Evaluation of Circulation Efficiency, Flow Patterns and User Satisfaction with Circulation Systems in Health Care Facilities in Osun State

• Author(s): Oladapo Olusola MAKINDE ; Olalere Kabir HASSAN
• Paper ID: 1709938
• Page: 29-39
• Published Date: 08-08-2025
• Published In: Iconic Research And Engineering Journals
• Publisher: IRE Journals
• e-ISSN: 2456-8880
• Volume/Issue: Volume 9 Issue 2 August-2025

Abstract

The efficiency of circulation systems in healthcare facilities significantly influences patient experience, staff productivity, and overall service delivery. In Osun State, Nigeria, where rural healthcare infrastructure is often outdated and under-resourced, poorly designed circulation patterns contribute to delays, congestion, and low user satisfaction. This study evaluates circulation efficiency, flow patterns, and user satisfaction across selected general and state hospitals in Osun State to identify critical spatial and operational gaps. The study addresses a pressing need to improve healthcare design and delivery in rural Nigerian contexts, where research has historically focused on urban centers. A quantitative research approach was employed. Structured questionnaires were administered to 321 respondents (patients and healthcare staff) across six hospitals selected using stratified and purposive sampling from the state’s three senatorial districts. Responses were analyzed using descriptive statistics, mean ranking, standard deviations, and Relative Importance Index (RII) to prioritize key issues affecting circulation efficiency. Findings revealed strong alignment between patients and staff on the importance of logical departmental flow (Mean: 4.29 and 4.05; RII: 0.86 and 0.81, respectively), which ranked highest across all indicators. Both groups also valued environmental comfort, with ventilation in circulation areas scoring high (Patients’ RII: 0.76; Staff: 0.79). However, only 62% of patients were satisfied with directional signage, and 66% reported difficulties navigating congested corridors during peak hours. Significant perception gaps emerged: Patients ranked the lack of separation between staff and patient pathways second (RII: 0.77), citing concerns over privacy and cross-infection, while staff placed it 19th (RII: 0.64), showing less concern. Likewise, staff ranked circulation cleanliness 3rd (RII: 0.80), whereas patients ranked it 24th (RII: 0.57), highlighting inconsistency in perceived hygiene standards. Ingress/egress accessibility was valued more by staff (RII: 0.81) for emergency response, but less by patients (RII: 0.63). Satisfaction assessment revealed that 83% of patients found intra-department movement relatively easy (RII: 0.79), while 71% of staff indicated that poor flow patterns significantly delayed service delivery (RII: 0.56). Both groups moderately agreed that current layouts support workflow and reduce stress (RII: 0.69 for patients, 0.68 for staff). In conclusion, the study highlights the critical need for improved circulation design to enhance user satisfaction and operational efficiency in Osun State healthcare facilities. Priorities include optimizing space layouts, reducing cross-traffic delays, improving accessibility, and integrating inclusive, well-ventilated circulation paths. These findings offer actionable insights for healthcare designers, planners, and policymakers aiming to create functional, patient-centered environments in rural healthcare settings, ultimately promoting better health outcomes and equitable access to care.

Keywords

Circulation Efficiency, Flow Patterns, User Satisfaction, Healthcare Design Rural Healthcare Facilities

Citations

IRE Journals:
Oladapo Olusola MAKINDE , Olalere Kabir HASSAN "Evaluation of Circulation Efficiency, Flow Patterns and User Satisfaction with Circulation Systems in Health Care Facilities in Osun State" Iconic Research And Engineering Journals Volume 9 Issue 2 2025 Page 29-39

IEEE:
Oladapo Olusola MAKINDE , Olalere Kabir HASSAN "Evaluation of Circulation Efficiency, Flow Patterns and User Satisfaction with Circulation Systems in Health Care Facilities in Osun State" Iconic Research And Engineering Journals, 9(2)