 68 presents the revised GNRP for 2011.

Table 68. Revised GNRP for 2011.
nation/economy 2011 GNRP (O) DECISION EXCESS GDP REVISED GNRP
USA 177775 INJECT 13984411 14162186
CHINA 56170547 INJECT 5120659 61291206
JAPAN 67664 INJECT 4720137 4787801
GERMANY 73310 INJECT 2437134 2510443
UNITED KINGDOM 42232 INJECT 1449719 1491951
INDIA 758041 INJECT 676656 1434697
FRANCE 10473 INJECT 1666876 1677349
BRAZIL 402200 INJECT 1228911 1631110
ITALY 17829 INJECT 1145097 1162926
CANADA 40664 INJECT 633503 674168
RUSSIA 1455942 INJECT 544955 2000897
Rep of KOREA 51551 INJECT 114538 166089
AUSTRALIA 6258 INJECT 162916 169174
SPAIN 54420 INJECT 451627 506046
INDONESIA 29905 - 0 29905
MEXICO 526477 INJECT 71168 597645
TURKEY 85773 - 0 85773
NETHERLANDS 1486 - 0 1486
SAUDI ARABIA 14289 - 0 14289
SWITZERLAND 963 - 0 963

…where GNRP (O) is the original GNRP for the year 2011, and the Revised GNRP is the sum of GNRP (O) and the excess GDP is previous year (2010) for that nation.

Similarly, the data for the year 2011 for excess growth is tabulated below:

Table 69 presents the excess growth and decision for 2011.

Table 69. Excess growth and decision for 2011.
DIFFERENCE (GDP-mean GDP) 2011 DIFFERENCE (GDP-mean GDP) 2011 DECISION EXCESS GROWTH
DIFFERENCE (GDP-mean GDP) 2011 DIFFERENCE (GDP-mean GDP) 2011 DECISION EXCESS GROWTH
USA 14429659 INJECT 14429659
CHINA 6484288 INJECT 6484288
JAPAN 5069193 INJECT 5069193
GERMANY 2669432 INJECT 2669432
UNITED KINGDOM 1520558 INJECT 1520558
INDIA 734783 INJECT 734783
FRANCE 1774414 INJECT 1774414
BRAZIL 1527935 INJECT 1527935
ITALY 1188026 INJECT 1188026
CANADA 700381 INJECT 700381
RUSSIA 943502 INJECT 943502
Rep of KOREA 114197 INJECT 114197
AUSTRALIA 302291 INJECT 302291
SPAIN 399751 INJECT 399751
INDONESIA -195297 - 0
MEXICO 82921 INJECT 82921
TURKEY -255720 - 0

Derived data for revised GNRP for subsequent year (2013) is as tabulated below:

Table 70 presents the revised GNRP for 2013.

Table 70. Revised GNRP for 2013.
nation/economy 2013 GNRP (O) DECISION EXCESS GDP REVISED GNRP GDP
USA 189010 INJECT 15044042 15233052 16691517
CHINA 55155726 INJECT 7449334 62605060 9607224
JAPAN 51297 INJECT 5092000 5143297 5155717
GERMANY 72689 INJECT 2432771 2505460 3752514
UNITED KINGDOM 39016 INJECT 1534790 1573805 2719509
INDIA 795743 INJECT 716425 1512168 1856722
FRANCE 9475 INJECT 1570203 1579678 2808511
BRAZIL 419054 INJECT 1353976 1773029 2472807
ITALY 16033 INJECT 961610 977643 2130491
CANADA 50996 INJECT 713076 764072 1842628

The data for excess growth for the year 2013 is tabulated below:

Table 71 presents the excess growth and decision for 2013.

Table 71. Excess growth and decision for 2013.
DIFFERENCE (GDP-mean GDP) 2013 DIFFERENCE (GDP-mean GDP) 2013 DECISION EXCESS GROWTH
DIFFERENCE (GDP-mean GDP) 2013 DIFFERENCE (GDP-mean GDP) 2013 DECISION EXCESS GROWTH
USA 15550527 INJECT 15550527
CHINA 8466234 INJECT 8466234
JAPAN 4014727 INJECT 4014727
GERMANY 2611524 INJECT 2611524
UNITED KINGDOM 1578520 INJECT 1578520
INDIA 715732 INJECT 715732
FRANCE 1667521 INJECT 1667521
BRAZIL 1331817 INJECT 1331817
ITALY 989501 INJECT 989501
CANADA 701638 INJECT 701638

Corresponding data for revised GNRP for subsequent year (2014) is as tabulated below:

Table 72 presents the revised GNRP for 2014.

Table 72. Revised GNRP for 2014.
nation/economy 2014 GNRP (O) DECISION EXCESS GDP REVISED GNRP
USA 184761 INJECT 15550527 15735288
CHINA 51525965 INJECT 8466234 59992199
JAPAN 47724 INJECT 4014727 4062451
GERMANY 73086 INJECT 2611524 2684610
UNITED KINGDOM 42337 INJECT 1578520 1620857
INDIA 758385 INJECT 715732 1474117
FRANCE 9921 INJECT 1667521 1677442
BRAZIL 400427 INJECT 1331817 1732244
ITALY 17296 INJECT 989501 1006797
CANADA 63986 INJECT 701638 765624

Note: The figures in yellow highlight are derived from historical data due to non-availability of actual data.

13Forecasting the equilibrium point

The difference between UGNRP and UGDP (UGNRP – UGDP) is tabulated below:

Table 73 presents the difference between UGNRP and UGDP (USD mn).

Table 73. Difference between UGNRP and UGDP (USD mn).
YEAR UGNRP UGDP Difference
2010 52005948 62717503 -10711555
2011 95361804 69649058 25712746
2012 90726738 71117633 19609105
2013 99033324 73023357 26009967
2014 96082237 73850628 22231609

(Note: all values in USD mn)

13.1Stage a: trend analysis

The trend in difference between UGNRP and UGDP is presented graphically below:

Figure 7 shows the trend of variation in the difference between UGNRP and UGDP (2010–2014).

Trend of variation in the difference between UGNRP and UGDP (2010–2014).
Figure 7. Trend of variation in the difference between UGNRP and UGDP (2010–2014).

Trend of variation in UGDP and UGNRP is tabulated below and also presented graphically:

Table 74 presents the trend of variation in UGDP and UGNRP (USD mn).

Table 74. Trend of variation in UGDP and UGNRP (USD mn).
52005948 < 62717503
UGNRP (Revised) vs UGDP (Act) 2011 UGNRP (Revised) vs UGDP (Act) 2011 UGNRP (Revised) vs UGDP (Act) 2011
95361804 > 69649058
UGNRP (Revised) vs UGDP (Act) 2012 UGNRP (Revised) vs UGDP (Act) 2012 UGNRP (Revised) vs UGDP (Act) 2012
90726738 > 71117633
UGNRP (Revised) vs UGDP (Act) 2013 UGNRP (Revised) vs UGDP (Act) 2013 UGNRP (Revised) vs UGDP (Act) 2013
99033324 > 73023357
UGNRP (Revised) vs UGDP (Act) 2014 UGNRP (Revised) vs UGDP (Act) 2014 UGNRP (Revised) vs UGDP (Act) 2014
96082237 > 73850628

(values in USD mn)

Figure 8 shows the trend of variation in UGNRP, UGDP and their difference (2010–2014).

Trend of variation in UGNRP, UGDP and their difference (2010–2014).
Figure 8. Trend of variation in UGNRP, UGDP and their difference (2010–2014).

13.2Stage b: forecast analysis

The GDP (nominal as well as PPP) forecast as per StatisticsTimes.com for the year 2017 and 2022 is as tabulated below:

Table 75 presents the GDP forecast (nominal and PPP) for 2017 and 2022.

Table 75. GDP forecast (nominal and PPP) for 2017 and 2022.
Country/Economy GDP Nominal (billions of $) GDP Nominal (billions of $) GDP PPP (billions of Int. $) GDP PPP (billions of Int. $) PPP/ Nom
Country/Economy 2017 2022 2017 2022 PPP/ Nom
World 77,988 99,956 126,688 168,202 1.624

Based on the growth rate calculated above, the cumulative GNRP for the sample size of 64 nations (UGNRP) is calculated for the year 2017 (97027202 USD mn).

Accordingly, the difference between the UGDP forecast and the derived UGNRP for the year 2017 is calculated as 22450256 USD mn.

Table 76 presents the difference between UGDP forecast and derived UGNRP for 2017.

Table 76. Difference between UGDP forecast and derived UGNRP for 2017.
YEAR UGDP (USD mn) UGNRP (USD mn) Difference
2014 73850628 96082237 22231609
2017 74576946 97027202 22450256
Growth Rate 1.0098 (forecast) (forecast)

The final aim of the research is to achieve zero difference between UGDP and UGNRP values, projected for the year 2022. The Forecast Table for 2017 and 2022 is presented below:

Table 77 presents the forecast of UGDP and UGNRP.

Table 77. Forecast of UGDP and UGNRP.
YEAR DIFF (USD MN)
2010 -10711555
2011 25712746
2012 19609105
2013 26009967
2014 22231609
2015
2016
2017 22450256
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022 0
Forecast

The Trend Analysis based on the forecast can be graphically depicted as follows:

Figure 9 shows the moving average trend of the difference between UGNRP and UGDP.

Moving average trend of the difference between UGNRP and UGDP.
Figure 9. Moving average trend of the difference between UGNRP and UGDP.

Figure 10 shows the linear trend of the difference between UGNRP and UGDP.

Linear trend of the difference between UGNRP and UGDP.
Figure 10. Linear trend of the difference between UGNRP and UGDP.

13.3Stage c: projections

The Projected values of UGDP and UGNRP for the year 2022 based on the derived growth rate are as follows:

Table 78 presents the projected values of UGDP and UGNRP for 2022.

Table 78. Projected values of UGDP and UGNRP for 2022.
Projected UGDP 2022 95287011 Projected UGDP Projected UGDP 95287011
Current UGDP 2014 73850628 Projected UGNRP Projected UGNRP 72812695
Rate of Growth 29.0%
Current UGNRP 2014 56432279
Projected UGNRP 2022 72812695

In order to achieve the target of “Zero difference” between UGNRP and UGDP, there are two ways that can be adopted

Method 1: UGDP value in 2022 equals the UGNRP value: Economic growth (UGDP) is planned first; natural resources are utilized to match this value. The natural resources extracted for economic growth must have an economic potential equal to a fixed growth plan.

In other words, Projected UGDP = UGNRP = 95287011 USD mn.

Method 2: UGNRP in year 2022 must be equal to the planned UGDP value: UGNRP value is determined first, the economic activity is planned and achieved accordingly. Economic Growth (UGDP) must be planned, regulated, and monitored in such a way as to equal the Economic Potential expected at the beginning of the economic cycle.

i.e. UGDP = Projected UGNRP = 72812695 USD mn

Method 1: In the first instance, the forecast table for UGDP (95287 USD bn) will be as follows:

Table 79 presents the forecast of UGDP towards USD 95,287 bn (method 1).

Table 79. Forecast of UGDP towards USD 95,287 bn (method 1).
YEAR UGDP (USD bn)
2010 62718
2011 69649
2012 71118
2013 73023
2014 73851
2015
2016
2017 74577
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022 95287

Graphically, this can be depicted as follows:

The Moving average trend towards UGDP 95287 USD bn is depicted below:

Figure 11 shows the moving average trend of UGDP towards USD 95,287 bn.

Moving average trend of UGDP towards USD 95,287 bn.
Figure 11. Moving average trend of UGDP towards USD 95,287 bn.

Linear trend towards UGDP 95287 USD bn is depicted below:

Figure 12 shows the linear trend of UGDP towards USD 95,287 bn.

Linear trend of UGDP towards USD 95,287 bn.
Figure 12. Linear trend of UGDP towards USD 95,287 bn.

Method 2: In the second instance, the forecast table for UGNRP (72813 USD bn) is as follows:

Table 80 presents the forecast of UGNRP towards USD 72,813 bn (method 2).

Table 80. Forecast of UGNRP towards USD 72,813 bn (method 2).
YEAR UGNRP (USD bn) YEAR UGNRP (USD bn)
2010 52006 2017 97027
2011 95362 2018
2012 90727 2019
2013 99033 2020
2014 96082 2021
2015 2022 72813
2016

Graphically, this can be depicted as follows:

Moving average trend towards UGNRP 72813 USD bn is depicted below:

Figure 13 shows the moving average trend of UGNRP towards USD 72,813 bn.

Moving average trend of UGNRP towards USD 72,813 bn.
Figure 13. Moving average trend of UGNRP towards USD 72,813 bn.

Linear trend towards UGNRP 72813 USD bn is depicted below:

Figure 14 shows the linear trend of UGNRP towards USD 72,813 bn.

Linear trend of UGNRP towards USD 72,813 bn.
Figure 14. Linear trend of UGNRP towards USD 72,813 bn.

13.4Stage d: interpretation of the results

Thus, in order to plan for achieving the Economic-Environmental Equilibrium point in the year 2022, we have two scenarios:

(1) UGDP value in 2022 equals the UGNRP value: Economic growth (UGDP) is planned first, natural resources are utilized to match this value. The natural resources extracted for economic growth must have an economic potential equal to a fixed growth plan.

In other words, Projected UGDP = UGNRP = 95287011 USD mn.

(2) UGNRP in year 2022 must be equal to the planned UGDP value: UGNRP value is determined first, the economic activity is planned and achieved accordingly. Economic Growth (UGDP) must be planned, regulated, and monitored in such a way as to equal the Economic Potential expected at the beginning of the economic cycle.

i.e. UGDP = Projected UGNRP = 72812695 USD mn

Table 81 presents the difference between UGNRP and UGDP towards equilibrium.

Table 81. Difference between UGNRP and UGDP towards equilibrium.
YEAR UGNRP UGDP Difference
2010 52005948 62717503 -10711555
2011 95361804 69649058 25712746
2012 90726738 71117633 19609105
2013 99033324 73023357 26009967
2014 96082237 73850628 22231609
2015
2016
2017 97027202 74576946 22450256
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022 72812695 72812695 0
2022 95287011 95287011 0

13.4.1Conclusion

It is easier to fix the planned economic growth (UGDP) first, and utilize the natural resources (UGNRP) wealth in such a manner as to equal this planned growth. The economic activity can be controlled at micro-level for each nation, so that there is no need for extraction of natural resources in order to achieve economic growth beyond the targeted UGDP.

The trend analysis of UGDP and UGNRP in linear and moving average form can be utilized to determine the various check-points for the coming years from 2017 onwards.

At this point, we can conclude that equilibrium has been achieved.

The following results and outcomes are derived from the study:

14Interpretation of the results of the research process

The outcome can be interpreted in three different ways-

Note: An unbalanced social model undermines stability of the growth process. At equilibrium point, the GDP of the universe remains constant. There is no addition to the total intrinsic economic value of the environmental ecosystem, and there is no deletion from the human macro-economic subsystem. There is mere substitution of economic value from the natural resources to the utility-based goods for consumption. Net worth of both parameters, the total natural resources of the world, and the total finished goods for consumption, are equal in value and remain constant. At this point, sustainable growth is achieved infinitely.

15Recommendations: policy implications

Role of Government: Normally, the Government plays following three roles in economic development- provider of institutions, provider of income distribution, and promoter of economic growth. The Role of Government as a promoter of economic growth is in getting the nation into “the right business”, as a supplier of infrastructure, in providing skilled labor and entrepreneurship, creating demand, and as an Entrepreneur and Capitalist of last resort.

The research aims at more involved role for the Government in Policy Formulation, based on the decision models and Key Industry concept for economic development.

16Significance of the research study

The research is a comprehensive and all-inclusive research that adopts a holistic approach to the Economy-Ecosystem conundrum, and offers a long term sustainable solution to the problem of sustainability. The recommendations that are derived from the models are simple, workable solutions that require a developmental mindset. Economic progress based on inclusion of natural resources in growth mechanism will contribute to a better world. Greater transparency in reporting will ensure mutually beneficial growth.

Table 82 presents the comparative analysis of UGDP and UGNRP.

Table 82. Comparative analysis of UGDP and UGNRP.
Observation Interpretation Corrective Action Action Plan
UGDP > UGNRP Excess growth achieved Output must be curbed in the next business cycle i. by utilizing fewer resources ii. cut down agriculture production iii. curb population growth
UGDP < UGNRP Excess natural resources utilized Output must be curbed in the next business cycle i. Extracting fewer resources ii. cutting down excess agricultural production

Inference: Since both scenarios of inequality between UGDP and UGNRP require the same action to be undertaken, that of curbing of the utilization of natural resources and decrease in output of agricultural produce, the cyclic activity will be allowed to continue till the perfect stage of macro-constancy is reached: when UGDP equals UGNRP.

Finally, consider the universe of all the nations, for all the minerals used for economic activity, with a fixed Common Price Index kept constant (the only necessary condition for macro constancy). When the Cumulative GNRP equals the Cumulative GDP, and no more injections into the common wealth pool is required, the Economic-Environmental; Equilibrium point is considered to have been reached. When UGDP = UGNRP, it can be concluded that the utopian state of economic equilibrium and sustainability of economic-ecological ecosystem has been achieved through the continuous process of optimal resource management.

At this ideal point, the total GDP of the Universe (total Economic Energy content) remains constant, and sustainable growth can be achieved under regulated macro-constancy.

17Scope and limitations of the research

The scope of this research is ambitious enough to cover all nations of the world, and all minerals that contribute to the economic activity and growth of nations and of the world economy. The research opens up avenues for global collaboration with World Bank group, and the IMF and the UNO. The research urges to exploit the challenge for “Big Data Analytics” as a professional opportunity and for statisticians with the ability to collate humongous data for economic projects around the world.

Limitations of Research: The limitations of the research include data availability, data accuracy and data reliability, due to the very nature of the data: complex, dynamic, changing, and simply, huge. The economy of the world cannot be used as a laboratory for economic experiments, hence the approach has to be progressive, and prudent, taking into account the complex economic and socio-political structures of every nation involved.

18Managerial implications of the research

There is managerial scope in the process of Policy Formulation, both at institutional level and at Government level. The Research calls for the establishment of a global ombudsman agency to play the significant role of actualizing the recommendations of the research in the real world.

Note: The research rejects continuous institutional intervention and control, by proposing the application of mediating intervention only at the initial and final stages of global business cycle. In the interim, nations are free to pursue their individual economic policies and independent paths to achieve specific developmental goals and missions.

Figure 15 shows the tech4Good innovation framework.

Tech4Good innovation framework.
Figure 15. Tech4Good innovation framework.

Tech4Good Innovation Framework harnesses "collective intelligence". Each entity stands to benefit from the others, who fill key gaps in their own ability to deliver on social development goals.

Figure 16 shows the the 5Es framework for scaling Tech4Good: ethics, engineer, embed, enable, educate.

The 5Es framework for scaling Tech4Good: ethics, engineer, embed, enable, educate.
Figure 16. The 5Es framework for scaling Tech4Good: ethics, engineer, embed, enable, educate.

Figure 17 shows the the 5Es require synergistic coordination and collective intelligence for success.

The 5Es require synergistic coordination and collective intelligence for success.
Figure 17. The 5Es require synergistic coordination and collective intelligence for success.